7 ms·
Certain things lend themselves well to master-planning. TCP/IP, or where transit lines are run before the city builds up around them. But only things that reall
by bombcar 4y ago
Certain things lend themselves well to master-planning. TCP/IP, or where transit lines are run before the city builds up around them. But only things that really need to be master-planned do better when planned that way; much of the best "large things" seem to work out better when many of the aspects are organic and human-scale.
- CrazyStat 4y ago> where transit lines are run before the city builds up around them. I'm not sure even this is true. The city may not build up in the way the planners anticipated. Even if it does, it will change over time.
- bombcar 4y agoYeah, the main advantage of pre-building is that land is cheap and nobody's using it, vs post-building where you know where the density is but you have to get the land. In the cases I know of the density followed upon building the line, but that may not be universally true.
- thewataccount 4y agoFrom my experience playing factorio, the best way to approach it is to plan out the areas you are building to allow future "backtracking" possible - increase space between buildings, ensure new "roads" are "reasonably" arranged to allow future expansion, etc. An example of this is ensuring that driveways/building distances are a certain minimum from the road, allowing you to expand a 2 lane road to 3, etc. You build your infrastructure to, or just past the edges of what you know is being built, and make sure you reserve space past that to accompany further expansion. The lets you expand the ~factory~ city while still allowing some sanity to the underlying infrastructure. * This will likely apply to anything that needs both preplanning and unknown future expansion such as codebases
- bombcar 4y agoYou see stuff like that done in some places (eg: https://goo.gl/maps/q4Qm1cjjF9rA6MQY6 https://goo.gl/maps/q4Qm1cjjF9rA6MQY6 - the "highway" has space all around it for expansion, and has had that for decades from when there was nothing there)
- microtherion 4y agoThat looks like an utterly car dependent community. I don't think you can have walkability without fairly dense construction.
- alksjdalkj 4y agoThey aren't independent, the city will tend to build up along the transit lines due to the easy access to transit. E.g., the NYC outer boroughs and the DC metro area.
- Eleison23 4y agoThat may be true for immovable train lines, but vehicle transit such as buses have routes which are subject to change, and therefore developers cannot depend on the transit lines being there in 10-20 years. Bus lines instead tend to follow where the traffic wants to go. Around here, many shopping malls double as bus stations because the primary aim of transit seems to be circulating consumers around places they will spend money.
- wins32767 4y agoConsider the income levels of the staff that work at shopping malls and what that implies for their ability to pay for reliable personal transportation.
- toast0 4y ago> Bus lines instead tend to follow where the traffic wants to go. Around here, many shopping malls double as bus stations because the primary aim of transit seems to be circulating consumers around places they will spend money. This is circular reasoning though. Bus lines go to the mall, but malls are built where the bus lines go. Malls use a lot of space, so carving out a little bit for transit is easy.
- mattpallissard 4y agoMaybe not so much the where, but the how (zoning regs) matter. In SLC, the roads are pleasantly wide for a city it's age. Turns out they had to be wide enough for a wagon to turn around. Trying to avoid painting yourself into a corner without over thinking is the game.
- vkou 4y ago> The city may not build up in the way the planners anticipated. It might not, but planners have a lot of forcing functions. For example, if they build a transformational backbone, and nobody uses some part of it, they can fix it, by say, moving major government offices to that area. Residents, other businesses, services will follow suit. What doesn't work is half-assed planning, where you have a grand, but myopic vision, implement it, and never adjust after-the-fact.
- puffoflogic 4y agoIn what sense is TCP/IP master-planned? TCP has tons of options, and one of its key components, the congestion control algorithm, is unspecified and left up to client choice. Both of these facts have led to significant improvements, but even greater improvements were obtained by dumping TCP altogether, in large part because TCP ossified due to middleware behaving as if TCP were master-planned when it isn't. TCP, at least, is an anti-example to your point!
- pclmulqdq 4y agoSo is IP - which version are we talking about? The out-of-address-space v4 that wasn't future-proof enough to conceive of more than 4 billion computers? Or the reinvented ipv6 that seems to have gone way too far in the other direction (and not just in terms of address size)?
- pjlegato 4y agoAt a broader level, TCP/IP was just one of many competing networking technologies. Nobody master planned which one would win. That emerged organically through gradual decentralized convergence as many individual actors concluded TCP/IP was in some sense "better" than the alternatives.