3 ms·
In an effort to make this a little less political and a little more geeky: Say we have a binary relation R (so we write x R y to say x is related to y by R) S
by 082349872349872 4y ago
In an effort to make this a little less political and a little more geeky:
Say we have a binary relation R (so we write x R y to say x is related to y by R)
Say this relation is also transitive, so whenever x R y and y R z we always have that x R z
We notice transitivity can be extended over N-hops, not just 2. So what is 0-hop transitivity? We usually call that reflexivity: we always have that x R x
Now we come to the crux: is our relation symmetric, or antisymmetric, or something else?
Ignoring the third case; with an antisymmetric relation, we have either x R y xor y R x, but never both; with a symmetric relation whenever we have x R y we also always have y R x.
Crudely put, the cartoon conservative wants more antisymmetric relations, and the cartoon progressive wants more symmetric relations.
Before the 1960s, many european languages were antisymmetric in 2nd person pronouns: the superior would say tu/du to the inferior; the inferior would say vous/Sie to the superior. ([Edit:Counter example]: one says "thou" and not "you" to God)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/T–V_distinction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/T–V_distinction
Since the 1960s, we've moved to a symmetric use of these pronouns. The V form is more formal, but if one party uses vous/Sie the other party will mirror it. Similarly the T form is more informal, and if a company (such as McDo) addresses their customers as tu/du, they'd be fools to think they will be addressed in return as anything else.
Lagniappe: cf "Weak Components Revived" on https://www-cs-faculty.stanford.edu/~knuth/news.html https://www-cs-faculty.stanford.edu/~knuth/news.html for a discussion of structure in graphs of the third kind, having a mix of symmetric and antisymmetric relations.
- DoctorOW 4y ago> In an effort to make this a little less political and a little more geeky Is there a demand for essays like this? I've been playing around with an idea where I take some of the more talked about legislation and present a semi-neutral deep dive into the actual facts of the matter.
- f_devd 4y agoI think it depends on the structure, I find the structure of GP always very engaging: X (technical or not) can be represented as structure Y (math/cs). Side note: I suppose this would be the informal version of type/category theory?
- 082349872349872 4y agocategorical objects are "up to isomorphism" so the symmetric relations are in the kernel (the identity arrow for each object), and the arrows in the category reflect the antisymmetric relations.
- giraffe_lady 4y agoIsn't the bible example kind of a counterpoint? God says thou but you also say it back. You tutoie god in french too and I assume other languages with this distinction. Which is a good example of how this system doesn't only convey status but also intimacy.
- 082349872349872 4y agovery good point! I was just looking at KJV and it is indeed "why hast thou forsaken". (one might argue that there is much in the NT that argues against maintaining hierarchical relationships, but that's probably for a different thread...) Erratum: change "NB" to "Counter Example" above. PS. Re-listening to Lady Marmalade, and while normally « voulez vous baiser ...» would be even more unlikely than « passez le joint, s'il vous plaît », maybe in the context of a paid transaction, addressing a john, the V form would indeed have been used?
- giraffe_lady 4y agoI'm not at all a biblical scholar or anything but iirc there are two reasons one historical one theological. The hebrew and aramaic of the old testament had the distinction between singular and plural second person pronouns but without the hierarchy/formality distinction. Later languages did have that, so translating into them using the singular also gave the connotation of familiarity that eventually became accepted. And then, in the gospels christ instructs his followers to pray to god intimately, when he gives them the lord's prayer. It's giving explicit permission to address god as a personal relation: you can call THE LORD daddy now. In that context it makes sense to use the informal/intimate form, basically reconciling what was probably the earlier usage anyway. It's unclear to me if pre-christian jews would have considered themselves to have this level of intimacy with god. Actually it's unclear to me whether contemporary jews or muslims do for that matter. In french it's a pretty subtle social practice to know which to use in any given situation. There are a lot of situations where it's pretty obvious or firm but others where it's flexible or depends on specifics of context. It's also a moving target since social norms like this are always changing.
- 4y ago
- 082349872349872 4y agorelated: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34017545 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34017545
- theGnuMe 4y agoWhat advantage do asymmetric connections give you? Does it enforce a hierarchy?
- 082349872349872 4y agobasically yes ==== pedantically no: antisymmetric connections give us an acyclic graph (DAG), whose reachability is a partial order. if we say there are always minimum and maximum elements (adding some[0] if needed), antisymmetric connections give us a graph where we can always find a least common superior and greatest common inferior. In the special case when a = lcs(a,b), we say that a is superior to b, and always find that also gci(a,b) = b, b is inferior to a. symmetric connections give us an undirected graph, whose reachability is an equivalence relation. (asymmetric is just not symmetric, which is a distinct notion) [0] eg under feudalism, we might say that all nobles are inferior to the divine, but any noble is superior to all commoners, so [divine,commoners] are our added maximum and minimum. Exercise: under what conditions is an acylic graph a tree; ie the DAG of antisymmetric connections is a hierarchy?
- theGnuMe 4y agoa rooted tree