5 ms·
Open source has the same problem. You can review source, great, but you can’t prove it’s the same source that’s executing. From evil compilers to source/binary
by brookst 4y ago
Open source has the same problem. You can review source, great, but you can’t prove it’s the same source that’s executing.
From evil compilers to source/binary modification in flight to supply chain attacks, it is probably impossible to prove secure operation of open (or closed) source.
All we have are mitigations and risk reduction. If the bar is provably perfect security, nothing can meet it.
- fsflover 4y agoYou can verify that the executable came from the same sources: https://reproducible-builds.org/ https://reproducible-builds.org/.
- okdood64 4y agoHow do I obtain the all the executables in the chain?
- brookst 4y agoHow do you know the tools you use to verify weren’t modified in memory? Seriously. It is not possible to prove 100% security. Between human, electrical, hardware, firmware, and software vulnerabilities, there is always a gap.
- fsflover 4y agoNothing is ever 100%, but some things are good enough. By the way, I am using Qubes OS for reasonable security.
- brookst 4y agoYou’ve absolutely illustrated my two points: 1) nothing is ever 100%, and 2) everyone thinks their personal choices are the ideal; anything less secure is playing with fire, anything more secure is unnecessary overkill.
- fsflover 4y agoThere is no need to be 100% secure at all. All you need is to make hacking you more expensive than what you get if successful. I'm sure it works well with Qubes, if you use it in the right way.