3 ms·
It would be unethical if the tables were turned and ordinary citizens were getting their emails released. It would be unethical if a company properly secured t
by angersock 15y ago
It would be unethical if the tables were turned and ordinary citizens were getting their emails released.
It would be unethical if a company properly secured their servers.
It would be educational if ordinary citizens expected their communications to be completely private without taking reasonable measure to assure same.
This is a great lesson in security.
I supported the wikileaks 'collateral damage' video leak, because I think its important that our government be transparent and its citizen understand the ramifications of going to war. But this, I can't support it.
One of the ramifications of going to war, like it or not, is increased scrutiny. This is a weaker form of the "collateral damage" that our politicians and bureaucrats routinely write off.
- angersock 15y agoAlright, so, anyone care to put effort into a reply as opposed to solely downvotes?
- danilocampos 15y ago> It would be unethical if a company properly secured their servers. My guess is that this is the root. It's unethical for you to walk into my house and read my mail regardless of whether I locked the door that morning or not. I'm not losing any sleep over this particular leak, just saying, what I quoted is probably their beef.
- angersock 15y agoI mean, that's an interesting question, right? I've copied the information in your mail to myself without harming the original. If I burned your letter, I've absolutely committed a wrong, but I didn't do that. If you fail to lock your door, you are in effect allowing this possibility. If you communicate over a "clear" channel, without taking steps to encrypt that data, you are again allowing this. That's why I don't view this as a valid moral claim.
- earbitscom 15y agoCould the same not be said for having windows made of glass? You did not build your entire house of steel and deadbolt locks, so you have allowed this possibility and therefore I am entitled to come into your house.
- danilocampos 15y agoThat may be true, but most jurisdictions recognize an inherent right to physical privacy which isn't lost based on how securely the premises are sealed. So, the truly problematic part is the trespassing and/or burglary (illicitly entering a building, regardless of destruction or theft of property, meets the test). The law around extracting information from a physical place is something I don't really know about. But either way, we have a parallel in the unlawful access of shit that isn't yours.
- noahc 15y agoYou're argument is essentially the "She deserved to be raped" argument. I understand that your argument is a bit more nuanced than this because of the idea of harm you introduced. But at it's simpliest core you argue that "Hey, you made it easier and the possibility exists..." It's the same way with rape. "Hey she was wearing a short skirt and was drunk, the possibility exists." We should be able to to agree that because I make something easier for you to do that doesn't mean you are free and clear to do it. If you want to have this debate it shouldn't be about the ease of which someone allows another to take a particular action. Instead, we should debate about if we believe we should secure in papers and from who. In a world in which non-political actors have more power than political actors that's an interesting question!
- figgles 15y agoWell, let's see. If you're a hot chick, drunk as hell, staggering around in the dark alleys of a big city in the bad part of town, you should at least be less surprised that it is rape-o-clock.
- electromagnetic 15y ago> I've copied the information in your mail to myself without harming the original. If you opened mail from my physical mailbox, you'd have committed the federal crime of mail tampering, which faces a fine and/or jail time. If you opened 3.3 million letters from my mail box, you'd probably be the first person to live the remainder of their life in jail for mail tampering... regardless of your age. My mail is stored in an easily accessible box at the end of my driveway. If it has any form of lock, you're committing a much more serious crime. When you're hacking into a passworded system to steal email, your crime should be treated with just severity. Not only should it be regarded as committing a federal crime, but there should be charges for breaking the lock too (I'm against the DMCA's whole copyright circumvention bullshit, because it hurts the little guy. But no protection against email fraud hurts the little guy.) > If you fail to lock your door, you are in effect allowing this possibility. If you communicate over a "clear" channel, without taking steps to encrypt that data, you are again allowing this. That's why I don't view this as a valid moral claim. If I fail to lock my door, it's still immoral to enter my property and steal everything. Just as it's immoral to enter my unlockable mailbox and steal my mail. If you don't find it immoral for someone else to read your mail then honestly you should have no qualms with posting the entire contents of all your email addresses online for us to scrutinize as well. If there's no immorality about stealing a corporations emails, containing hundreds or thousands of peoples personal emails and information then you should have no morality problems about HN trawling your own emails. Regardless of if I lock my door or not, I have a right not to have my property looted. Regardless of if I use a strong or weak password for my email, I have the right to not have my property looted. My problem with this world is people like you, who will be the first to scream fucking murder when some trivial wrong happens to you but you claim everyone else has no moral claim for not doing everything you deem appropriate. Get off your fucking high horse and learn the god damn definition of morals because at least knowing the definition might help you find a set. I'm giving myself a 99% chance of being down voted, but put your money where your mouth is. I want to see your goddamn emails.
- earbitscom 15y agoThe post was clear that they did not do this to prove the security flaws. They did it because they believe this information should be made public for the good of the public. Nearly everyone in this forum opposes SOPA's attempt to shut down websites without a trial. Effectively subpoenaing private communication between suspected criminals without a court order and making those emails public requires much the same infringement of basic rights. So you have to ask yourself, "Do I approve of private citizens and organizations taking actions such as these if they believe they're helping fight crime?" And then ask yourself whether you're talking about the release of these emails, or SOPA.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- jonhendry 15y ago" "Do I approve of private citizens and organizations taking actions such as these if they believe they're helping fight crime?"" Crime? If every fringe nutcase gets to decide what is crime, and act on that, then it's likely you've committed somebody's idea of a crime, and so has everyone else. So far the accusations of Stratfor's evil have been about as meaningful as the British people who threatened a pediatrician, ignorantly thinking she was a pedophile. I don't see anyone railing against the crimes of Jane's, or the Economist Intelligence Unit. Probably because they know nothing whatsoever about the industry and don't even know those organizations exist.
- jaylevitt 15y agoI think you're in violent agreement, and that this was the point of "if THEY believe they're helping fight crime".
- garethsprice 15y agoIt's pointless, causing a lot of people a lot of trouble with no clear upside. Even the Pastebin admits that Stratfor doesn't seem to be involved in anything shady, but they're going to release all their e-mails anyway just in case. It's a witch hunt. There is no best case scenario from releasing this data. The point that even security companies can't guarantee security has been made, all that releasing the data can do is turn public sentiment against Antisec and towards "whatever it takes to stop this kind of thing".
- jonhendry 15y ago"The point that even security companies can't guarantee security has been made" But in their nerd rage tunnel vision they still haven't figured out that not all security is internet security, and not all security-related companies are internet security companies. There are valid non-computer matters of security, such as "Is the Lord's Resistance Army active around this particular village at this time?" which would be crucial if, say, you're sending some doctors in to work in that village. Or "How active are the Maoist militants in India?" Basically, the Anonymous people don't have the faintest clue what Stratfor does, or why you would turn to them or similar firms for information. "It's a witch hunt." And a publicity stunt.