6 ms·
Unmentioned is the origin of much of this value: > McMaster-Carr shoppers don’t encounter distractions; you can see proof of this on the homepage which jumps r
by gumby 4y ago
Unmentioned is the origin of much of this value:
> McMaster-Carr shoppers don’t encounter distractions; you can see proof of this on the homepage which jumps right into the action:
The web site is based on the paper catalogue (book), from layout, visual interface, and organization. The paper version was excellent and useful. Instead of trying all sorts of "fun" (for the designer) web capabilities, they focused on ohw the web could augment what they were already successfully doing. No redesign for design's sake.
Some of the best paper catalogues like McMaster and Sigma had excellent, customer-centered design, which led to long term loyalty. Easy to find what you needed, and useful as references, not just as a place to buy. They have retained that philosophy into the web world.
Compare this to, say, Amazon where Amazon's needs are prioritized over the customers', with the obvious result of reduced loyalty and the need to shore that up with rewards (prime, discounts, advertising).
- analog31 4y agoI learned so much from keeping a copy of the yellow catalog in the bathroom. Like, how many different kinds of nuts and bolts and fittings there are. I still remember that stuff when a colleague is trying to design something. In addition to a paper catalog that "just worked," they started out with a business that just worked, before the Internet came along. I'd say that Mouser and Digi-Key stand out in that regard too. About 25 years ago I remember calling McMaster and ordering a heavy steel machine base. It showed up the next day on a flat bed truck, and had to be unloaded with the forklift. It must have been drop shipped from their supplier, meaning they had already worked out a huge amount of logistics stuff before ever going online.
- hammock 4y ago>Compare this to, say, Amazon where Amazon's needs are prioritized over the customers' I'm not sure that's the whole story. A critical point is that this is a B2B site. The people shopping here would tend to have a need in mind that can be solved by finding the exact right part that meets their specifications. By comparison, the typical consumer shopping experience is much more one of discovery, not need-solution mnatching. Keep in mind the average HN user is not the typical shopper. You and I might like to "get in and get out" but so many consumer shoppers LOVE to go to a place like Target or HomeGoods and browse around aimlessly, window shop, discover, explore - and that indicates a far different type of UX than what B2B would look like. These shoppers value stimulus, sparks of ideas, reviews and testimonials, and all the other "cruft" that was removed from McMaster.com
- TeMPOraL 4y agoWonder how much of that is actually a preference of typical consumers, and how much it is just being forced on them. > stimulus, sparks of ideas, reviews and testimonials, and all the other "cruft" that was removed from McMaster.com In meatspace this is often discussed as customer-abusive design - overloading senses with shapes, colors, sounds and smells, confusing and ever-changing shop layout forcing shoppers to wander and explore, defeating the no.1. normal people advice for responsible shopping - make a list beforehand and stick to it. I don't think HNers are that much different. We complain more, because we know more about how the web works, and realize things could be much better.
- geodel 4y agoGreat point. At this point it is pretty clear Amazon is fattened on sweet billions from ads. To add insult to injury they also get to say We are delighted to offer ten thousand brands of USB cable in hundreds of colors to suit every personal style
- yamtaddle 4y ago> Wonder how much of that is actually a preference of typical consumers, and how much it is just being forced on them. I can just about guarantee it's mostly the latter. My elderly dad was shown how to do a couple things on Craigslist, years ago, and has been using it without assistance for years. Meanwhile he often has to ask for help with the fucking phone app on his phone. And every time Google updates it or he gets a new phone, he has to figure it all out again. For no benefit, just to be able to do the same shit he already could. Design thrashing and all kinds of slow-downs and animations and "helpful" pop-ups and crap make things harder on everyone, it's just that some of us can push past it. It has a cost, but we become blind to it because we're so used to putting up with it. A few seconds lost there, a couple minutes here, but we've forgotten about it by the end of the day. For those on the edges it's catastrophic to their ability to actually use their devices for anything.
- gumby 4y agoOrdinary people are well known to suffer from "choice fatigue" and overstimulation. In a supermarket though it's considered a zero sum race between independent players. On a web site run by a single entity that need not be the case. > all the other "cruft" that was removed from McMaster.com The point of my comment is that crap was not removed but rather was never introduced in the first place.
- azalemeth 4y agoI wish Amazon was more like McMaster Carr or RS or any of the good websites. The ability to have filters that are meaningful (sort by random technical parameters, filter by dimensions or manufacturer, warranty, lead time, item location and that of manufacture, as well as price) and datasheets that were informative world be absolutely fantastic. I'm probably spoilt by datasheets for chips but God I miss them elsewhere...
- ooklala 4y agoI’m surprised you mention RS in the same breath as McMaster— their website is awful. Yes, you can put in very detailed parameters, but if you want a fairly generic part (like a DPDT 12v relay) you’re presented with hundreds of options, only one of which will be in stock— which they only tell you after you add it to your trolley… Given that RS is mostly ‘I need one of this part, tomorrow’ the inability to filter by stock completely ruins the usability of the site. It’s bad enough that I just use Farnell or Rapid—who both let you filter by stock—despite their sometimes worse selection. (and about a year or so ago the RS site stored state on the server side so if you hit the back button, or opened something in a new window the site would freak out and bring you back to the homepage)
- divbzero 4y agoI believe the parent is referring to Sigma-Aldrich? Here is an example of their search results: https://www.sigmaaldrich.com/US/en/search/edta https://www.sigmaaldrich.com/US/en/search/edta
- gumby 4y agoIndeed, I was referring to Sigma's and Fisher's old paper catalogues. Mcmaster seems to have done the best at preserving that value.
- mmmmpancakes 4y agoThe problem with your comparison to Amazon is that the scale of products offered on Amazon is completely different. A catalogue system like this is only viable if the number of products is relatively small, as appears to be the case of mcmaster-carr.
- stingrae 4y agoMcMaster has >700,000 products available on its website so I wouldn’t really call that relatively small. It is more segmented than what Amazon offers.
- mmmmpancakes 4y agoAmazon has roughly 350 MM products if you account for third party sellers, so yeah, the scale is massively different.
- ckemere 4y agoMaybe a related big difference is that McMaster Carr actually know what they sell?