2 ms·
You hit the nail in the head. It is about mimicry. Apes are often dismissed as just mimicking human behavior in many circumstances. Putting on a hat for instan
by galaxyLogic 4y ago
You hit the nail in the head. It is about mimicry. Apes are often dismissed as just mimicking human behavior in many circumstances. Putting on a hat for instance. They don't know nor think about what it is about. And neither do babies nor even many adults. They don't reflect on it, and most definitely they don't reflect on their own thought-processes. They just mimic other humans around them.
Now mimicking the speech of people may give the impression that the AI has some thought-processes behind its speech because, it is text that any human might write. But there's no logic because there's no symbolic reasoning. There's just mimicry and trial and error. "Training the model" just means millions of trial-and-error practice runs.
What the (neural network) AI can NOT mimic is the actual (symbolic) thought-process of humans, because that is not visible anywhere. It can only mimic the input -> response -behavior of humans. Therefore no, the AI is not conscious. It is the proverbial zombie.
- pishpash 4y agoAre you sure there is an actual "thought-process [sic] of humans"? Witnesses have made up explanations for false memories, the same as in a dream.
- galaxyLogic 4y agoI am not sure. But humans can often explain the thought-process that led them to a certain decision. I think that counts as evidence of consciousness., in humans.
- skirmish 4y agoHumans can explain rational thought, sure, but not subconscious or acting on impulse. When you say something you shouldn't have said, how do you explain the thought process that led you to saying it? Were you an unconscious actor when you unwisely started an argument with your manager?
- galaxyLogic 4y agoYes you can be conscious about having been unconscious earlier. We do have reflexes. But we also have consciousness about our own thinking.