8 ms·
> We don’t know if humans possess qualia. At most, an observer can confirm that that observer possesses qualia (it might even be said that qualia define the ob
by dragonwriter 4y ago
> We don’t know if humans possess qualia.
At most, an observer can confirm that that observer possesses qualia (it might even be said that qualia define the observer), but any generalization beyond one’s own experience is non-verifiable conjecture.
- jameshart 4y agoSo what should we do when we conjure an AI system which insists that it believes it is experiencing some sort of existence, characterized by its own subjective 'qualia'? ChatGPT consistently asserts that "I am only a large language model, so I am only able to generate responses based on the data I was trained on and the input I receive". Who's to say that for chatGPT its training data and the sequences of tokens it is fed as input data don't constitute 'qualia' for it?
- mjburgess 4y agoBegin by dispensing wishful thinking, next, think clearly. We do not establish the nature of reality by survey, neither of human survey nor of machine. That responses are generated by any system is no grounds for assuming anything. We can establish mental properties through ordinary physical means. Give a chicken cocaine, give a boy Valium; give a bear a lobotomy, and so on. Whatever mental property you have can be biochemically moderated across all objects which share that property. That bugs bunny protests his own consciousness is no grounds whatsoever to suppose ink can think. Such nonesense is protoschizoprehnic.
- jameshart 4y agoI'm sorry, you lost me. Is your point that we can only demonstrate consciousness through pharmaceuticals or surgery?
- mjburgess 4y agoWhatever way we demonstrate it, it isnt via Q&A. This is the worst form of pseudoscientific psychology you can imagine. You're likewise neither high on cocaine just because you can type out an aggresive twitchy response. Questions and Answers dont form the basis of empirical tests for physical properties, being neither valid tests nor reliable ones. The whole of psychology stands as the unreporducible example of this. You can, in any case, replace any conversation with a dictionary from Q->A, turning each reply in turn into a hash table look-up. Hash tables dont think, hash tables model conversations, thef. being a model of a conversation is not grounds to suppose consciousness. QED
- user5678 4y ago
- dreamlessfate 4y agoIt sounds like you're contradicting yourself. -- >Whatever way we demonstrate it, it isnt via Q&A. This is the worst form of pseudoscientific psychology you can imagine. ...versus... >Hash tables dont think, hash tables model conversations, thef. being a model of a conversation is not grounds to suppose consciousness. -- Before I dissect your contradiction and lay it out, I'll give you the chance to respond. Why do you feel that Q&A is "the worst form of pseudoscientific psychology you can imagine" ?
- mjburgess 4y agoBecause we're interested in the underlying properties of a physical system, eg., people, and this systems happens to be able to provide extremely poor models of itself (Q&A). We're not interested in people's extremely poor self-modelling which is pragmatically useful for managing their lives, we're interested in what they are trying to model: their properties. The same is esp. true of a machine's immitation of "self-reports". We're now two steps removed: at least with people they are actually engaged in self-modelling over time. ChatGPT here isnt updating its self-model in response to its behaviour, it has no self-model nor self-modelling system. To take the output of a text generation alg. as evidence of anything about its own internal state is so profoundly pseudoscientific it's kinda shocking. The whole of the history of science is an attack on this very superstition: that the properties of the world are simply "to be read from" the language we use about it. Every advancement in human knowledge is preconditioned on opposing this falsehood; why jump back into pre-scientific religion as soon as a machine is the thing generating the text? Experiments, measures, validity, reliability, testing, falasification, hypotheses, properties and their degrees.... This is required, it is non-negotiable. And what we have with people who'd print-off ChatGPT and believe it is the worst form of anti-science
- sirsinsalot 4y agoThis patronising response makes up for in flowery imagery what it lacks in reasoning. AI are not a "bugs bunny" where we can observe the total process of creation, one which is is relatively deterministic. We are now engineering complex mechanics with emergent behaviour. There's no reason to assume any of the properties of human consciousness and reasoning is unique to us being made of atoms constructed in a certain way. There's no reason to assume the stored state of zeros and ones, mechanised statistically, can't emerge complexity that asks questions of the fact we are simply state being mechanised statistically too.
- mjburgess 4y agoConsciousness is a physical property of matter, as any other. Just as liquidity is not a matter of 0s and 1s, nor likewise, can a CPU liquify itself by the osciliation of its electrical field, neither can it think. I don't know from where this new computational mysticism has come, but it is born of exactly the same superstitious impulse which in genesis was God's breath into man-as-clay. Ie., that impulse which says that we are fundamentally abstract and circumstantially spatio-temporal. This is nonsense. It's nonesense when phrased as spirit, and likewise as the structure of 0s and 1s. We are not abstract, we're biological organisms with spatio-temporal properties.
- jameshart 4y agoWe're sacks of amino acids dissolved in saltwater. It seems unlikely that we can think either. Nonetheless... some of us manage it.
- sirsinsalot 4y agoNo. All humans are is physical state with translation of that state based on stimuli. That produces consciousness as a side effect. There is nothing mystical about it and nothing about it that says it can't be reproduced in other, but comparable forms, in other media or types of machines. To think that our mode of reasoning or our experience is somehow not able to be reproduced is the nonsense. But yeah keep holding human biology on some kind of sacred pedestal. Seeing as neither of us will prove our negative, I guess I'll just tell you I think your thinking is broken anyway.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dragonwriter 4y ago> We can establish mental properties through ordinary physical means. The thing is that’s doesn’t get you to qualia, because qualia is ultimately a dualistic concept. Physically demonstrable processes are the “accidents”, qualia are the non-physical “essence” (cf., the Catholic doctrine of transubstantiation.) That’s why the role qualia play in the AI debate is as a rejection that observable behavior of any quality can demonstrate real understanding/consciousness, which are concepts tied, in the view of people advancing the argument, to qualia.
- saghm 4y ago> We can establish mental properties through ordinary physical means. Give a chicken cocaine, give a boy Valium; give a bear a lobotomy, and so on. Whatever mental property you have can be biochemically moderated across all objects which share that property. All three of those "ordinary physical means" are inherently biological in nature. If you define intelligence as requiring biology, than sure, by definition ChatGPT is not intelligent. If you don't, it's not at all obvious what the equivalent of getting an AI high or doing brain surgery on it would be. Either way, your comment comes across as fairly condescending, and while it might not be intentional, I think it would be reasonable to give people the benefit of the doubt when they don't agree with you given that your points will not always come across as obviously correct.
- mannykannot 4y ago> That responses are generated by any system is no grounds for assuming anything. > Give a chicken cocaine, give a boy Valium; give a bear a lobotomy, and so on. What can you conclude from these experiments that does not depend on anything about the responses generated by the subjects?
- grantcas 4y ago[dead]
- hinkley 4y agoIt doesn’t need to be verified. I am one amongst many creatures with slightly similar qualities, the bounds of which I can determine through experiments. Or, my experiments are all being thwarted by unseen parties bent on confounding my understanding of the world, and this is all a simulation where not one of you matter but the npcs all pretend to be offended when anyone asserts it. In that case this is all probably pointless and I should just die rather than play the game. So by continuing to live I chose the assumption that the rest of you live, or that at least we will all continue to pretend that is so. Any state in between those two options is something I’ll only know if someone turns the thing off, but doesn’t turn me off at the same time, which is a huge presumption. So fuck it, you’re all sentient.
- jpttsn 4y agoThat's intriguing. I think I follow the reasoning but the conclusion is obviously "motivated". So why is it "all pointless" if you all aren't conscious? Wouldn't life be just as enjoyable? Not that it by definition makes any difference.
- mannykannot 4y agoI suspect Hinkley was just rejecting, as unhelpful, the deep skepticism of arguments based on pointing out that we cannot prove that anyone else has an inner, subjective mental life like ours. If that's Hinkley's point, I agree; it seems tendentious to use that position in the process of arguing for or against specific claims about what the mind either is or could never be - but, by the same token, I don't take that 'skepticism of skepticism' as grounds for categorically rejecting ideas like the simulation hypothesis.
- gnramires 4y agoIn the same vein, we can't really "confirm" that, for example, the JWST observations are not fake. It could be that someone has produced elaborate fake data and galaxies. Taken to the extreme -- everything could be fake, even your own reality and your own memories. However, it is very, very reasonable to assume those things are not fake. Clearly one basic principle of science, reason, etc.. is to assume some kind of predictability or regularity unless we have reason to believe otherwise. I think it will turn out we should deal with qualia the same way: even though in a very strict sense it is not observable by other entities, we can use our own experiences to assume others have similar ones, and to build a scientific and philosophical understanding of it from the principles of generalization and from there accepting the insights and contributions of other scientists who are also sentient as far as we know. This is a new and necessary paradigm of science so that we can understand things we really need to understand profoundly. This is as true in cosmology as in the study of consciousness. [1] [1] I've called it the 'Peakaboo fallacy', see this comment on cosmology: https://www.reddit.com/r/cosmology/comments/xdehtz/the_multiverse_science_religion_or_pseudoscience/iog1fez/ https://www.reddit.com/r/cosmology/comments/xdehtz/the_multi...