4 ms·
What a misleading title > However, the accounting firm said on Friday that it had “paused its activity relating to the provision of proof of reserves reports f
by seydor 4y ago
What a misleading title
> However, the accounting firm said on Friday that it had “paused its activity relating to the provision of proof of reserves reports for entities in the cryptocurrency sector due to concerns regarding the way these reports are understood by the public”. According to communications seen by the Financial Times, the level of media focus on the matter was also a factor in Mazars’ decision ... Mazars’ decision to halt work on proof of reserves reports was not driven by specific financial problems at any of the companies, said a person briefed on its decision. The firm’s work was so limited that it had “not looked that much” into the financial position of the companies ... Some people at Mazars feared that despite caveats in its reports the firm was “lending credibility to a very volatile sector” and felt it had been “naive” and “silly” to take on the work, the person added.
Nothing indicating that audit did not go well, but that because of its limited scope, the auditor wants to avoid bad PR.
Binance being an exchange, they make money whether cash goes in or out. so outflows are in a way good business?
- lobochrome 4y agoExcept there was no audit, only an attestation. Outflows are as good as they were for FTX - if there is no 100% coverage of customer deposits.
- jacquesm 4y agoChartered accounts are liable for their work. Both Mazars and BDO have already been warned by the UK regulators their oversight is insufficient in July of this year. If they end up being associated with Binance and Binance goes under it could well take Mazars with it, there is good precedent for that, see Enron and Arthur Andersen.
- itake 4y agoLess money on the exchange means less money to be traded
- pifm_guy 4y agoOutflows are good business only if you are fully backed....
- jacquesm 4y agoPrecisely. If they end up dry then that's end of story for them and Mazars as their auditors may well end up in the spotlight and/or the crosshairs of those that wish to seek redress.
- dash2 4y agoI think the point was, it wasn't even an audit, and Mazars is worried that people will misconstrue it as them giving Binance a clean bill of health (and then hate Mazars if Binance comes crashing down). Also, presumably Binance has reserves because it needs them. Also, wouldn't the same logic apply to FTX? But then it turned out they were playing with the customers' money.
- dwighttk 4y ago>Mazars is worried that people will misconstrue it as them giving Binance a clean bill of health If they saw the same headlines I did they were worried that people were misconstruing it as them giving Binance a clean bill of health
- seydor 4y agoThe title puts "halts proof of reserves work" next to "outflows hit $6B", which on quick reading implies that they halted the actual "audit" presumably because something went wrong , hence why i think it's misleading And while the article makes it clear that they withheld their report for PR reasons, I'm sure most people here will assume that the "audit" went wrong
- dash2 4y agoIt's a journalist's job to be suspicious. Yeah, maybe it's a total coincidence that these things happened together. Maybe the rat just happened to be leaving this listing and waterlogged ship! To visit its relatives! But that's not how a journalist thinks.
- jacquesm 4y agoI don't know if you have ever worked with a large accounting firm but when they 'pause their activity' that means that they are not going to tie their name to yours, effectively that's as much as saying we will not go down with you. Alternative reading is that they found fraud but they don't want to be the ones to ring the bell on a customer. Binance is an exchange that holds balances, and those balances are in their internal coin, which supposedly is backed by their reserves. But as you've been able to see in the FTX affair that isn't always true and that is exactly the bit that Mazars refuses to continue to work on. Let's assume they know more than you and I and take it as a sign. Keep in mind that an internal stable coin ledger is just a bunch of numbers that need not necessarily be backed by anything at all.
- seydor 4y agoafaik binance uses various wallets, their BNB is used for tranactions
- jacquesm 4y agoWhat matters is whether or not when you add up all of reserves and subtract the liabilities that the balance is positive indicationg the firm is still solvent. If they've been leveraging or borrowing from the reserves then the proof-of-reserves process (which they themselves have created) is the only thing that they can use to shuffle the books to the point that it looks as if they are still solvent. The way money has been routed between various accounts (both internal and external) suggests that they are using timing rather than actual reserves to make it look as though they are solvent when in fact they are not. Time will tell if that is an accurate reading of the situation.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- notacoward 4y ago> when they 'pause their activity' that means that they are not going to tie their name to yours A parallel that might help people understand this is a "no recommendation" for an employee. When someone is enjoined from saying anything actually negative, silence can speak volumes.