5 ms·
This is actually an argument for why Twitter shouldn't exist. Twitter makes it super easy to do mass warrantless surveillance, because Twitter gathers millions
by lapcat 4y ago
This is actually an argument for why Twitter shouldn't exist.
Twitter makes it super easy to do mass warrantless surveillance, because Twitter gathers millions of people together in the same searchable public space. It's a honeypot.
What's dangerous about the "public square" concept is that Musk doesn't just want a public square — one public space among many, one among equals — he wants the public square, a monopoly on online conversation. "I think I see a path to Twitter exceeding a billion monthly users in 12 to 18 months" https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1596751751532937217 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1596751751532937217
We shouldn't have all of our conversations, political or otherwise, in one place. That's a giant mistake. We need decentralization for our own safety and freedom.
- jacquesm 4y agoThis goes for any large web property where people congregate to communicate. HN is no different in that respect.
- lapcat 4y ago> This goes for any large web property where people congregate to communicate. Yes, for example Facebook and TikTok. > HN is no different in that respect. Well, Twitter has over 200 million users. I believe that HN is much much smaller. HN also tends to be more anonymous.
- jacquesm 4y agoHN is a lot larger than you probably think and YC has an excellent legal department and even if I do not know for sure that there has been contact between LE and HN/YC about this forum given the fact that we are looking at a decade+ of operation and many millions of interactions, including threats of bodily harm and other nonsense I would expect the chances of there having been such interaction to be better than even.
- lapcat 4y ago> HN is a lot larger than you probably think I'd be interested to know the user number.
- jacquesm 4y agoA typical homepage link can cause between 40 and 50K visitors to your website. And that's a small fraction of the total number of users. Millions of pageviews per day, 250K+ registered users and a multiple of that in lurkers. Does that help?
- lapcat 4y ago> 250K+ registered users That's the relevant number. So Twitter is about 1000x larger than HN. From a surveillance standpoint, we're really only talking about commenters, on both sites.
- jacquesm 4y agoTrue, but Twitter is mostly cat pictures, I think the average HN users could do a lot more damage to society than the average Twitter user.
- lapcat 4y ago> I think the average HN users could do a lot more damage to society than the average Twitter user. How so? How many HN comments have "gone viral"? How many news stories are about a HN comment? How many politicians and journalists and pro athletes and Hollywood celebrities are commenting on HN? Any given HN comment can receive only a theoretical maximum of 250K upvotes, if (improbably) every registered user upvoted it, and those upvotes would be superfluous anyway, because they would only bring the comment to the top of a single HN submission.
- survirtual 4y agoMost technical people are not perceived a threat all because they do not pose any social damage. Tech threats can be handled in all kinds of passive or escalated to cruel and insane ways without any risk of public backlash. Someone with 1mil+ followers is a whole other story. They have enough people watching their every move to cause problems if they are dealt with directly, so they need more attention for implicit handling over time, psychological and financial handling, etc. People with an audience can cause a lot of social, political, and ultimately financial damage to many entities just by some words. And in a world run by marketers, salespeople, lawyers, bankers, and politicians — this is the scariest threat imaginable. Tech people can do a lot of technical damage but it is mostly just a thorn in the side of the machine. Even if they built something disruptive, an audience is needed for it to go anywhere, and most avenues for scaling anything disruptive are already tightly controlled / monitored by big tech. I say this as what I believe the controlling authorities perspective is on the matter.
- hedora 4y agoI've occasionally noticed some sketchy article flagging in the new submissions feed. (A recent article explaining how to add snow animations to HTML pages comes to mind.) I like to think that dang's days consist of monocle and tophat shopping, sabotaging the metric system, and propping up the global media conspiracy. However, I suspect the root cause is more mundane: Some small percentage of users treat "flag article" like the downvote button.
- craigching 4y agoOn mobile, I accidentally hit flag quite often trying to tap the link of the article below it. I do go back every time and unflag, but I can imagine not everyone would.
- stanislavb 4y agoHN is a niche compared to Twitter.
- jacquesm 4y ago
- superchroma 4y agoyes and the day when they all go away will be a good day
- Akronymus 4y ago> HN is no different in that respect. HN doesn't even have DM's to release though.
- idlewords 4y agoSlack is an even better example.
- jacquesm 4y agoYes, that would be a real problem.
- abigail95 4y agosurveillance of public comments is an oxymoron no?
- lapcat 4y agoNo. Are you ok with the government putting cameras everywhere in public? Setting up auto license plate readers everywhere? You don't have the expectation of privacy in public in the sense that someone can see what you're doing. But there's also the expectation that a democratic (small d) government isn't watching your every move in public, because that's a sign of totalitarianism.
- croes 4y agoDidn't Snowden show us, that there already is warrantless mass surveillance as soon as you use the internet? No matter where or what site you use.
- ABCLAW 4y agoThere's a bunch of these analytics platforms available. Government isn't the only one using them, and twitter isn't the only platform being used. Look up Talkwalker, Hootsuite, Nexalogy, etc. Governments and other institutions use these tools. Spreading the conversation elsewhere doesn't change the ability of these analytics platforms to cover them, although it does introduce more noise into the signal; the smaller the forum, the less an impact it has in the analytics rankings. If you slice up the pie into a ton of tiny chunks, the data received becomes less useful. That said, some of the uses of these platforms are completely reasonable and very pro-social. We kinda want law enforcement to know if Jimmy Bullets just posted that he's gonna shoot up grade 4 English tomorrow.
- lapcat 4y ago> Look up Talkwalker, Hootsuite, Nexalogy, etc. Governments and other institutions use these tools. I suspect that these tools are all looking at the world's largest social networks with 9-10 figure user bases. The same argument applies to them: they're too big. None of them should exist. Once you break it down to thousands or millions of different platforms, each with much smaller user bases, it becomes prohibitively expensive to surveil them all. > We kinda want law enforcement to know if Jimmy Bullets just posted that he's gonna shoot up grade 4 English tomorrow. Has this ever prevented a shooting? They always find these posts after the fact.
- enkid 4y agoAll internet companies at this point are doing "mass warrantless surveillance" at this point then. Google makes money off matching people to advertisers by learning what they search, post, and how they use their computers.