4 ms·
So, both sides are right. Nuclear is too slow, but renewables are not fast enough / sufficient either. Another thing is that politicians tend to plan that thin
by nine_k 4y ago
So, both sides are right. Nuclear is too slow, but renewables are not fast enough / sufficient either.
Another thing is that politicians tend to plan that things will continue to go about as well as they are going at the moment, and the only major crisis ahead is the one being discussed at the moment. Nobody has the nerve to think that e.g. France will have trouble with several nuclear reactors at once, and a major war erupts in Europe at the same time. Ah, and a global pandemic right before that. Who in their right mind would vote for an energy budget based on such paranoid view of a possible future?
- Retric 4y agoHardly, the UK completely replaced coal and reduced it’s dependence on natural gas with renewables from 2010 to 2020. Meanwhile that wasn’t enough time to bring any new nuclear online in the current environment. https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/2e/Electricity-production-by-sourceUK1985-2020.svg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/2e/Electric... Looks like renewables where simply the better, cheaper, and faster option. Which is shocking considering how little hydro and solar they have.
- nine_k 4y agoPlenty of wind though! Wind farms in the sea are a great idea; UK has a lot of sea at every side.
- vlovich123 4y agoWell sure. When you effectively ban nuclear through regulatory hurdles, why is it a surprise that you don’t builds any and why is that a conclusion you can draw about the efficacy of nuclear itself? Somehow China is building out quite a bit of nuclear capacity while the west is sitting around dithering.
- epistasis 4y agoI wouldn't put nuclear and renewables as opposed sides. The only reasonable future will be built for a minimum of 80%-90% of primary energy generated from renewbles, and it may be that 10%-20% of nuclear is cheaper than to do it all by renewables. I don't understand why you say renewables will be too slow. I've only done napkin math, but simple projection of continued growth of existing production capacity through, say, 2035, completely replaces all current electrical generation, as well as other energy uses. And when you account for the much much higher efficient of electrification, meaning that we get 2-3x as much work out of the same amount of energy compared to all the waste with fossil fuels, we can fulfill the developing world's needs for growth too. But this is just my napkin math from taking production trends from top Google hits, it's not a sophisticated analysis. I would be interested to see one that is realistic, meaning that it doesn't assume that solar deployments plateau tomorrow.
- nine_k 4y agoRenewables and nuclear are of course not opposing each other; they are opposing fossil fuels. According to the article, the UK now has less electrical generation than it would like / planned to have. Partly because the nuclear power plants failed to go online at the planned time. Partly because the amount of renewable generation that has been built in the meantime is not sufficient ether, because renewables need to be seriously overpeovisioned, due to their varying output. Hence "both were too slow". Were they not, there'd be no energy deficit, I suppose.
- Manuel_D 4y agoThey are opposing each other because of the combination of two factors: * Peak energy demand happens when intermittent sources are at their lowest production [1]. * Nuclear power is as cheap to run at 100% capacity as it is to run at 50% or 25% capacity. If you build enough nuclear power to fulfill the peak demand when renewables aren't producing, then you've already built enough nuclear to power the grid all day. And since nuclear is just as cheap to run at 100% capacity there's no point in provisioning renewables. Renewables work well when paired with a dispatchable energy source like gas or hydroelectricity. The former emits carbon and the latter is geographically dependent. In areas without hydroelectric potential, nuclear is the only existing option for full decarbonization. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duck_curve https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duck_curve
- nine_k 4y agoThis is right, and again, I'm pretty pro-nuclear. The upside of solar generation is its potential for really rapid deployment, and for piecemeal deployment. I can't afford to have a personal nuclear reactor, but I likely would be able to adorn my house with some solar panels, some batteries, and maybe a heat pump to create ice during the day's heat peak and use it after dusk. When I'd be able to afford a house, that is %)
- vlovich123 4y agoRenewables don’t really oppose fossil fuels. Not to the same extent that nuclear does anyway. Nuclear can 100% replace all fossil fuels as a drop in. Renewables on their own can’t and need significant battery capacity as well to even out the load. Additionally, there are industrial use cases that need high temperature (like 300+ degrees C if my memory is correct). Nuclear power plants can generate this no problem because it’s a massive furnace already. Coal too. Solar and wind cannot. I strongly believe who think renewables can replace all carbon energy sources are not realistic about what is needed and don’t appreciate the nuance and just think of it as “energy source” rather than as part of a complete energy production / distribution problem.
- godelski 4y agoA big problem with projects like these (nuclear and even renewable, but to a bit lesser of a degree) is that these projects outlast leadership. It then becomes easy to support something and it never get done. You make a big speech, but a few gears into motion, but more pressing stuff takes priority because a voter's attention is less than an election cycle. Truth is that if they work hard, get everything in motion you have 1 of 2 outcomes: 1) the next person gets all the praise because it is finished under their leadership or 2) the project goes into major delay as the next leadership doesn't prioritize it (often because it was the previous party's platform). Honestly I think we could get a lot more done if people were able to disentangle when policies were achieved from when they were implemented. Governments are fantastic for long term investments, but politics works on shorter timeframes than many corporations. Though I think changing the cultural mentality to provide that selective pressure is an unrealistic pipedream. That said, it does also really show the constraints that we operate under and why existential issues like climate change are extremely difficult to solve.
- orhmeh09 4y agoHow could this be achieved? I have one model in mind that might enable this type of long-term planning, but it would take quite a bit of work to make the US like China.
- tene 4y agoPolicy Prediction Markets.
- godelski 4y agoThe reason China can do it is because they are an autocracy. Voters don't matter and their elections aren't as meaningful, meaning they can have projects longer than an election cycle. If you want to get the West on a path this way, you have to get the people to have a change in how they evaluate their leaders. But first, you need to have the people trust in the leaders, which they don't right now for good reason. It is a tough nut to crack. I'm not saying this in approval of authoritarianism btw. I think the results of that are worse, but it does have advantages (which is why it is attractive to some).