4 ms·
The missing thing: international incentive structures. Today, most things are done the most economical way. And that might involve emitting carbon. A coun
by londons_explore 4y ago
The missing thing: international incentive structures.
Today, most things are done the most economical way. And that might involve emitting carbon.
A country which regulates the emissions of carbon will end up producing goods and services using carbon free methods - but those methods will often be less economically efficient than the carbon producing method, even at scale.
So any country that goes all in on the carbon-free world will end up economically worse off -- it's goods won't be competitive in the global marketplace. A government cannot subsidize itself to competitiveness in all markets.
Solve that problem, and the world will decarbonize itself almost overnight.
- tdaltonc 4y agoYou might be interested in the EUs new carbon border adjustment tax. https://www.ft.com/content/51e6bd85-dbb2-4071-b635-8ab9bd2ab95b https://www.ft.com/content/51e6bd85-dbb2-4071-b635-8ab9bd2ab...
- londons_explore 4y agoIt appears that all solutions to this problem require one of: * All countries to agree on an incentive scheme (unlikely - although big trading blocs like EU/China/Russia/USA might be able to bully the rest of the world into it with the threat of sanctions if they do not agree) * Some countries to agree on a scheme, and to break WTO rules to penalize (carbon tax) imports and subsidize exports to/from those who do not. Or... the world continues on the current trajectory of decarbonizing highly visible things only (Electric cars, solar panels on the roof!) to appease voters while avoiding decarbonizing anything that much affects nationwide competitiveness (eg. steel/fertilizer production).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- toiletfuneral 4y ago
- theptip 4y agoYC can’t solve that. I agree it’s an important cause, but it’s really hard coordination problem. If we can make progress without, just by using tech to lower emissions, that’s a clear win. Having said that, a CO2 tax just makes the financial incentives for change better; someone still needs to build the better system after funds are reallocated. So if you already started a cost-reduction startup, you’ll have first-mover advantage when the CO2 taxes come into play.
- beachy 4y ago> So any country that goes all in on the carbon-free world will end up economically worse off -- it's goods won't be competitive in the global marketplace. A government cannot subsidize itself to competitiveness in all markets. Isn't this just the tragedy of the commons writ large? It makes no sense for anyone really to make personal sacrifices for the planet. Why should I stay at home riding my pushbike to the artisan markets when my neighbour will gleefully fly to Hawaii for his holidays, undoing in a few days whatever carbon reductions I've achieved in a year? The logical course is to accept that your actions mean nothing and live a greedy life, amassing wealth at the cost of the planet's health and hoarding it for when things get bad, whether that's this generation or the next.