3 ms·
This is only measuring the time from first shovel to completion. In reality, the period before first shovel is often much longer. Best case scenario is China
by bryanlarsen 4y ago
This is only measuring the time from first shovel to completion. In reality, the period before first shovel is often much longer.
Best case scenario is China, where it takes them about 3 years to do the planning and then 2 years to do the build. In the US it seems to be about 20 + 20. I can see the build phase coming down to about 5 years, but it's hard to imagine the planning phase taking less than 10...
And it's not the nuclear part of the regulation that makes it slow in the US. In a country where it takes over 30 years to go from initial planning to completion of High Speed Rail, every big project seems to take forever and cost way too much. Nuclear specific regulation doesn't help, but I don't think it's the primary problem.
- sct202 4y agoEven in China it takes a while, China's Sanman power plant uses the same Westinghouse reactor design as Vogtle in Georgia. Both started plants construction in 2009, and Sanman finished 9 years late, while Vogtle is slated to finish next year.
- ShredKazoo 4y agoWhy can't we just hire companies from whichever country builds nuclear the best to build plants in our country?
- Schroedingersat 4y agoPrice wise, that's China, and most countries rightly don't want to have an ongoing absolute dependence on China for their energy. Second best is Russia, a bunch of countries did this and now a big chunk of Europe depends on a hostile power for half of their nuclear fuel and for parts. Third best is South Korea and they just charged Saudi Arabia $5/W with an extra $4/W in mandatory service fees (no labour included). Their plants at home are also not great reliability wise and their nuclear industry keeps getting caught forging documents. Fourth by price or tied first by effectiveness is the US, they can't do it for under $10 and they're famously good sports about controlling other countries' energy infrastructure. Then there's Japan and France, and they're in the news a bunch for some reason lately. Finland and UK bought the latest French model and they are going just peachy. Taishan (another EPR) was also pretty dismal for a Chinese plant, but was at least mostly on time when it started leaking. Alternatively buy renewables which are generally below the (much smaller) budget and on time from China, South Korea, USA or many places in Europe. The whole intermittency thing is largely just a scare campaign from coal, and the emissions avoided per dollar are far better.
- TazeTSchnitzel 4y agoChina has built an impressive amount of high speed rail in the last two decades, but I expect they must have been planning that through the 90's, and the amount is probably because they dared to construct several projects simultaneously.