12 ms·
I could see staying with Windows 7. That was the best version Microsoft ever made. Microsoft finally figured out how to make it stable, and it didn't have all t
by Animats 4y ago
I could see staying with Windows 7. That was the best version Microsoft ever made. Microsoft finally figured out how to make it stable, and it didn't have all the ad and cloud crap nailed in. You can run current Firefox, current Thunderbird, and current LibreOffice, which covers the basics. Most Windows software still works.
- Koshkin 4y ago> That was the best version Microsoft ever made No. 7 was a rollback on Vista. The best one which was not a step back but rather a step forward was Windows 2000. (Some even swear by NT4, which I feel also has some merit.)
- nix23 4y agoI think WindowsServer2003R2 was the best OS Microsoft ever made, then XP >SP2 and Windows2000, then Win7.
- Koshkin 4y agoAs to "the best OS Microsoft has ever made," it was OS/2 (which they abandoned in favor of the "hugely successful" Windows 3.0 which was clearly inferior on all technical accounts).
- nix23 4y agoThat was made by IBM AND Microsoft, but if we go so far Xenix was the best os MS ever made/buy'd ;)
- EvanAnderson 4y agoI used Server 2003 R2 as a daily driver on a laptop for a couple of years pre-Windows 7. It was very nice. Most Windows XP software would work fine.
- StillBored 4y agoYes 2003 64-bit was the first official 64-bit x86 windows and is probably the largest advance over 2000, and there really hasn't been anything since that is as large a technical capability addition. I'm on the fence, but frequently say that 2000 was probably the best. Then I have to qualify that maybe the preview 64-bit XP or full win2003 might be first or in the running because 64-bit is such a major/critical feature to modern computer that if you wanted to sell a modern "Windows for business" release you would have to pick one of the 64-bit versions rather than rolling back to 2k. I too ran 2k3 (64-bit of course on my athlon64) for a while as a desktop and technically it was fantastic, but eventually ended up switching back to XP with a few hacks to just avoid the general issue that a number of pieces of desktop software refused to run on a "server OS" without buying the server license for $$$$.
- ahartmetz 4y agoYes, 2000 was by far my favorite Windows. Very solid, very clean style. I have a burning hatred for the visual design of Windows 7 (and Vista to a lesser degree) - it may have been technically great, but the design felt appropriate for a toothpaste, not for an operating system. I could only stand XP with the 2000 style as well. What the hell were they thinking?
- rzzzt 4y agoThe theme in Windows 2000 and its classic counterpart in XP 64-bit used a darker shade of blue for the background, which I always tried to hand-select on the systems that I had (and weren't running these versions). There was also some tiny difference between the active window colors as well, IIRC.
- mrighele 4y agoI consider Windows 2000 the top that Microsoft reached with regard to style (both look and feel). But you can choose "Windows Classic" as a style in Windows 7 and it will not to be too different, although some thing may be annoying. For example, Windows 2000 was more keyboard-friendly. In Explorer, you edit the path on the top input, then you tab and you move between files. Since Windows XP that has been increasing, and its 5 tabs in Windows 7. Pratically unusable The control panel is not yet fucked up like in Windows 8+ but still you can guess the year in which the entry was written. On the other side, the start menu is better because you have a search field that works well (no web stupid web searches there).
- KMag 4y agoMy chief complaint about Win7 is how much slower it seemed to perform than Win2k on late 90s/early 2000s hardware / on a virtual machine. (Also, IIRC, the licensing terms for Win2k were better regarding running on virtual machines.)
- ihatepython 4y agoFor me, peak Windows in terms of style was Windows 3.1 with the Hotdog Stand theme. But Windows 2000 was solid as well
- monocasa 4y agoIt wasn't really a rollback, but instead a bit more stable from Vista having taken all the flack for the changes like a lightning rod.
- eyelidlessness 4y agoWin2K was the only version of Windows I ever ran as a daily driver. I had access to Macs from an early age (since System 7 and through all the processor architecture transitions, except I haven’t gotten an M-series yet), but sold my Mac and couldn’t afford a replacement for some time around the XP transition. My completely unqualified ranking… - 2k: excellent, top Windows - XP: fine, if you turn off all the UI changes, but not appealing over 2k in any way I can recall - Vista: didn’t use it, but I think it got a bad rep for efforts that should’ve been lauded - 7: good enough, mostly didn’t suck for web compatibility testing - 8: I’m one of the weirdos who found it very compelling… but not enough to actually use it. I’m sure it was as bad in practice as everyone who used it thinks, but I really appreciated the bold attempt at a UI for any device. And I’d been very taken by earlier Metro. - 10: seemed like a perfectly reasonable reversion to evolving 7, but also seemed like it got weirder and worse as they dug into no new versions. - 11: new version doesn’t seem to have improved things on that front. - 3.x-98: I didn’t like them, but objectively they were probably just as good as their contemporary Mac offerings just catering to different markets - ME: lol why even did this exist
- Lammy 4y ago> - ME: lol why even did this exist To get Internet Explorer 5.5 deployed as widely as possible which was their strategy pre-DOJ: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HTML_Application https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HTML_Application
- eyelidlessness 4y agoExtra lulz. I understood ME to be a stopgap in the NT transition, where 2k was supposed to be the consumer/corporate merge but that was delayed til XP for reasons… I think drivers? But of course there was IE strategy. Maybe I’m just softening because I haven’t had to deal with IE for so long, but I really do think it’s an incredible achievement that MS transitioned Windows with as little disruption as they did, with all sorts of good and bad incentives. It’s a wonder Windows even still works, much less keeping such a large majority of install base. Obviously it’s not my favorite software in the world, but I’m thoroughly impressed with what the devs have pulled off through a cartoonish timeline of priority shifts with unbelievable backcompat expectations.
- mrcarruthers 4y agoVista was a necessary evil on Microsoft's end. While yes some things weren't great (Aero), the main issue was always drivers. Microsoft had to switch the ways drivers work for some very necessary security reasons. This led to many hardware manufacturers just not making new drivers or slapping together the shitiest thing and hoping it worked. Took a few years but eventually everyone had new hardware (with decent compatible drivers), at which point 7 came out which is basically Vista with a new skin. Hell, at the end its life an up to date Vista was actually pretty decent.
- wlesieutre 4y agoTheir other issue was giving in to Intel on lowering the requirements of a "Windows Vista Capable" sticker, so a lot people were buying hardware for Vista that really shouldn't have been recommended, especially at the start of Vista's era. https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2008/03/the-vista-capable-debacle-intel-pushes-microsoft-bends/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2008/03/the-vista-capable-de...
- pjmlp 4y agoAlso the start of COM everywhere, after WinDev managed to win over DevDiv regarding Longhorn. So instead of having everyone working together to make an OS where managed stacks take the main role, as Google has managed to push no matter what, regarding Android and ChromeOS, we got Longhorn's demise and its ideas being redone in COM and C++, WinDev darlings.
- SanjayMehta 4y agoNT 3.51 was rock solid stable. 4.0 had some GUI implementation changes which made it unstable in the early days.
- grishka 4y agoLooking at it another way, 7 was the last properly-desktop one, before touchscreens ruined everything for everyone.
- kitsunesoba 4y agoWindows 7 also had the best customization/theming, followed by XP. Both 7 and XP had some amazing looking community-made .msstyle themes but 7's theme engine allowed for things like full transparency while XP was limited to 1-bit transparency. This was nice in that it offered UI looks that were more modern than the classic theme yet more understated than the gaudy Luna/Aero. Then Windows 8 came along and decided flat squares were the only option anybody could use, removing theme transparency support altogether.
- rkagerer 4y agoYeah I've been using tabbed folders in Explorer for a decade, and some theming overrides to make that more slick.
- idiocrat 4y agoI wonder what is the rational of removing features like allow for customization.
- gsich 4y agoDesigners in constant need of change, otherwise their jon would be useless.
- m-p-3 4y agoTechnical debt, requiring someone to maintain it.
- StillBored 4y agoBut then they notice they cant build a dark mode and end up reinventing it all poorly. I've come to the conclusion that 99% of the time "technical debt" particularly in old stable code that hasn't been touched in years is translation for "Its complex and I don't understand it". Particularly when asked to add what seems like a trivial feature. SOS as always, the new guy knows better than the old one, but by time time all the edge cases get reimplmented it consumes 100x the ram and runs 1/10 as fast and is just as unmaintainable, if not worse because now its written with 20 layers of OO or functional abstractions in some interpreted language that is a giant mess. Which is why when the next new guy joins its all "garbage code". Sometimes KISS is best, and it should generally be a requirement that before your allowed to throw the code away you have to refactor it a couple of times.
- insane_dreamer 4y agoI always thought XP + >=ServPack2 was the best.
- rkagerer 4y agoI'm still running it on a PC I use all the time and it's great. I do use 0patch and some other tricks to mitigate the obvious downside. If Win10 had a permanent off switch for all telemetry and better control over upbreak timing I'd switch... starting to run into software I care about dropping support (the Chrome deadline coming up is heartbreaking).
- codegeek 4y agoWindows XP wasn't bad either. Windows 98 was great as well for its time.
- Grazester 4y agoI cant remember Windows 98 offering anything over 95 OSR2.
- bombcar 4y agoI remember holding out for 98 SE which had working USB or something.
- Grazester 4y ago95 OSR2 came with USB support.
- giantrobot 4y agoWindows 98SE had a generic USB mass storage driver and generally much better USB support.
- SanjayMehta 4y agoI considered this but ending up loading Linux Mint instead with exactly the same basics.
- rasz 4y agoWindows 7 file explorer doesnt have UP arrow for traversing up the directory tree, absolutely unacceptable! :)
- JoyfulTurkey 4y agoMy personal choice for best Windows is Windows 2000. It was amazingly stable when I used it in college. I remember going to a MS sponsored talk on campus when it was in beta and we got free beta copies that were labeled NT 5 Beta! Traded that for a copy of original Starcraft. Now, I wish I would have kept it.
- running0nMT 4y agoThunderbird!
- dangus 4y agoGroan, the luddite mentality about Windows is and has always been out of control, with so many people insisting on living on decade-old software for silly pedantic reasons like "cloud crap" that can be turned off in 5 seconds. Don't move my cheese, nothing else can possibly be better, Windows peaked 10 years ago. No, my Windows 11 system doesn't use a Microsoft Account. No, I don't get ads on Windows (web search and suggestions are off, e.g., turn Windows Search settings to "classic"). All of the annoying stuff takes very little time to disable. And let's not pretend that Windows 7 didn't have people looking to turn off things about it they found annoying. [1] Don't forget that the system requirements for Windows actually decreased after 7 when Microsoft optimized it for lower spec devices. Windows 7 isn't actually all that well optimized compared to 8/8.1/10/11. Windows 10 and 11 are much better able to take advantage of hardware enhancements on modern chips that are vastly different than the hardware available over 10 years ago. How many x86 processors had big.LITTLE architecture in 2009? Because that's what Intel is shipping now. Don't forget about all the things that are massively antiquated about Windows 7 like the legacy control panel with no search function, lack of multiple desktops, lack of basic built-ins like a PDF reader, garbage command prompt and powershell, troubleshooting wizard that did nothing, Windows Update still being relatively disruptive and unreliable. Don't forget about all the things that are actually REALLY good about Windows 11 like the game bar, task manager, Linux tooling and aliases (can you run ls ~/ | grep example in a Windows 7 shell without additional software?)/PowerShell 7/SSH being preinstalled, expanded and improved window management, very clean and minimal visual design, Windows Hello biometrics (I can SSH to my Linux server with a key stored in 1Password, automatically authenticated with my fingerprint when I run the SSH command (I don't have to open 1Password manually), using the built-in Windows SSH client, can Windows 7 do that??) Windows 7 looked good because Vista was so unfinished and inappropriately matched to the contemporary hardware of the time, but in reality it wasn't anything particularly special and had plenty of missing and frustrating aspects. [1] https://www.maketecheasier.com/disable-annoying-things-in-windows-7/ https://www.maketecheasier.com/disable-annoying-things-in-wi...
- steponlego 4y agoNobody wants to fiddle with Windows to make it not spy on you. It's over.
- highwaylights 4y agoWindows 11 is the best it’s ever been. I really don’t understand everyone’s issue. I get they try to push you towards a cloud account, but you don’t have to have one, and the ads can be much easier excised than the bloatware they used to install.
- eterm 4y agoEvery time I do a "big" windows update I get 4-5 nag screens telling me I should sign up and sign in, some of which have "skip" buttons and some of which don't so you have to click "cancel" instead which to most users would probably be scared to do since they'd worry it would cancel everything instead of just "cancelling" the sign in to cloud.
- highwaylights 4y agoI agree, but you can move around those screens and keep your account offline. Do I wish they wouldn’t try to funnel you? Sure, but every tech company does this and no-one bats an eye. I’m not excusing it, just saying it’s standard behaviour in 2022 and objectively I’d rather click through those rare funnels than not if it gets me modern protections like memory isolation and secure boot. Also I really like the new UI, but I realise I’m an outlier on this.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- amaccuish 4y ago> but you don’t have to have one, A simple Google search refutes this. Ok, if you count running some cmd magic as meaning they don't require you to have a Microsoft account, we're never going to agree. For Joe Bloggs, a Microsoft account is required and there is no way around it.
- highwaylights 4y agoFair enough. I mean it’s one line in CMD, but I do see your point. That said, maybe Joe Bloggs is better off. If he’s not savvy enough to know the difference / be able to Google around it, he might be better of with an online account given he’ll probably not understand why certain things don’t work the same on his machine or care about the implications of taking his account online.
- hnlmorg 4y agoPersonally Windows 2000 was the only Microsoft operating system I’ve ever liked. And I’m including Microsoft Basic in that scope as well. XP did mature into something that was decent, but the initial release of XP was just an uglier and more system hungry version of 2000. And thus XP drive me to run Linux as my primary OS. But back when 2000 was around, most other OSs were terrible. Linux was getting close but still had a lot of rough edges. BeOS was awesome but you could tell it was a dying company. Apple were struggling too: MacOS 9 was less stable than Windows 9x (and that’s saying something!) and OS X took a couple of releases to really take off. Atari were dead. Amiga was basically only ram by enthusiasts. Yet Windows 2000 arrived and it felt genuinely like a next generation OS for its time. Windows 2000 took NT4 and focused on bettering the stuff that didn’t work rather than breaking the stuff that did. Often little changes like adding short cut keys to Notepad.exe. Whereas every version of Windows since has done far too much GUI overhaul (and always to the detriment of UX in my personal opinion) while doing very little to improve my core complaints with the OS. I get this is going to be my subjective opinion, just like Windows 7 is yours. But I did wasn’t to share a counterpoint to the praise of Windows 7.
- mmerlin 4y agowindows 11 removed many of the previous keyboard shortcuts eg ms paint annoys me so much now the keyboard accessibility degraded badly in win 11 Microsofties: Please put them ALL back to match Windows10, acknowledge the heritage of the previous version, and the years of keyboard muscle memory now flushed down the drain example, let me use the arrow keys again in popup dialogs (arrow left+right keys now do nothing... have to use the tab or shift tab or mouse in dialogs)
- pjmlp 4y agoThis kind of stuff is why while work laptop is on Windows 11, I am holding to Windows 10 on private gear. Another one, snip it doesn't work properly when using two monitors. Doesn't anyone on Windows 11 team afford having two HDPI monitors?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pieter_mj 4y agoToo many interdependent services and superfluous wan connections that can't be disabled already on windows 7, 2K was the pinnacle of usability and system configurability and sparse use of system resources, with XP closer to 2K than to 7. 7 Mostly was allright because of huge increase in availabe RAM on laptops.
- pjmlp 4y agoWindows 7 plus an evolution Android like, where COM's role get downplayed and we get .NET bindings for all major workflow, with the same performance focus of .NET Core progress would have been great. UWP was great from the point of view that .NET Native is what .NET 1.0 should have been, and C++/CX was the very first time Microsoft had anything similar to C++ Builder. However it was horrible managed, and asking everyone to keep rewriting their code isn't something that makes Windows dev community jump of joy. Now WinUI is too late for the party, too buggy, too many features lacking.