2 ms·
This is not the end of the story. The First amendment is about government, yes -- but not "free speech" in general. Speech is not really free when you need to
by bambax 15y ago
This is not the end of the story. The First amendment is about government, yes -- but not "free speech" in general.
Speech is not really free when you need to subscribe to a private service in order to express yourself, and those services can edict their own rules defining what can be said.
A business is not free to do anything it wants. For example, a business is not free to demonstrate prejudice in hiring.
Just because, as of now, businesses who are in the business of providing tools for self expression, can define their own rules as regards to how those tools are used, does not mean they will always be able to do so, nor that they should.
Free speech should be enforced in private companies. My guess is, it eventually will.
- notahacker 15y agoSpeech is free in the sense of absence of legal restrictions on it, not in the sense of the presence of third parties obliged to unconditional bear the costs of broadcasting it. Why should Google be obliged to host and display MG Siegler's silly picture if they don't want to? Should misapplication of the First Amendment also oblige Google, at their own expense, to also deliver all spam to and from Gmail accounts, host every copyright-cleared hardcore porn video uploaded to YouTube and allow people to turn their Google Circle into the next Stormfront if it's their wish to do so? Legislation implying that permitting some forms of user- generated content on your internet property cedes all owners' rights of control of what is broadcast would have the counter-intuitive effect of killing free-speech on the internet stone dead; better to shutter the comment field than be sued by spammers for filtering them.