8 ms·
Windows 11 update added 'Search' label to taskbar search button – how to remove?
- account-5 4y agoGlad I'm immune to this sort of thing!
- sebazzz 4y agoInteresting how other OS can get away with it, but Windows must always stay thre same.
- mort96 4y agoAll OSes (or applications for that matter) will get flack when they waste the most valuable screen realestate unnecessarily in a non-configurable way. It seems to be one of the most common complaints about UI redesigns I see.
- PascLeRasc 4y agoAlmost like Microsoft can only make UIs worse.
- butz 4y agoTry "format c:".
- 2143 4y agoWhat does it search for? Things already on your computer? The web? > how to remove? Consider switching to Linux.
- livinglist 4y agoI grew up using windows until I got myself a MacBook for college. I’m now a heavy Mac user, I enjoy using the Magic Trackpad (so much so that I barely have touched a mouse in the last five years), copying something on my phone and pasting it on my Mac with barely any delay, sharing stuff using Airdrop, not having to worry about virus most of the time, and the consistency of user experience.
- timbit42 4y agoKDE Connect can do that.
- userbinator 4y agoIt's ironic that they still haven't restored the option to have labels for the other buttons, but will add this absolutely useless unremovable label instead.
- samoit 4y agoEven in the case you could remove it, it would probably be reinstated the next update. If it is not software dependant I will try linux and remove Windows completely
- Drakim 4y agoCan somebody explain this to me? When Microsoft adds something like this, to the very valuable visual prime real estate taskbar, which is always visible at all times, why do they not include the option to remove it? Do they simply not think about it, or is it a cold calculated choice in order to promote use of the new feature?
- secondcoming 4y agoAndroid has as unremovable Search bar that can't be removed. At least, I can't figure out how to get rid of it. I never use it.
- agluszak 4y agoThere's no single "Android" OS in the same sense as Windows. Do you mean AOSP? You can edit the source code and remove it yourself.
- tbillington 4y ago> edit the source code and remove it yourself That is not a realistic option.
- drkhn1234 4y ago
- rentnorove 4y agoThat search bar's part of the home screen app, which you can replace. Search for 'launcher' on the play store.
- millzlane 4y agoThe other launchers were always more feature rich compared to the launchers that come with some phones. I love having everything and the kitchen sink in case I need it.
- YeGoblynQueenne 4y ago>> Can't you right-click the Taskbar > Taskbar settings and set Search to Off? – harrymc Nov 12 at 10:07 A drastic solution, for sure.
- Semaphor 4y agoUse a taskbar replacement. I use StartAllBack [0] because unlike the Windows devs, I use my monitors in landscape mode (sassy way of saying it gives you a vertical taskbar). It’s not free (not even as in beer, cheap and a one-time payment though), but it’s the only one that did what I wanted. If you are okay with a horizontal taskbar, there are even FLOSS tools. [0]: https://www.startallback.com/ https://www.startallback.com/
- phreack 4y agoIt's sad because I liked Windows, but at this point if they keep doing this stuff I'd rather change the OS than the task bar. I still get all sorts of hardware and driver trouble that require arcane commands buried in old forums to fix, but Windows' UX is getting so much worse every update.
- Semaphor 4y agoBesides being very much in love with a bunch of Windows-only programs, I also work on .NET Framework (from before cross-platform times) apps, so I’d need to dual-boot anyway.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- usrusr 4y agoI'm on https://github.com/valinet/ExplorerPatcher https://github.com/valinet/ExplorerPatcher to make 11 bearable, but it's a bit of a rough ride every time an update hits. First time ever I went through with a "donate" link on some software, that's how bad 11 is!
- Semaphor 4y agoThanks to using Directory Opus [0] as my explorer replacement for 1.5 decades by now, I got never hit by the explorer annoyances ;) [0]: https://www.gpsoft.com.au/ https://www.gpsoft.com.au/
- nailer 4y agoJust a note that search indexer will still make your computer unusable when it kicks in, even on a Microsoft Surface device, as it has for the last twenty years. I gave it another try with this last update thinking they’d maybe worked on the backend, but:nope.
- tiffanyh 4y agoCan you not just completely remove the Search widget from the dock? And instead just use WinKey+F as a keyboard shortcut.
- satysin 4y agoYou can still remove Search from the dock in Settings\Personalisation\Taskbar
- 2Gkashmiri 4y agoi am on kde so this is never a concern for me. anything and everything is customizable because they believe their users should be given a choice. compared that to apple/gnome (i even read in an old apple design magazine/books that users are stupid and should not be given choice to change the "design") but this is trying to move towards that but then you "still" have an option to change the taskbar with a third party one so windows is still not apple like yet.... the problem is, i choose apple, i know i am getting into a walled garden where people are expected to follow the way apple wants them to. kde is on the opposite end. Windows until win7 at least or as late as win10 was more towards kde than apple but it is trying to transition.... the problem is, people who use windows "expect" windows to be customizable and that is giving them grief. i'd stay people are having trouble adjusting to the Microsoft vision of moving to the apple side (because of actual nefarious purpose at least)
- kehrin 4y agoJudging by the screenshot, both the text and search icon aren't even centered correctly :(
- brarsanmol 4y agoWhy does Microsoft make these pointless UI changes? Instead of migrating over existing UI's in the rest of the operating system that use Aero, Windows 10, and even Windows 98... I know that there are probably different teams for the Shell, and each app but I would hope that there would be a person that drives the overall "vision" of the Operating System.
- gumboza 4y agoI have concluded that the overall vision of Microsoft is entirely telemetry data driven and the data is shite.
- 323 4y agoFunnily enough, on this actual web page (superuser) you have at the top a search box prefilled with the "Search on Super User..." place holder. Windows is not Linux, you can't customize every bit of text you see on screen. Every Windows instance kind of looks and behaves like every other one. For some that's actually a good thing, some people just want to get work done instead of spending days customizing every little pixel on the screen.
- Karunamon 4y agoThat's an argument for sane defaults, not removal of all ability to customize.
- ht85 4y agoFor a sec I thought you were asking how to remove Windows
- appstorelottery 4y agoI removed the search text-box by right clicking on the task bar, this brought up the Personalisation>Taskbar settings menu. The top item under Taskbar Items is search, toggle the switch from on to off. As a side-note, I'm in EU, so perhaps you don't have this option in other regions?
- judge2020 4y agoThis is also available on my W11 Pro machine in the US. 22H2.
- unsafecast 4y agoThat works, but the issue was to remove the label on the text box, not the box itself.
- zeta0134 4y agoIn Windows 10 at least, if you remove the Search box / icon, you can still access search by typing while the start menu is open. This means you can quite easily search from the keyboard alone by first hitting [Win] to open the menu, then typing a query. If the result is a program, hitting [Enter] then launches it. Does this not work in Windows 11?
- unsafecast 4y agoIt does! You lose no functionality by removing it. I just wanted to clarify what the issue was.
- judge2020 4y agoIt does, but I suppose the Superuser post is really against the text "Search" being there. At a certain point it's unrealistic to expect configuration, even in registry etc, to be able to customize every little part of the UI. Even if it's 10 lines defining the registry state and checking it when the OS is pulling the search text, it's debt that only a handful of users will be annoyed by enough to go change.
- karmakaze 4y agoOn the subject, is there any compelling reason to use Windows 11 rather than Windows 10? My plan is to use Windows 10 as long as it's supported, then stop using Windows altogether which is already only for games. Then I can hopefully use a Steam Deck or a future 'Steam PC'. I can see how MS might consider Windows to matter less with their infrastructure/services business, but anything that keeps users on Windows rather than switch to the Apple ecosystem has to be worth the effort to make Windows suck less rather than cashing out. I'm trying to see the long term strategy and it might be making MS an open-source services company around .NET (and a Linux distribution) along with proprietary cloud and apps (SharePoint etc).
- Havoc 4y agoI believe the direct storage implementation on 11 is faster than 10, so gamers looking for every last FPS might switch. I'm personally hoping steam/proton/anti-cheat etc improves so that I can dump the entire mess...
- alkonaut 4y agoI upgraded and can’t see why they even gave it a new number. Feels like some past Win10 upgrades were similarly large. Apart from some cosmetic changes I have no opinion on, a few new and changed features (mostly good), the biggest difference I see is the new explorer context menu which is awful since you 98% of the time need an extra click to reach the item you need. But apart from that, it feels like a solid version. Just the usual hardware support improvements alone make it an acceptable upgrade. It also feels slightly more clever in the MacOS way when it comes to switching between audio devices etc.
- fuzzfactor 4y ago>I upgraded and can’t see why they even gave it a new number. The latest W11 is still obviously Windows 10 version 10.0.22621.1037, and that's on the beta channel where the comment is "Updated the search box on the taskbar with more rounded corners."
- ajdude 4y ago> I upgraded and can’t see why they even gave it a new number My theory is that MS never expected macOS to stop being OSX (version 10) and once Apple came out with MacOS 11, Microsoft had to follow suit.
- forgotusername6 4y agoOutlook made a similarly annoying UI change recently, moving the nav items to the left side and taking up the full height of the screen. Thankfully there was an advanced setting to turn it off.
- NDizzle 4y agoTo search in Windows, click the start button (or hotkey for start) and simply start typing. I’ve never seen the need for the search box or button, label or no label.
- alerighi 4y agoInstall Linux
- joe91 4y agoBoth KDE and Gnome seem to have the text "Search" in their search boxes too (Gnome is an even worse choice, it has "Type to search" in its search box)
- uses 4y agoPersonally I’d like to hover over the weather widget without seeing tabloid and politics headlines. There doesn’t seem to be any way to remove them.
- PascLeRasc 4y agoLast time I mentioned this here I was condescended to that this is a group policy setting. I'm not allowed to change them or request a change, but maybe you can.
- thesuperbigfrog 4y ago>> Personally I’d like to hover over the weather widget without seeing tabloid and politics headlines. But then how will MSN News drive up their engagement metrics?
- gumboza 4y agoWindows is just a burning trash heap at this point. I hate every moment of using it when I have to. How they can use the "professional" moniker with a straight face I don't know. It's a shame because it could be better if they actually stopped the marketoids and CXO class from interfering in the product engineering decisions.
- wheelerof4te 4y agoIt's a MS product, and if they want a "Search" label, they are free to add it. Either don't use an MS OS (there are at least two alternatives) or stop complaining about trivial things.
- CogitoCogito 4y ago> It's a MS product, and if they want a "Search" label, they are free to add it. > Either don't use an MS OS (there are at least two alternatives) or stop complaining about trivial things. Are you seriously arguing that entirely switching OSs is the correct approach to solving this as opposed to asking how to remove the undesired behavior? Are you totally against individual customization of a user’s OS or sonething?
- timbit42 4y agoMicrosoft is. KDE lets you configure so much more.
- chapium 4y agoThis is all really subjective of course, but I dislike that that start button is small, search is big, and then applications are small again. However, perhaps eliminating the start button is in the future? Move the search button in place of the start button and its quite pleasing, to me at least.
- willsoon 4y agomfw.jpg
- _a_a_a_ 4y agoI have to use windows for work but hate MS and want to move to linux at home at least. I did some f/oss work that needed unix, installed Ubuntu on a spare box, picked gnome - and it was horrible. Big, clunky, so much weird user-hostile behaviour, superficially slick visually but not good for workflow, and bugs... Windows has a lot of polish (which they are destroying) but I can't consider gnome again. Are there any alternatives anyone knows of that are user friendly, reliable, don't keep hiding options...? I'd really like to move off windows but so far it doesn't feel like I can.
- bitigchi 4y agoKDE is your friend. Customisable to the last bit.
- yyyk 4y agoI've always been happy with KDE. KDE/Wayland still has a few rather unfortunately bugs, so if you go that way it's better to stick with X for now.
- kinghtown 4y agoHave you looked at KDE Plasma? I personally don’t like it because it looks and acts too much like Windows but it’s probably what you’re looking for. I use Gnome myself because I like the hot corners, and I like it well enough but I’m currently trying to figure out AwesomeWM. I did borrow some of the shortcut ideas from it for gnome like windows key + enter for a console.
- _a_a_a_ 4y agoTo be clear, it's not about how it looks or acts - I flip between emacs and visual studio and they are utterly different for example - I need an interface that a) isn't buggy and b) is designed by people who understand a GUI isn't an end in itself but a means for someone to get their work done. I need both and gnome... wasn't it.
- Corazoor 4y ago
- dbg31415 4y agoI really liked Windows 10. Like I honestly felt like Microsoft had gotten their head out of their ass and started trying to build a good product again. Sure, you had to use O&O ShutUp (1) and block ads via hosts table (2) and turn off DNS Caching (3) or it would take like 10 minutes to find your internet connection again every time you re-booted... but I felt like they were going in the right direction, and I could mute all the crap I hated. And then Windows 11 came out. And it has zilch in the way of any new features, and they keep pushing more and more of the annoying crap. Like a "search" button that forces Bing, and weather than forces Bing, and "online" that forces Teams and whatever else. And you can turn stuff off, for the most part... But I just feel like they're constantly trying to find new ways to spam their crap on me, and force their other products or services -- many of which I've already told them numerous times I hate. I hate Bing. I hate Teams. I hate all that schlock they're peddling. And they keep making it more pervasive, and harder to turn off. And look, there's no UX improvements I enjoy, there's no features I need... Windows 11, and all of Microsoft's new features for Windows are just garbage. And it was hard to install, I had to do some hacky stuff to get my motherboard to spoof some settings so I could even put Windows 11 on what was at the time a 2-year-old computer. If I had one wish for Microsoft, it would be to stop trying to sell me things via the OS. Just build a good OS, and stop all the other crap. It's not making me say, "Gosh, I love all your new features!" It's making me actively look for alternatives. (1) https://www.oo-software.com/en/shutup10 https://www.oo-software.com/en/shutup10 (2) https://github.com/StevenBlack/hosts https://github.com/StevenBlack/hosts (3) https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/answers/questions/47441/how-to-disable-windows-10-dns-cache-services.html https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/answers/questions/47441/ho...
- canistel 4y agoWhen, pray when, would ReactOS go beta? Or am I a dreamy fool to look forward to that day?
- jeditobe 4y agoSoon ^) If you contribute then sooner! https://twitter.com/reactos https://twitter.com/reactos follow to see the progress
- sonicgear1 4y agoCheck out windhawk. https://windhawk.net/ https://windhawk.net/