4 ms·
All true and a perfectly valid model. But also try: If I were incredibly wealthy and obsessed with running the score up, I’d see any taxes or other loss of we
by brookst 4y ago
All true and a perfectly valid model.
But also try:
If I were incredibly wealthy and obsessed with running the score up, I’d see any taxes or other loss of wealth as a threat to my ego.
If my tax accountants came to me and said I could have a greater net worth by founding a charity optimized for my personal benefit, I’d happily shuffle money there rather than paying taxes.
I think that’s also a valid model. I don’t have enough info to have a strong opinion, but my priors on Musk make me at least question what he’s optimizing for.
- c22 4y agoI think he's probably optimizing for both. Don't hate the player, hate the game.
- SketchySeaBeast 4y agoPor que no los dos?
- s1artibartfast 4y agoIts not a feature, it is a bug. You don't have to hate either.
- heartbreak 4y agoAnyone that wealthy has substantial influence over the design of the game itself.
- c22 4y agoVery true, but I think the dubious-donation game predates Musk by quite a bit.
- brookst 4y agoI don’t see how a charity can be simultaneously optimized for benefiting its founder and also benefiting people other than its founder. Different goals, different choices. Unless you’re suggesting that Musk is such an egomaniac that he thinks the best thing a charity can do is help him personally?
- dbfx 4y agoOne could argue that he wants the charity to be good just because of the "prestige" of having a top charity, and that would be helping personally I guess. Not sure how putting money in a charity would make him more money even with tax breaks than just investing that money somewhere else, although I got no clue how charity tax breaks work in the US,
- c22 4y agoIt goes like this: I want to lower my tax liability by donating to charity > as long as I'm doing that I want to make sure I'm supporting something I agree with > I'll start my own charity to ensure that's the case. Frankly I'm much more concerned about the billion dollar roth IRAs and 529 plans which seem to have a much lower chance of helping anyone else.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoRoth IRAs aren't supposed to benefit anyone else. That's not why they exist
- c22 4y agoThey're also not meant to hold billions of dollars (the annual contribution limit is like $6000). Yet somehow this happens [0]. [0]: http://www.propublica.org/article/lord-of-the-roths-how-tech-mogul-peter-thiel-turned-a-retirement-account-for-the-middle-class-into-a-5-billion-dollar-tax-free-piggy-bank http://www.propublica.org/article/lord-of-the-roths-how-tech...
- s1artibartfast 4y agoyeah, I'm aware of that. They are designed with no cap, but clearly this type of growth was not expected. Seems like it is an easy fix if it is determined to be a problem worth fixing. Just add a IRA cap at something like 50 million before you have to withdraw.
- 4y ago
- mattalex 4y agoJust that in this case the players are so powerful they can use their wealth to define the rules themselves.
- nimbius 4y ago“In a rich man's house there is no place to spit but his face.” ― Diogenes of Sinope
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pwinnski 4y agoOr both. One can certainly despise a particular player playing a horrible game.
- yunohn 4y agoAh of course, “the game”. Which part of the game do you play and succeed at? Do you also get to make the rules? If not, don’t simp for billionaires.
- c22 4y agoI'm playing the same game everyone else is and so far I've found moderate success. I have some small say in the rules, just like I hope you do and I agree that in a lot of cases the rules are completely whack. Rather than "simping for billionaires" the intent of my comment was to cause the reader to introspect upon the part they play in crafting the rules and allowing the game to exist as it's currently played.
- ensignavenger 4y agoAnd you would be violating the law.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- brookst 4y agoNot necessarily. Plenty of rich peoples’ charities are incredibly inefficient at their stated purpose, good for their owners, and legal. Consider an imaginary tobacco tycoon’s charity that promotes cigarette use. It would be 100% legal.
- missedthecue 4y agoLegal, but it would not qualify for 501c3 tax exempt status.
- Volundr 4y agoHonest question, what would make it illegal? Charities pushing for social change is 100% a thing and I don't think it's limited to such a vague concept as "positive" social change.
- c22 4y agoIt's limited to charitable, religious, educational, scientific, literary, testing for public safety, fostering national or international amateur sports competition, and preventing cruelty to children or animals. I guess you could argue promoting cigarette use is "educational" or perhaps "religious" if a cigarette-smoking cult existed a la The Leftovers, but I suspect it would be a hard sell in today's environment, given the scientific and social consensus on the dangers of smoking, especially if your day job is selling the things. Maybe you could make it fly by using the funds to buy cigarettes and gift them to the homeless?
- ensignavenger 4y agoFirst, you can't actually "own" a 501c3, you can control it. Second, a 501c3 can be beneficial to its donors or controllers, but: "The organization must not be organized or operated for the benefit of private interests, and no part of a section 501(c)(3) organization's net earnings may inure to the benefit of any private shareholder or individual. If the organization engages in an excess benefit transaction with a person having substantial influence over the organization, an excise tax may be imposed on the person and any organization managers agreeing to the transaction." A charity that promotes peace on earth may be beneficial to the donors to the charity... but if "optimized for my personal benefit" it is likely to be non-tax-exempt... but I suppose we could debate the exact words used and what they really mean in theory. I think in the above tobacco scenario, the IRS and courts would likely find that the tobacco promotion was merely advertising, and therefore subject to taxation. https://www.irs.gov/charities-non-profits/charitable-organizations/exemption-requirements-501c3-organizations https://www.irs.gov/charities-non-profits/charitable-organiz...