4 ms·
Making money through art is already not a feasible career, as you yourself learned. If you want a job that millions of people do for fun in their free time, you
by lolinder 4y ago
Making money through art is already not a feasible career, as you yourself learned. If you want a job that millions of people do for fun in their free time, you can expect that job to be extremely hard to get and to pay very little.
The solution isn't to halt technological progress to try to defend the few jobs that are actually available in that sector, the solution is to fight forward to a future where no one has to do dull and boring things just to put food on the table. Fight for future where people can pursue what they want regardless of whether it's profitable.
Most of that fight is social and political, but progress in ML is an important precursor. We can't free everyone from the dull and repetitive until we have automated all of it.
- stemlord 4y ago>The solution isn't to halt technological progress Technological progress is not a linear deterministic progression. We decide how to progress every step of the way. The problem is that we are making dogshit decisions for some reason Maybe we lack the creativity to envision alternative futures. How does a society become so uncreative I wonder
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- godelski 4y agoBut do you know what reducing the progress of generative modeling will do? Because there seems to be this confusion that generative modeling is about art/music/text.
- visarga 4y ago> We decide how to progress every step of the way. I think the wheels are turning. It's just a resultant movement from thousands of small movements, but nobody is controlling it. If you take a look not even wars dent the steady progress of science and technology.
- MSFT_Edging 4y agoYou'll find its nearly impossible to imagine a world without capitalism. Capitalism is particularly good at weaponizing our own ideas against us. See large corporations co-opting anti-capitalist movements for sales and PR. Pepsi-co was probably mad that they couldn't co-op "defund the police", "fuck 12", and "ACAB" like they could with "black lives matter". Anything near and dear to us will be manipulated into a scientific formula to make a profit, and anything that cannot is rejected by any kind of mainstream media. See: Capitalist Realism and Manufactured Consent(for how advertising effects freedom of speech in any media platform).
- astrange 4y agoIt’s pretty easy to imagine a world without capitalism. It’s the one where the government declares you a counterrevolutionary hedonist for wanting to do art and forces you to work for the state owned lithium mine. Mixed social-democratic economies are nice and better than plutocracies, but they have capitalism; they just have other economic forms alongside it. (Needing to profit isn’t exclusive to capitalism either. Socialist societies also need productivity and profit, because they need to reinvest.)
- dopidopHN 4y agoOr a world where the gouvernement runs hospitals & schools and pay for it, no matter the cost. Effectively pulling those out of the market. It’s not a fantasy idea. I grow up there and it’s still working. It’s not out of beautiful idea either. But sheer pragmatism. A country will always need those things and those are important things. We might as well invest in them for the long run. Clearly those are not hip idea anymore. Oh well.
- CatWChainsaw 4y agoPerhaps it would be better to say you can't imagine "the future" without capitalism, as history prior to maybe the 1600s offers a less technologically advanced illustration.
- dopidopHN 4y ago
- kg 4y agoIf it's so important, we could at least pay the people who create the training set. Otherwise, we're relying on unpaid labor for this important progress and if the unpaid labor disappears, we're screwed. How does it seem sensible to construct a business this way?