6 ms·
With Apple, I'm the customer, not a marketer. This makes me comfortable with our relationship. I don't really care about Ping or app store approval policies,
by nostromo 15y ago
With Apple, I'm the customer, not a marketer. This makes me comfortable with our relationship. I don't really care about Ping or app store approval policies, so, meh...
With Google, I can see their ability to become a shady company pretty easily, but it is just too damn easy to switch search engines. Bing isn't so bad you know.
But Facebook knows so much about me, and the network effects are so strong -- this is the company I feel most unpleasantly stuck to. Not "Comcast stuck" mind you, but still, more "stuck" than I'd like. It's like my friends keep having parties at a bar I'm not super fond of... and I keep going.
- fauigerzigerk 15y agoApp Store policies restrict what I can put on my own device. I do care about that. Switching search engines seems pointless as they all have the same business model (maybe duckduckgo is different), but blocking all the tracking and analytics stuff solves this problem. Facebook isn't a huge problem for me either. I basically use it in read only mode, blocking them on all third party sites.
- davidedicillo 15y ago> App Store policies restrict what I can put on my own device. I do care about that. IMHO I think that's a wrong affirmation. They restrict what developer can sell through their platform. Big different. You could then complain about not allowing not approved apps on the device, but it would be like saying that Playstation or Xbox limit your freedom by not allowing Super Mario Kart run on their consoles.
- fauigerzigerk 15y agoThey restrict what developers can distribute via the App Store, at the same time mandating that the App Store be the only distribution channel. That amounts to restricting what I can install on my device (short of jailbreaking). I'm not sure I understand your Super Mario example. You seem to suggest that it's perfectly normal to face such restrictions. I can assure you it's not normal for me and I'm not going to put up with it.
- jrockway 15y agoThey do. Game consoles were the beginning of this slippery slope. Now we are at phones. Personal computers seem to be next. This is worrisome and it was worrisome before the iPhone was even a twinkle in anybody's eye.
- riffraff 15y ago> but it is just too damn easy to switch search engines. and personal email, and collaboration tools, and project mailing lists, and photo service, and maps service, and video hosting.. If you consider google as the search engine maybe not, but if you consider google the company the it's downright scary how hard it would be to get out of their grasp, IMO.
- drivebyacct2 15y agoSo? Google is "bad" because they provide a lot of really good services that are also well integrated? How dare they!
- KeithMajhor 15y agoI love Google but they're at least dangerous. The "bad" may come later.
- drivebyacct2 15y agoDangerous because it's easy for you to use their services and be happy? Why does that make Google dangerous? Even if you tout "lock in", I don't see how that makes them dangerous; it makes your dependence dangerous. Especially given the volume of data liberation/exportation tools they provide.
- KeithMajhor 15y agoDangerous: "Able or likely to cause harm or injury" [1] Google is exactly that. I think you're reading too much into whats being said. Are you suggesting we shouldn't keep a watchful eye on Google? They have a tremendous amount of power. 1: http://www.google.com/search?q=define:%20dangerous http://www.google.com/search?q=define:%20dangerous
- drivebyacct2 15y agoTheir power is derived from your use of their services. You can quote the dictionary at me, but I simply don't understand this attitude. It's like handing over money to a drug dealer in the back alley and going "I just don't know about you, you seem dangerous" and then coming back week after week. Stop using Google and they lose all power over you and the "danger" evaporates.
- freebird_uk 15y agoThe problem with Google is you get tracked even if you don't use any of their services. Almost every single web page has one of Google Adsense, Analytics, Maps, ... all of which can build up a profile about you. To a degree this same effect is happening with FB as more and more sites add like buttons, though they remain less common than Google's array of libraries.
- bru 15y agoDoes Google have a look at Google Analytics? I thought it was only for the webmasters who set it up and that Google did not touch it. It is nearly their only service that I haven't blocked (with the libraries available on their CDN).
- freebird_uk 15y agoThe issue is they have the potential to do it. Once the potential is there and you have people motivated by performance targets, stock price, etc it's very difficult to permanently resist the temptation.
- justincormack 15y agoIf you are really paranoid you could mirror their cdn libraries and rewrite the urls, as they could be used as fairly poor info too...
- fauigerzigerk 15y agoHere's what Google says about analytics: Website owners that use Google Analytics have control over what data they allow Google to use. They can decide if they want Google to use this data or not by using the Google Analytics Data Sharing Options. When these options allow, the data is used to improve Google products and services. Website owners can change these options at anytime. http://www.google.com/intl/en/analytics/privacyoverview.html* http://www.google.com/intl/en/analytics/privacyoverview.html... Since I have no control over it, I block Google analytics.
- conradfr 15y ago
- statictype 15y agoWith Apple, I'm the customer, not a marketer. I believe the party line is "I'm not the product being sold". but it is just too damn easy to switch search engines. Or, you know, run an ad-blocker - much easier than jailbreaking a phone and Google Search/Gmail will continue to work well with an ad-blocker running, even if they upgrade the site.
- dextorious 15y ago"""Or, you know, run an ad-blocker - much easier than jailbreaking a phone and Google Search/Gmail will continue to work well with an ad-blocker running, even if they upgrade the site."" Actually, no, Google would stop business if people used ad-blockers en masse. So that's just something that works because few people do it. And it's not like Google is gonna decide where they want to go their services, changes, etc, with you and not the marketer's benefit in mind. So, even if you use ad-block, you're still the product being sold (to be exact: you're just a lost sale). You can't escape that, unless you actually pay the company whose services you use.
- statictype 15y agoWell, that wasn't exactly the point I was trying to make. My point: The downside of Google products is having to look at their ads. The downside of Apple products is getting locked-in to their restricted platform. You can sidestep Google's downside with an ad-blocker. You can sidestep Apple's downside with a jail break. It's easier to run that ad-blocker (heck, you can even get it from Google's own store) and keep it running than it is to perform a jail break and keep that updated. As an aside - just like a lot of people aren't offended by the restrictions Apple places on its platform, a lot of people are not offended by Google's ads. In fact, I bet there's a very significant overlap in those two groups.
- Joeri 15y agoWith google i feel like a data funnel, that's true. But with apple i feel like a money funnel. Apple always manages to make me spend more than expected. Their products are deliberately engineered to make it painful to seek affordable alternatives when you need new parts.
- KeithMajhor 15y agoCan you give any examples of this? You may be over-generalizing. Most of their products don't even have replaceable parts. Are you sure their reasons aren't legitimate?
- statictype 15y agoRAM from Apple is certainly expensive enough that almost no one recommends it. They also tend to nickle-and-dime you on accessories like converter cables.
- KeithMajhor 15y ago"Their products are deliberately engineered to make it painful to seek affordable alternatives when you need new parts." Some of apples products have RAM directly soldered to the motherboard. This has legitimate engineering trade-offs. Of the ones that don't do this: Are there any that deliberately void compatibility with alternatives. It looks like most of their cables have alternatives too. Their stuff is expensive sure. But are they deliberately locking you into using their accessories?
- statictype 15y agoYes, sorry - I missed that part of the point. You can get usually get cheaper alternative accessories.
- Bud 15y agoSo basically, you are griping because Apple hasn't chosen to be a mass seller of RAM upgrades who keeps large stocks and is willing to sell it for very small profit margins. Heard of damning with faint praise? I'd say this amounts to praising with faint damn.
- bhrgunatha 15y agoI'm deleting my facebook account tomorrow. I dumped all my data already and gave notice to my friends. I'd rather be cut-off than have to pay their price; they've proven time and time again how little regard they have for your privacy. Every slight change facebook makes means re-evaluating all of the privacy settings and other configurations to re-assess what extra information is being leaked without warning or approval.
- statictype 15y agoI understand your point. But it has never bothered me (so far) because I've never posted anything on Facebook that I want private. I do things there with the full expectation that someone will be able to see it if they really want to. I also treat Dropbox the same way. That said, I've also been toying with the idea of removing my FB account - just because I'm bored with it.
- joering1 15y agothis will all change very soon. I think the product is almost done: http://mankabros.com/blogs/chairman/2011/03/26/manka-bros-to-launch-facebook-killer/ http://mankabros.com/blogs/chairman/2011/03/26/manka-bros-to...
- jrockway 15y agoWith Apple, I'm the customer, not a marketer. Are you sure about that? Apple "sells you" as a user that will buy apps on the app store, and they take 30% of the developer's profit for that privilege. Whenever Apple can, they advertise how their users buy more apps than Android users, and bill this as a reason for developing for iOS and not some other mobile platform. You are a product.
- robterrell 15y agoThat's a stretch. It's simpler than that: follow the money. I pay Apple, so I'm the customer. Advertisers and marketers pay Google for access to me, so they're the customer. Just because Apple touts their user numbers doesn't mean they're selling those users. In fact, as a developer, I can't pay Apple to guarantee installs, or even visibility. Apple won't sell me customers. I might like to give Apple money to get leads or users for my apps, but Apple will not do that.