3 ms·
Donating $5.7B to save an absolute max (37% tax bracket; he's probably much lower with most income via capital gains) of about $2.1B in taxes doesn't make finan
by ceejayoz 4y ago
Donating $5.7B to save an absolute max (37% tax bracket; he's probably much lower with most income via capital gains) of about $2.1B in taxes doesn't make financial sense, unless you've got a plan to siphon off at least $3.6B tax-free out of the charity. Why do people think a $1B donation saves $1B in tax?
- Quarrelsome 4y agoit only doesn't make sense if you plan to individually spend that money on yourself. However once you have billions of dollars it becomes relatively difficult to spend that much on yourself. Therefore it becomes a place to spend money enacting the change on society that you want to see.
- ceejayoz 4y agoSure, but that's a different motivation entirely.
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoThat money doesnt dissapear - it is still avaliable for lobbying, hiring staff and doing many other things.
- illegalmemory 4y agoOr funding research projects that will benefit you indirectly
- bena 4y agoYes, but the charity can pay for things for him. He needs to go to Europe and do "charity business", the charity can charter a jet for him, pay for his expenses, etc. Even better if he owns the jet, then he can essentially charter his own jet and have the charity cover the fuel and maintenance for that trip. That $5.7B is still effectively his, untaxed.
- Schweigi 4y agoHe doesn’t need to shiphon anything. All the “donated” money is still in his control. In order to be effective at tax deference you need to separate the concept of who ownes the money and who controls it. As long as you still control it, it doesn’t matter who ownes it. That’s why a donner advised funds and similar concepts are used to reduce taxes or defer them. In addition it’s also great for asset protection. For example if he gave a personal guarantee on some of the Twitter debt, then moving money into the foundation (as long as his Twitter stint was not fraud) will remove that out of his name and make it untouchable to the banks. He can now use those funds to support trips to Mars and other projects. For those projects the charity might pay his expenses - for example a flight to attend a meeting in Hawaii. He can even use the money to hire his kids. The kids would have a much lower (w2) tax rate so effectively he reduced tax but kept the money in the family.
- mindslight 4y agoExactly. It's not some hack that magically makes income tax liability just disappear, as many commenters are thinking it could be. Rather there are marginal tax benefits combined with strong asset protection, that make sense when you've got an obscene amount of money to manage so the administrative overhead becomes negligible - the question goes from "why" to "why not". Another thing people are missing is that it's not an income tax dodge, but rather an estate tax dodge. The money will remain in control of his heirs, assuring they'll never go hungry or want for a place in the world. It also creates more opportunities to play with asset valuations to evade taxes (eg separate the financial and voting interest of some stock in a closely held company, then claim the financial interest is worth very little without the control interest). But it's impossible to know if this is actually being done without seeing tax filings, including his (eventual) estate tax filing.
- yamtaddle 4y ago> Why do people think a $1B donation saves $1B in tax? A distressingly large slice of eligible voters don't even understand how marginal tax rates work. Which is, like, the absolute minimum to have any clue whatsoever how US income taxes are applied, what tax bills will actually do if they become law, and so on. I'd be surprised if understanding of how deductions work is any more widespread. [EDIT] Not a great source, but it's in-line with the results I've seen from better ones in the past: https://today.yougov.com/topics/politics/articles-reports/2013/01/08/understanding-how-marginal-taxes-work-its-all-part https://today.yougov.com/topics/politics/articles-reports/20... Roughly half don't understand how marginal tax rates work. Can't find data on how many US adults understand how deductions work, but I doubt it's better.
- yamtaddle 4y agoCan't edit anymore: not mad about the downvotes, but I also don't understand them, at all. What about this rubbed people the wrong way? The answer to the question is that lots and lots of people don't understand how income taxes work, even a little. So many that one may expect to regularly encounter such people. I'll grant the results are from the social science side of things, which HN doesn't much care for, but that's just... where the answers to that question happen to come from.
- mrep 4y ago> Can't find data on how many US adults understand how deductions work, but I doubt it's better. Almost certainly much much lower seeing as how a ton of people here don't understand how deductions work.
- bzjlvewivezw 4y agoIt is possible to donate appreciated stocks. And the tax rate can be higher than 37%, if it's short-term gains in California since there's state tax as well. To run the numbers on the 37%: Charity: 5.7B deduction * 0.37 rate = 2.109B value of the tax deduction Selling: 5.7B deduction * (1-0.37) = 3.5B value of the stock sale In addition, the shares were at an inflated value - if he dumps 5.7B onto the market, it's going to drop the value of the remaining 100B of shares. Whereas by donating to the charity, you get the 5.7B deduction, and the fund you donated to does not even have to sell the stock. Even if the stock drops shortly after, such as in this case, he still gets to keep the large deduction. See https://dlj.law.duke.edu/article/insider-giving-avci-vol71-iss3/ https://dlj.law.duke.edu/article/insider-giving-avci-vol71-i..., illegal but unenforced. Also, he can use the charity money anyway to pay for various things he feels like spending money on - other billionaires have used personal charities to settle lawsuits, employ their children / cousins, invest in businesses of friends, etc.