4 ms·
> I get it, I'm an anarchist You may need to read up the definition of that word
by paxys 4y ago
> I get it, I'm an anarchist
You may need to read up the definition of that word
- Psyladine 4y agoAt the end of the day everyone's really a pragmatist. Exceptions tend to shake the world, and not really for the better.
- smcl 4y agoMost people I know who have these beliefs - anarchism, communism - don’t believe a sudden big-bang is how a transition to their l preferred system of government would work, and are pragmatic in moving towards it without upending society in the process. Hell look at Russia’s “shock therapy” transition to capitalism, we are seeing the very direct consequences of that to this day.
- ancapsfascists 4y agoMy guy, I've spent a decade reading up on that word. You want to talk Bookchin, Kroptkin, or Öcalan I'm available any time. Respect to my anarchist comrades who are all or nothing, but I recognize the current system we live in, and I'm not going to throw away the useful tools before replacing them.
- diob 4y agoHeck, even Chomsky is an anarchist. I don't know what the comment to you was insinuating, that we shouldn't fix things? Big https://i.kym-cdn.com/photos/images/original/001/330/819/e47.png https://i.kym-cdn.com/photos/images/original/001/330/819/e47... energy.
- hutzlibu 4y ago"I don't know what the comment to you was insinuating" Obviously that anarchism means, being opposed to all government activity, regulation and rules, so he cannot call him an anarchist if he wants rules for a river. But the thing with anarchism is, that there is not really a authorative definition accepted and in use ..
- TEP_Kim_Il_Sung 4y ago> But the thing with anarchism is, that there is not really a authorative definition accepted and in use .. Sure there is: anarchism (n.) "political doctrine advocating leaderlessness," 1640s; see anarchy + -ism. anarchy (n.) 1530s, "absence of government," from French anarchie or directly from Medieval Latin anarchia, from Greek anarkhia "lack of a leader, the state of people without a government" (in Athens, used of the Year of Thirty Tyrants, 404 B.C., when there was no archon), abstract noun from anarkhos "rulerless," from an- "without" (see an- (1)) + arkhos "leader" (see archon).
- cowthulhu 4y agoI disagree with anarchists as much as the next guy, but a quick google gets a bunch of results that contradict your definitions. It seems that anarchism is, at best, very rarely defined in the way you provided.
- TEP_Kim_Il_Sung 4y agoWhich is why I quoted the original meaning and root words. etymonline.com
- cowthulhu 4y agoWell no fair! I’m sure the original meaning of “earth” is “the thing at the center of the universe”, but we’ve moved on from that definition!
- TEP_Kim_Il_Sung 4y agoEarth means soil, dirt, that sort of stuff. It's meaning has stayed consistent. What is unfair about using a word how it was meant to be used?
- cowthulhu 4y ago
- lazide 4y agoHow do you reconcile being an anarchist with calling for federal rule making interventionism?
- ancapsfascists 4y agoHere's an analogy: let's say you work on cars and you've got a decent set of tools. You have a friend who has an excellent set and a whole shop. You can imagine yourself running with your ideal set. But the first step isn't "throw out all your tools and get a $20 Walmart box of assorted tools." I can imagine a society built on mutual aid, and I practice that everywhere I can. But I have access to tools today. I can vote, I can use my voice to influence the government. What's my alternative, given the reality of today? Convert everyone asking the Colorado river to council communists before the river dries up? My tool box isn't perfect, but it has some good tools in it. Many of them I'd ideally get rid of and replace, but I'm not going to ignore the tools I have until I replace them with better ones.
- lazide 4y agoThat literally sounds like the opposite of anarchism to me. But you do you I guess?
- ancapsfascists 4y agoSounds like you don't know many anarchists? Most of the anarchists I know are focused on: Building mutual aid networks locally, first and foremost. We help us, we protect us. Think food, clothing, and shelter for anyone in need. Advocate for harm reduction. Given there are a lot of systemic problems that will take years to unwind, it's important to offset those harms, even if it's not your ultimate goal. I vote. It takes me ten minutes, it reduces the harm by electing progressive politicians who might be able to lower the power of capital. That doesn't make me not an anarchist. I can hold an ideal and also recognize reality simultaneously. Finally, anarchists educate. They are focused on teaching that anarchism isn't "the purge", it's a system built on the idea that every human deserves respect. We have the means to care for everyone and still enjoy some luxuries.
- refurb 4y agoAn anarchist who promotes the government taking rights by force? Im a communist who loves free markets!
- ancapsfascists 4y agoMarket socialism and market communism exist. I think they are bad ideologies, but they exist. Don't confuse ideals with immediate needs. My ideals, and what I'm willing to do today in the name of harm reduction aren't always aligned. It's called "making compromises" and "using your judgement". A blindly dogmatic adherence to ones own idealism is a recipe for all talk but no material improvements.
- listenallyall 4y ago> blindly dogmatic adherence So then what's with the insistence (and multiple reminders) of self-labelling as "anarchist"? Why not pragmatist, or harm-reducer, or just not labelling or categorizing yourself at all?
- cowthulhu 4y agoI think he calls himself an anarchist because his core beliefs are anarchist?
- ancapsfascists 4y agoBecause I'm an anarchist, that label is both correct and useful?
- antifa 4y agoKropotkin is my favorite geologist/climatologist.
- dontlaugh 4y agoAs a communist, respect to pragmatic anarchist comrades. State power can be useful, even if we both wish to be rid of it.
- ancapsfascists 4y agoHeck yeah. I might disagree with my communists friends, but we're closer together than we are far apart.