5 ms·
Red dwarf stars take up to 100 million years to settle down to the main sequence. Before that time, they are more luminous. During that period, these planets
by pfdietz 4y ago
Red dwarf stars take up to 100 million years to settle down to the main sequence. Before that time, they are more luminous. During that period, these planets would not have been habitable and may have lost their water to space.
Red dwarfs also subject their planets in the putative habitable zone to much stronger stellar winds and flare radiation, which makes survival of their atmospheres problematic.
- splittingTimes 4y agoFrom the abstract: "The closeness of the host star to the Sun makes [it possible] for their atmosphere to be studied via high-contrast high-resolution spectroscopy." Hopefully they can follow-up soon with those measurements. That could bring clarify to your fundamental questions.
- pfdietz 4y agoIt's possible that such planets could have abiotic oxygen atmospheres, from water photolysed by intense UV radiation from the star. The hydrogen would escape to space. For that reason, even if oxygen (or ozone) is detected, it would not necessarily be a sign of life.
- nine_k 4y agoThe presence of abiotic oxygen could help develop oxygen-breathing life, the same way as abiotic sulfur gives rise to teeming spots of life on the bottom of Earth oceans [1]. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrothermal_vent_microbial_communities#Sulfur_Cycle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrothermal_vent_microbial_co...
- perihelions 4y agoAny concrete numbers on that? I'd speculate there'd only be trace amounts: solar photochemistry is pretty slow, and rock weathering eats up any free molecular oxygen. Not sure of the relative rates.
- moloch-hai 4y agoAll these planets are necessarily tidally-locked to their star. That represents an extremely poor environment to try to evolve life in. The only temperate place would be a ring at the terminator with the sun permanently just above the horizon. With a very massive moon -- or a double planet, like Pluto/Charon, it might be possible to avoid tidal lock.
- xwdv 4y agoLife on such a world wouldn’t be so bad. It’s basically an inverted ring world. Belief systems would arise to discourage inhabitants from going too far off the ring, either into the burning desert eternally punished by the sun or the icy tundra shrouded in eternal darkness.
- jl6 4y agoThat burning desert could be a nice location to site their solar power plants, and perhaps the icy tundra could cool their data centers.
- thechao 4y agoAn advanced version of this civilization might think of the Earth as uninhabitable: how would you power anything without a builtin planet-scale, locally operable gradient?
- gota 4y agoCan you imagine _war_ in this world? At first armies can march in one direction of the ring or the other, with every natural defense point being sort of a Thermopilae situation Then, technology progresses and certain machines may allow smaller groups to traverse outward for limited periods of time. Analogous to our submarines? Would then flight make the world "flat" and globalized? They can't lay cables across the scorching dor icy deserts, so worldwide comm must either follow the ring or be satellite-based
- ericbarrett 4y agoThe planets are very close to their star, too: 0.046 and 0.074 au. The star is roughly 1.4 solar masses and yet much dimmer than the Sun. It is a very different solar system than ours.
- causi 4y agoWhat? GJ1002 is 0.12 solar masses, not 1.4. 1.4 solar masses and yet much dimmer than the Sun This is not even physically possible unless the star is a post-main sequence white dwarf.
- pantalaimon 4y agoWith our current methods we really only are able to detect rocky planets if they are close to a red dwarf and reasonably big. It’s a bit like losing your key and looking below the street light because that’s the only place you can see - only that the street is littered with millions of potential keys anyway.
- WastingMyTime89 4y agoThe interesting fact is that we find this kind of planets in the very narrow settings we are able to look for them. That means they are probably everywhere. Realistically if we wanted to look for life on a foreign object, we would probably start with the candidates in the solar system.