6 ms·
I don't get why he had to sue under that law: fraud is fraud and bait and switch is fraud too.
by tomjen3 15y ago
I don't get why he had to sue under that law: fraud is fraud and bait and switch is fraud too.
- mfringel 15y agoSee my comment above. IANAL, but "fraud" looks like it would be a very hard case to prove.
- tptacek 15y agoIANAL, but "bait and switch" is usually a specific thing; for instance, in Illinois, it's covered by the Illinois Consumer Fraud statutes. The general concept of "baiting and switching" is not automatically considered "fraud". To win a fraud case, this person would need to cite specific material false statements provided by Seagate, and then additionally establish through a preponderance of evidence that those misstatements were made knowingly with the intent to trick him. Since they actually gave the guy a job and paid him for 9 months, that could end up being hard to do. Note also that this cuts both ways. You probably don't want every business to find itself in the situation of having to fend off fraud claims any time it dismisses someone after less than a year's employment, or being in the situation of not being able to terminate someone for performance after having relied on that person in a sales process somewhere.
- jetti 15y ago" bait and switch is fraud too" That doesn't make much sense....they offered him a job with a salary and he got there and was given a job with a salary. Not like he got there and they had a car with a sandwich waiting for him and a note that says "Sorry :(". Bottom line, bait and switch is a consumer law not employment law.
- marshray 15y agoIf they knew at the time they the job was only temporary (i.e., they had planned in advance to dispose of him after a short time) yet they presented it to him as a "full time permanent" position ... obviously it's not the same as the classic car dealership B&S, but it doesn't seem like honest dealing either.
- jetti 15y agoWhat about the flip side, an employee who takes a job knowing that it isn't permanent and will jump ship giving the first opportunity (which could be in as little as 6 months). Is that wrong? These situations are always possible because most (if not all) states are at-will states.
- marshray 15y agoI'm thinking in your scenario the employee probably didn't entice the employer (under false pretenses) to terminate whatever their previous arrangement was and relocate to MN, with a much smaller job market.