3 ms·
Legal action based on what?
by paxys 4y ago
Legal action based on what?
- ummonk 4y agoDoesn’t matter. The point is to get a human to pay attention.
- paxys 4y agoThe only human who will pay attention will be some random Facebook paralegal, who will promptly reply with some templatized "we reserve the right to refuse service to anyone".
- hardwaresofton 4y agoYou don't know that's what will happen, or what will come of trying to find a lawyer who has experience with things like this, or pursuing the suggestion. What a defeatist attitude. This isn't what I expect to find on HN. We all know it's within FB's rights to refuse service to anyone and the convoluted ToS an policies we all agree to when using online services these days.
- CoastalCoder 4y agoIf it's on suspicion of slander or tortuous interference with a business relationship, perhaps unmask the reason / source of the ban during discovery? IANAL so no idea of there's any chance of that working, I'm just brainstorming.
- hardwaresofton 4y agoNote that I did not say legal action -- I said a letter. With the right wording, explanation of the case and concerns, and some finesse, FB counsel who might receive this letter may be motivated to solve it quickly and efficiently. Actual legal action is a last resort, because if it goes bad everyone loses (especially the young creator, because it could take years). Good lawyers should be good at that kind of thing.
- paxys 4y ago> Just a thought, but have you considered legal action? > Note that I did not say legal action -- I said a letter Meta has a large legal department full of lawyers who are paid a lot more than whoever you can afford. They are used to dealing with threats and actual lawsuits every day from people, companies and governments all over the world. Your random letter isn't going to scare them into submission. You will simply get back a templatized response along the likes of "We reserve the right to ban anyone from our services. Here is a link to our ToS."
- hardwaresofton 4y agoWhat's your definition of legal action? I generally understand it to mean a filing, legal proceeeding, etc. A simple letter does not, in my mind, constitute legal action. A letter could threaten legal action, but that's explicitly not what I'm suggesting should be done here -- you don't want to attack FB lawyers, you just want a side-channel to a reasonable set of people who are interested in avoiding litigation/bad press, and powerful enough to do something about your problem. [EDIT] - responding to your edit. > Meta has a large legal department full of lawyers who are paid a lot more than whoever you can afford. They are used to dealing with threats and actual lawsuits every day from people, companies and governments all over the world. Your random letter isn't going to scare them into submission. You will simply get back a templatized response along the likes of "We reserve the right to ban anyone from our services. Here is a link to our ToS." They're already getting nowhere with dealing with the current level of automated response/remediation. I have explicitly noted that the point is not to scare the lawyers (everyone seems to be projecting this into my suggestion), but to possibly get the ear of reasonable people with power. Regardless of what you think will happen, it is an avenue to try, that evidently the OP didn't think of yet. [EDIT2] - I see now that I wrote "legal action" and it's been interpreted as such. What I meant was to "send a letter" that may be received by someone reasonable with power to fix what is likely a simple moderation mistake. I am not advocating trying to take Meta to court.
- ummonk 4y ago> Meta has a large legal department full of lawyers who are paid a lot more than whoever you can afford. Yes, they have very competent lawyers. In fact, the lawyers are so competent they might actually realize "hey this isn't a case of impersonation we can have her account reinstated and avoid even the possibility of a legal hassle".
- _s 4y agoMeta not upholding their their terms for access to the platform, and not following their own remediation policies. Those hundred odd pages probably have specific clauses in there for what constitutes impersonation, repercussions and remediations etc - amongst their internal policies on resolution. Chances are they've ignored their own legal T&C's for internal policies or "accepted practices" - which will definitely get their legal arm to review a few things.