5 ms·
Not really. Android's "openness" doesn't include the ability to actually modify the software running on your device, which means that on its own it's useless to
by makomk 15y ago
Not really. Android's "openness" doesn't include the ability to actually modify the software running on your device, which means that on its own it's useless to everyone except hardware manufacturers. It's only on the rare occasions when those manufacturers actually choose to do more than is required on them and open up their hardware to modifications that "openness" is of any value at all.
- veidr 15y ago> doesn't include the ability to actually modify the software running on your device OK, I am uncomfortable with my weird position in this thread as the Android Avenger (especially seeing as how I don't even use Android except to fuck around), so I apologize in advance for the breakdown in my civility function. However: ARE YOU FUCKING HIGH ON FIRE? YOU CAN COMPILE YOUR OWN MOTHERFUCKING (HACKED) ANDROID AND INSTALL IT ON YOUR OWN MOTHERFUCKING PHONE. FOR INSTANCE: http://www.droid-life.com/2011/12/20/variety-of-android-4-0-3-roms-already-available-for-the-galaxy-nexus-lte/ http://www.droid-life.com/2011/12/20/variety-of-android-4-0-...
- drivebyacct2 15y agoI don't really get what you're saying here. Some Android devices have locked bootloaders, but that doesn't affect the openness of AOSP. If anything, you're making an argument for GPLv3 which would require Android OEM's to allow for open bootloaders and (S-OFF (htc)). But I can assure you, my Galaxy Nexus is running a CM9 alpha that I built from source last night.
- ootachi 15y agoReplace "some Android devices" with "the vast majority of Android devices". That is Marco's point.
- drivebyacct2 15y agoAll HTC devices since September, most devices from <=2010 (and many, many more with community support); all Samsung/LG devices; some early Moto devices (and all if you don't count the kernel via the community) can have custom software installed. And if that's Marco's point, it's pretty damn poor. How does what Motorola does with the bootloader of their phone have to do with the code that Google puts out exactly?
- ootachi 15y agoAs has been explained many times in the past, Android's relative openness compared to iOS at the source code level does not translate to measurable benefits for the majority of users because of carrier/manufacturer lockdown. Rooting is a security exploit, and I don't consider it relevant to whether the OS is practically open.
- drivebyacct2 15y agoNow you're just shifting around your position. I thought it was about the unlocked nature of bootloaders? Yes, in my last post I included some that require "root" but, #1, not all of those root methods are through user-facing security exploits, and #2, most of them allow custom software out of the box from the manufacturer (specifically without rooting or really any work at all), I noted the ones that require "community" support. Your characterization is disingenuous. Now it's about the openness at the source code level? I think you should look up the CM statistics. There is a measurable percentage (or may tenth of a percent) of Android users that run custom software, so I benefit from that. I and others will only buy devices that will have CM support. Further, the open nature of Android absolutely trickles down to the users. There are a dozen different (and with different physical form factor) Android models that are free on contract to buy. There is only one WP7 that I'm aware of that that is true for. Lower development costs are passed on to users, I've discussed this further somewhere else on this thread.