3 ms·
> If independent repair was widely available, products would have a longer lifespan, making them more valuable. Manufacturers would be incentivized to raise new
by bee_rider 4y ago
> If independent repair was widely available, products would have a longer lifespan, making them more valuable. Manufacturers would be incentivized to raise new product prices, which hurts consumers.
Even if this does lead to a higher price, “could this be cheaper at the cost of being more disposable” doesn’t seem like a good standard for consumer harm. If we’re paying more because we get longer-lasting more repairable products, we’ll still probably end up ahead.
> Easier repair could also lead more consumers to use old, energy-inefficient products, resulting in a higher environmental impact, especially with cars, trucks, refrigerators, or other major appliances.
Just impose carbon taxes to make sure that the ecological damage doesn’t get externalized and then let the market sort it out.
Anyway, every time we talk about replacing gas cars with electric cars, there’s a lot of worry about the embodied carbon of a new electric car. So I guess by that argument, we should prefer to keep old devices running rather than replacing them, or at least people who want to replace the old devices need to prove that the benefit of cleaner running is higher than the cost of replacing the device.
- supportlocal4h 4y agoThe idea that manufacturers would raise prices simply because a product lives longer flies in the face of Econ 100. Any time you raise prices you increase the opportunity for competition. Any improvement without raising prices gives you a competetive advantage. It may be that the longer life comes at some cost to the manufacturer. That can safely be added to the price because any competitor would also incur similar costs to add similar value. However, if the additional cost adversely affects the price per unit of life it could very well hurt the manufacturer. A $10 wrench that lasts 10 years could be perceived as a better choice than a $15 wrench that lasts 12 years. And of course it would be a better purchase than a $12 wrench that lasts 15 years for somebody who loses their wrenches about every 8 years. So single-factor Econ 100 homework might be over-simplified, but the principle should not be ignored.
- bee_rider 4y agoI would expect that, at least for companies that aren’t woefully poorly run and are in fairly competitive markets, creating more durable/repairable good will result in higher costs. I mean, if they could make a better device for less or the same amount of money, it seems they are just giving up a competitive advantage for no reason, and somebody would eat their lunch, right? But of course the consumer gets the benefit of a better device. It seems really industry specific how the pros and cons would balance out. If anyone is making predictions for how it would work out for the whole market, I’m pretty suspicious that they are overstating their level of confidence.
- snapplebobapple 4y agoIt is not industry specific though. One one side is benefit to consumers and on the other is a bunch of industry spun bs muddying the waters and tricking people into thinking there is a downside for consumers because the manufacturer's want to avoid the downside to themselves. It really is that simple.