3 ms·
I like RISC-V and hope it succeeds. But this article is disingenuous to the point of willful misrepresentation. It asserts that the only business risk to cons
by brookst 4y ago
I like RISC-V and hope it succeeds.
But this article is disingenuous to the point of willful misrepresentation.
It asserts that the only business risk to consider when choosing an ISA is whether the owner of the ISA might be sold to a new owner. Which I think might not even make the top 10 risks. Certainly it’s far less important than whether the ISA will reach critical mass for toolchain support, whether it will scale from small devices to datacenter applications, whether it will evolve and innovate, whether there is a pool of programmers with expertise, and so on. It’s bizarre to not even mention risks in these areas.
I’m not saying RISC-V falls short in these things; I don’t know enough to have an opinion on that. But I do know they’re all more important than whether e.g. a hedge fund takes Intel private.
Lots of other similar errors and omissions. This is evangelism from a True Believer, not a legit piece about RISC-V’s place in the industry.
- tenebrisalietum 4y agoA lot of those risks would be risks before there was Linux, GCC, and the plethora of open source tools. There's working RISC-V emulators running Linux with toolchains now, and there isn't even any real RISC-V hardware you can get yet beyond some demo boards, etc. > whether it will evolve and innovate CPU evolution and innovation is driven by the transistors beneath the ISA, not the ISA. For Intel, MMX/SEE and all the SIMD stuff was an innovation and something new, but the instructions that use it are really not that big of a deal in and of themselves. When some other capability arises in CPUs, any ISA will simply get new instructions.
- brookst 4y agoFair enough. For a startup considering committing to an ISA for low level development, would you say RISC-V is no riskier (har) than ARM? Despite, as you say, very little HW being available?
- Gordonjcp 4y agoRealistically how many products are going to be reliant on the development team writing bare assembly?
- the_duke 4y ago> there isn't even any real RISC-V hardware you can get yet beyond some demo boards, etc. I assume you mean Linux-capable hardware. The Risc-V foundation claims that over 10 Billion chips have already been produced.