4 ms·
This line of reasoning makes no sense to me. If the government was better at building things than "profiteers," why shouldn't we just have the government build
by rayiner 4y ago
This line of reasoning makes no sense to me. If the government was better at building things than "profiteers," why shouldn't we just have the government build everything? Why shouldn't the government make cell phones and iPads? Why does Silicon Valley even exist?
In fact, we tried your proposal at scale. Nearly every developed country privatized electricity generation in the 1980s. Many countries, like India, still have state-owned power companies. If they were better, we would know.
- makotech221 4y agoGo look at china. They have 100x more clean energy than we do.
- prottog 4y agoChina's grid is roughly 2322 TWh or 28% renewable, versus the US grid at roughly 857 TWh or 21%. 100x is beyond a gross exaggeration. Crucially, China still has 67% of generation from fossil fuel sources vs. the US at 61%.
- rayiner 4y agoGermany was at 40% renewables last year, and its electric generation sector is private. The UK—which privatized its electric generation under Thatcher back in the 1980s—was at 43%. China was at 29%.
- selimthegrim 4y agoDoes low cost Russian gas count as public or private