3 ms·
The «inhabitable for thousands of years» is a myth. Do you know how many people live in Hiroshima and Nagasaki today? Poeple vastly overestimate the dangerous
by littlestymaar 4y ago
The «inhabitable for thousands of years» is a myth. Do you know how many people live in Hiroshima and Nagasaki today?
Poeple vastly overestimate the dangerous of this stuff after a few years. Fukushima and Prypiat are probably safer to live than the average Asian city center due to air pollution, or even the Midwest due to pesticide exposure…
- maria2 4y agoHow many people live in the Chernobyl exclusion zone? Svetlana Alexievich interviewed some of “The Zone’s” residents in her excellent book Voices From Chernobyl. It’s not a fun place to live, unless having all your teeth fall out is fun.
- littlestymaar 4y agoDo you mean that Chornobyl resident don't get enough vitamin C? Because I can't think of a link between exposure to radio-elements and losing your teeth…
- yodelshady 4y ago[flagged]
- dredmorbius 4y agoIronic as it sounds, nuclear weapons in many ways have far shorter-term impacts than nuclear reactors. The Little Boy (Hiroshima) bomb contained 64 kg of highly-refined uranium, of which less than 1 kg fissioned, the remainder being vapourised in the ensuing blast and distributed over a wide area. That dispersal in large part reduces the risk of radioactivity as it is so highly diluted. The rule of thumb for nuclear blasts is the "seven-ten rule": every sevenfold increase in hours from the blast reduces residual radiation by a factor of 10. That rule-of-thumb is an approximation, but with nearly 7^7 hours since the blast, radiation by that rule would be one ten-millionth the level 1 hour following the blast. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_fallout#The_seven-ten_rule https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_fallout#The_seven-ten_...> Chernobyl put 400 times more radioactive material into the atmosphere than the Hiroshima bomb: <https://www.scifacts.net/earth/chernobyl-400-times-more-radioactive-atomic-bomb-hiroshima/ https://www.scifacts.net/earth/chernobyl-400-times-more-radi...> It's also worth noting that Chernobyl, and several other presently-operating nuclear power plants are in the middle of a war zone and have been the site of active fighting, bombardment, and missile strikes. I don't find a figure for the mass of the Elephant's Foot at Chernobyl, though it's clearly many tonnes of matter. In the case of Fukushima, the total reactor core and fuel waste on site is measured in hundreds of tonnes, with 560 tonnes of reactor fuel, from melted-down reactors, on site. <https://www.citizen.org/news/how-much-radioactive-material-is-at-the-fukushima-plant/ https://www.citizen.org/news/how-much-radioactive-material-i...> (There's another 680 tonnes of spent waste fuel, presumably in containment, on site. I'm excluding that from this discussion as that happens to be a managed waste stream.) The immediate vicinity of both Chernobyl and Fukushima will in fact be uninhabitable and restricted for at least many centuries, if not thousands of years.
- littlestymaar 4y agoYour elephant foot argument is a good summary of what you get wrong: in a nuclear plant there are tons of radioactive material, but even in the scenario of an accident, most of it stays inside the plant, and only the elements that are light enough to get vaporized by the accident's temperature are actually going to the atmosphere. In a nuclear bomb detonation, even the uranium or plutonium itself is vaporized and spread over the area. And the heavy material falls out much more quickly than the light one, so the dispersal is actually lower than the small fraction that leave the site in a nuclear accident. That doesn't mean nuclear accident are harmless, quite the contrary, because iodine for instance is being spread very far away from the plant and it has the nasty effect of being at the same time very radioactive, and very easily metabolizable. Also, you're confusing radiation (rays hits you when you just stays here) with contamination (you've ingested a radioactive particle and now it's going to release it's rays inside of your body, eventually causing cancer). Radiation is really unlikely to cause trouble unless you're really close to a highly radioactive source (next to nuclear bomb detonation, inside a criticality incident, or a few very rare scenarios like that). That's a common mistake to make but that highlights your misunderstanding of the topic. > The immediate vicinity of both Chernobyl and Fukushima will in fact be uninhabitable and restricted for at least many centuries, if not thousands of years. Maybe the few square kilometers around it, but this is also the case for most heavy industrial activities (heavy metal levels are typically way off limits in these places) but the exclusion zone as a whole will not. In fact, in Fukushima it was already safe enough back in 2016![1], and in fact it has been slowly re-opened for people to live in, Futaba[2] being the last city to reopen[3] in 2022. So much to the thousands of years! And you can even visit the Fukushima Daiishi power plant itself today[4]. Growing crop or raising cattle there will stay ill-advised for a few more decades though, because the only real risk at this point comes from ingestion of Cesium 137. The two reasons why it stays restricted for longer than needed are: 1. nuclear inspires a deep irrational fear that other carcinogenic pollutants do not, even when they are in fact much more dangerous. 2. Neither Japan nor Ukraine really have need for these land since they've had an anemic demography for decades, unlike in 1945 where abandoning the land of Hiroshima and Nagasaki would have been impossible. [1]: https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-35761136 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-35761136 [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Futaba,_Fukushima https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Futaba,_Fukushima [3]: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/feb/16/futaba-last-fukushima-town-to-reopen-welcomes-back-its-first-residents https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/feb/16/futaba-last-fu... [4]: https://blog.japanwondertravel.com/fukushima-exclusion-zone-tour-is-it-safe-to-visit-41130 https://blog.japanwondertravel.com/fukushima-exclusion-zone-...