5 ms·
Echoing David Sacks, he's now tweeting that the journalists in question were tweeting 'assassination coordinates.' https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/16035879
by anigbrowl 4y ago
Echoing David Sacks, he's now tweeting that the journalists in question were tweeting 'assassination coordinates.'
https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1603587970832793600 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1603587970832793600
Starting to think there might be some national security issues with one guy being the nominal linchpin of the US space program, satellite internet, and global public messaging infrastructure.
- lambic2 4y agoBut aren't the coordinates of his plane public anyways? And wouldn't shutting down ElonJet account be enough, why all these journalists' accounts as well?
- kevingadd 4y agoYeah, it was public ADS-B data. A lot of the suspended journalists never even posted his location, they just posted about the situation or the supposed stalker incident.
- TheHappyOddish 4y agoFrom what I've read, this is untrue. He has requested a privacy ICAO (https://nbaa.org/aircraft-operations/security/privacy/privacy-icao-address-pia/ https://nbaa.org/aircraft-operations/security/privacy/privac...), and as such the ownership was not public. The data published was not just ADS-B data, but ADS-B data + content intended to violate the specific privacy ICAO. I'm not defending Musks actions, simply providing additional context.
- pera 4y agoWell ADS-B Exchange just got suspended (https://twitter.com/ADSBexchange https://twitter.com/ADSBexchange) so it seems that publishing public radio data is now against their TOS.
- TheHappyOddish 4y agoI believe that ADS-B Exhange (like the suspended journalists) linked to ElonJet's Mastodon account. This is consistent with the policy - even if that policy isn't agreeable - and doesn't seem to indicate that publishing public radio data is banned.
- lambic2 4y agoIs there any evidence/source that shows the suspended journalists actually linked ElonJet's Mastodon account? I thought they only mentioned ElonJet's Twitter handle.
- TheHappyOddish 4y agoThat's what I've read, ironically on Twitter. The JoinMastodon account definitely did. This article from TC confirms: https://techcrunch.com/2022/12/15/elon-musk-suspends-mastodon-twitter-account-over-elonjet-tracking/ https://techcrunch.com/2022/12/15/elon-musk-suspends-mastodo... Also I get journalists are feeling threatened, but it's a shame to see such a clear emotionally charged article from TC, I used to trust them for unbiased tech reporting.
- lambic2 4y agoI'm curious, can you point me to a sentence that you find "emotionally charged"? I went over every sentence and every one just states some facts. I'm not seeing the emotionally charged part.
- lambic2 4y agoThe article confirms that Elon suspends link to Mastodons, but doesn't say anything about the journalists posting links to the Mastodon account for ElonJen.
- TheHappyOddish 4y agoApologies, the TC article states why the JoinMastodon account was suspended: > Twitter apparently suspended its open source competitor Mastodon from the service on Thursday afternoon. Just prior to its suspension, Mastodon (@joinmastodon) tweeted a link to the jet tracking account on its own service, according to archives.
- _djo_ 4y agoThis claim keeps being made, but Musk’s aircraft is fully visible in the FAA registry data and doesn’t have an obfuscated ICAO hex code. It wasn’t part of the PIA programme, which is also not something endorsed by the ICAO but only used by the FAA within US borders. When flying abroad an aircraft must use its static ICAO address. Even if it was there’s still nothing wrong with tracking the aircraft and nothing illegal about people matching the rolling ICAO hex codes to the real aircraft. It frustrates me that we’ve allowed Musk to completely redefine the conversation around something that was already settled and accepted: 1. Flight tracking data, collected from ADS-B, is legal and publicly available. Aircraft ownership data is public too. 2. Nobody has a right to keeping their aircraft movements private, and aircraft movements != personal movements. 3. After much lobbying the FAA introduced LADD & PIA, but they say outright that it’s not a guarantee of confidentiality and just makes it slightly harder to track an aircraft. 4. PIA temporary ICAO codes can only be rotated every 60 days (going down to 20) and it’s pitifully easy for any aircraft spotter, as have hung around airports for decades, to match a new one to an aircraft registration.
- jdong 4y ago>1. Flight tracking data, collected from ADS-B, is legal and publicly available. Aircraft ownership data is public too. Not legal in Europe. You can't legally collect this (or any other PII) for fun, you'd need particularly strong reasons to do so without consent. Mobile phones also broadcast their IMEIs and location, it would be similarly illegal to collect and store those signals to track phone movements. >2. Nobody has a right to keeping their aircraft movements private, and aircraft movements != personal movements. While not all aircraft movements are personal movements, many are.
- _djo_ 4y agoAgain, please provide any substantive evidence for that claim. Private aircraft are neither private cars nor private phones and have he ever been treated equivalently under EU law. You’re reasoning through false analogies.
- 4y ago
- whywhywhywhy 4y agoThe journalists posted links to it to no? To try and sneak around the rules but still do the same as the banned account. Wasn’t about his plane anyway someone in a mask made a threat on a car his child was being driven in thinking it was Elon.
- jacquesm 4y agoFull-on paranoia.
- xracy 4y agoHonestly this is scary. Someone with a lot of power and sway over speech and other things getting paranoid that people are after him, and lashing out at any perceived threat is scary. It would be scary if he didn't have half the power he currently holds.
- ModernMech 4y agoWould be scarier if we hadn’t just endured 4 years of the exact same thing with Trump. Scarier thing to me now is that people somehow still can’t see guys like Musk and Trump (malignant narcissists both) coming from a mile away.
- jacquesm 4y agoIt very much explains the 'strong man' concept and why people fell for it in the past.
- 082349872349872 4y agoSee Bob Altemeyer for research into "people who are willing to follow strong men" (authoritarian followers)
- giantrobot 4y agoIf Musk dropped off the face of the Earth tomorrow it wouldn't meaningfully affect operations at SpaceX. If anything it would probably increase productivity there.
- azernik 4y agoThat is, to put it mildly, not the worst case scenario people are worried about.
- akmarinov 4y agoGlobal? Twitter’s barely used in Europe, let alone Asia and Africa.
- intvocoder 4y agoCouldn’t say anything for Eastern Europe, but it’s rather popular in Western Europe and Japan, which is where the ad dollars are.
- mschuster91 4y ago> Starting to think there might be some national security issues with one guy being the nominal linchpin of the US space program, satellite internet, and global public messaging infrastructure. Which is why there are rumors and calls floating around that the US government should seize control over Starlink and SpaceX, e.g. [1], for national security issues. The entire debate perfectly shows why neither complete government control over such programs nor complete private control is good - Boeing/ULA were milking the government for cash and acted as pork distributers for decades while showing not much progress, and Starlink's actions in Ukraine show the dangers that independent actors can wield over US foreign policy. [1] https://fee.org/articles/former-bush-speechwriter-says-feds-should-plan-to-seize-starlink-form-elon-musk/ https://fee.org/articles/former-bush-speechwriter-says-feds-...