5 ms·
> Perhaps she could move to Frankfurt am Main, one of the world's most important financial centers? No, James said. Germany is out of the question. To find a jo
by rayiner 4y ago
> Perhaps she could move to Frankfurt am Main, one of the world's most important financial centers? No, James said. Germany is out of the question. To find a job, you need to learn the German language, which is difficult. "Aside from that, Germany is also rather strict with issuing visas. And I have heard that the Germans are quite harsh toward people with brown skin, and to immigrants in general."
I really don't know what Europe is going to do over the next century. These countries are homogenous in a way that's difficult for Americans to comprehend. Forget "white" versus "brown"--Germany is 86% ethnic German. It's one specific tribe of white people with a flag. It's been almost half a century since Germany began a family reunification program for Turkish immigrants, and the Turkish population still hasn't assimilated, much less reached parity with native Germans. (Meanwhile, in the same amount of time, multiple refugee groups, such as Cubans and Vietnamese, have achieved economic parity with whites in America.)
I love Germany and Germans. My wife is a fluent German speaker and lived there. We have had several German au pairs who are now family friends. I have family in Frankfurt who immigrated there from Bangladesh, and they seem to be doing okay. But personally I would never immigrate there.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoWell, the natives aren’t reproducing really, so the next century is collapse before they have to assimilate. The only constant in nature is change.
- throwaway74829 4y ago"America" is in the unique position of having no culture -- barring "make money" -- to assimilate to. This obviously leads to much greater ease of assimilation for immigrants; you don't even need to speak English. If you can achieve an upper middle class income, you have assimilated and are thus dubbed "American." In Europe, it's much different. There's no "short cut" to being accepted in your host society; and I very much doubt anyone really assimilates into a European culture if they're not born within. There's a depth to it that is impossible to grasp unless you've been submerged in it for the entirety of your life. You will never be a German. Should you decide to change your mind, and make the decision to move to and have children there -- then perhaps they will end up being German; but that path is closed to the individual you. Accepting people is a long process when your standards are high; and short when low. Letting people come and go as they please does not make for a very stable society, filled with the types of persons that are beneficial to the whole.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoWe have all the cultures, whether that means they all cancel out on average is up for debate;)
- noworriesnate 4y ago> "America" is in the unique position of having no culture -- barring "make money" -- to assimilate to Which part of America are you from? America where I live absolutely has culture. Where I live this means things like sacred harp, country dances (contra, waltzes, English country, buck, etc.), bluegrass fiddle music, southern cooking (okra, smoked corn on the cob, etc.). Hollywood would have you believe we have no culture but we actually do.
- triceratops 4y agoIronic considering Hollywood and its popularity is emblematic of how popular American culture actually is.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- throwaway74829 4y agoNone of that is culture -- unless you apply it in a shallow way. The South is a cultural wasteland. The only thing it has going for it are its manners.
- klipt 4y agoA cautionary tale: after living in Germany for generations, German Jews thought they were pretty well assimilated. The rest, as they say, is history.
- rayiner 4y agoNot just Germany. Jews across Europe, for example in Poland, had lived harmoniously with their neighbors for hundreds of years until their neighbors turned on them. When times get difficult, there’s really no telling what can happen. As I was telling my dad the other day, it’s nice as Bangladeshis that we have an ethnostate we can always return to.
- lmz 4y ago> As I was telling my dad the other day, it’s nice as Bangladeshis that we have an ethnostate we can always return to. Does this extend to others too? Is it maybe best to make Germany an Ethnostate so when they are thrown out of some other country they have some place to return to?
- klipt 4y agoAlready happened, the Soviets expelled German minorities from Eastern Europe, and East Germany absorbed them. Of course, that expulsion was mostly because Germany invaded Eastern Europe in the first place.
- xyzzyz 4y agoThe expelled German Russians had little to do with the invading Nazi Germans.
- type0 4y agoYou probably mean Russian Germans like Volga Germans https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volga_Germans#Deportation_and_genocide_of_the_Germans_from_USSR https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volga_Germans#Deportation_and_...
- BlargMcLarg 4y agoI have a hard time believing homogeneity is the most important factor. Cities are expensive in Europe and rural life isn't exactly popular among expats. Now take your pick between Europe, struggling to keep native talent over finances, using tax breaks for expats to win them over and causing bad blood among its citizens, their own country, or some other rich first world country. The most common complaint in Europe is that we are emulating the US at the cost of the middle class and below.
- riedel 4y agoOnly 73% of all people living in Germany have no modern migration background. Beyond that the German nation is relatively young concept (which has proven to be problematic) and there is no homogenic population within the country. Many people rather identify with their region (which is supported by the federal structure). But it is true that we have problems Integrating migrants.
- LatteLazy 4y agoCareful: no one is more anti-immigration than people with foreign born (grand)parents and no nation is more concerned with it's state than new ones...
- rayiner 4y agoThe people with migrant background includes ethnic Germans from neighboring countries. CIA world Facebook estimates that over 85% of Germany is ethnic Germans: https://theodora.com/wfbcurrent/germany/germany_people.html https://theodora.com/wfbcurrent/germany/germany_people.html
- riedel 4y agoActually ethnic Germans also include many people who repatriated from Russia etc. (not that much neighboring). As another commenter said, more migrant population does not lead automatically to better integration.
- xyzzyz 4y agoMaybe CIA is using a looser, American notion of ethnicity, where just because born in America immediately makes you ethnic American. European people, for the most part, do not see it this way (even if their governments do).
- VK538FY 4y agoGood point. The Aussiedler represent some big numbers, are foreign born, but can loosely be considered German. I've known a lot and while not entirely representative, the criteria were loose: only adoptive father of German ancestry, last person really German and to speak German was mummy's oma, etc. Of course when you're being beat up by the locals in some ex soviet republic because you're not really one of them either, well, you do what you have to do. What surprises me are the numbers of Spanish, Italians, Poles, Hungarians. Anecdotally I would have expected bigger numbers. Germany has emptied such countries of their qualified workers in recent years.
- galadest 4y ago> Forget "white" versus "brown"--Germany is 86% ethnic German. This number is not entirely correct (it's more like 74% as of 2019, depending on the definition), and it's certainly way more off for larger cities or urban areas in general. You mentioned Frankfurt. Frankfurt am Main e.g. had 54.6% migrants as of 2020. Some statistics cite Germany as the country with the second most immigrants world-wide, right after the US. (for details, see e.g.: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_to_Germany https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_to_Germany https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sovereign_states_and_dependent_territories_by_immigrant_population https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sovereign_states_and_d...)
- RhysabOweyn 4y agoThat number is not really accurate though because ethnic Germans from their diaspora that ended up back in Germany post-WW2/USSR collapse are considered to have migrant background.
- onecommentman 4y agoWonder if the relative lack of a Colonial past plays a role in the German experience today. The Brits, French, Spanish, Portuguese all had a long-term personal all-class interaction with the rest of the world. The rest of the world might not have been all that pleased, but intermarriage, educational opportunities, economic investment made “the Other” (or at least some Others) acceptable and even desirable. Granted it took 100-200 years to have that happen…and the Europeans were basically living a Peace Corps experience (sometimes War Corps but still) collocated with the Natives in their Countries. That does something to a person, and thus to a society. Germans, not so much.