6 ms·
I wish they could solve the basic use case of "Let me set a temperature and thermostat keeps the house at that temperature." I tried several versions of Nest, a
by ryandrake 4y ago
I wish they could solve the basic use case of "Let me set a temperature and thermostat keeps the house at that temperature." I tried several versions of Nest, and they all inevitably decided on their own that they were smarter than me and generated some weird schedule despite my never commanding them to operate on a schedule. I just want my thermostat to hold whatever temperature I set it at, until I set it at another temperature. This shouldn't take AI wizardry to achieve.
- wiml 4y agoIt does seem like you could do that with a bimetallic coil and a little blob of mercury in a tube, like thermostats have done since the 1950s
- pdonis 4y ago> I just want my thermostat to hold whatever temperature I set it at, until I set it at another temperature. If it only takes one of heating or cooling to do this, not both, a standard "dumb" thermostat can of course do this just fine. Just set it to "cool" or "heat" mode and set a temperature. But of course you will need to change modes as the season changes (unless you live somewhere where only one mode is ever needed). If you want to not have to change modes when the season changes, it gets more complicated, because the simple control system in the standard thermostat is too dumb for that. For example, suppose you set your temperature to 75. The actual temperature rises to 76, above the setpoint, so your A/C comes on. It cools the house to 74 and then the thermostat shuts it off (you have to have some buffer so the A/C doesn't come on again almost immediately). Now the temperature is below the setpoint, so your heat comes on. It heats the house to 76 and then shuts off. Now the temperature is above the setpoint... You can see what's going on. From a pure design perspective, the right way to solve this problem is an outside temperature sensor (and probably a sun sensor as well since sunlight is a significant heat input to your house), so the system can predict what will happen when both cooling and heating are off. Given reliable sensors, the control algorithm is fairly simple (automatic climate control systems in cars already do it). I have never seen this in a house, though. I'm not sure why.
- maxerickson 4y agoI wonder if the quote is referring to balancing 2 systems. I don't have AC, but I use my heat to maintain a minimum acceptable temperature, not to maintain the temperature I find ideal. I don't want it to go a lot lower than the setting.
- tshaddox 4y agoSurely a basic PID controller with reasonable tuning could mostly mitigate the problem you describe, which isn’t really a different problem than a thermostat that would attempt to turn the furnace on and off multiple times per second if the thermometer was fluctuating between 74 and 75 multiple times per second. Granted, tuning the PID controller implies loosening the “maintain the exact target temperature at all costs” spec.
- pdonis 4y ago> tuning the PID controller implies loosening the “maintain the exact target temperature at all costs” spec. And if you loosen that spec, then, as others have already pointed out, just having two setpoints, a lower one for heating and a higher one for cooling, will be sufficient as long as the difference between them is large enough (probably 2 degrees or more would be enough for many use cases). That would be simpler than adding a PID controller.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kkielhofner 4y agoThis is solved in thermostats with hysteresis and even many DIY or close to it solutions like esphome[0] implement it. I know on my Nest when heat and cool mode is on the set heat and cool temperatures have to be two degrees away from one another, which is fine with me because for whatever reasons 67 in the summer feels great but I want close to 69/70/71 in the winter. The linked esphome docs are actually great whether you care about esphome or not - they explain all of this very well and you can tell from the configuration values and samples what kind of logic goes into all of this. [0] - https://esphome.io/components/climate/thermostat.html https://esphome.io/components/climate/thermostat.html
- adanto6840 4y agoAs a kid we had a very simple (mercury) thermostat which had two levers -- one for heating set-point & one for cooling set-point. I recall it working quite well.
- beambot 4y agoAlways thought the old mechanical bimetallic strip solution was particularly elegant. In effect, two strips of metal were bonded together forming a coiled "spring." Because each metal had different coefficient of thermal expansion, the spring would expand or contract to different lengths depending on the temperature. Place the electrical contact at the temp where the heater or HVAC should turn on & bam. No electronics at all, just a temperature-dependent mechanical switch.
- AlbertCory 4y agoExactly. I had a problem with the temperature in my house often being wrong, so I bought a smart thermostat. Now I have ten problems.
- rootw0rm 4y agothey still exist, that's what cheapo thermostats still use. i've wired up a couple thermostat controlled extension cords over the past couple years for a dog house and chicken coop using them
- KMag 4y agoAlso, they usually had a tiny magnet at the tip of the bimetallic strip to make their decisions path-dependent (more "sticky"/less flip-flopping).
- wycy 4y ago> I just want my thermostat to hold whatever temperature I set it at, until I set it at another temperature. You can set your own schedule with Nest, you don't have to let the AI take over. Mine is fully on my own manual schedule.
- ourlordcaffeine 4y agoI've set my own schedule with nest, and it still reset it to its own weird (and far too warm) schedule
- ownagefool 4y agoYou need to turn off learning mode, otherwise it eventually overrides your schedule. Personally I think it's significantly better than what was common ( in the UK ) before, but the tech is dime a dozen, and new houses should probably come with underfloor, and control per room, though most still don't.
- cjrp 4y agoI had Hive before and prefer that; being able to boost the heating to a certain temperature for 30/60/120 mins is a common use case for me that Nest doesn't do.
- stickfigure 4y agoYou can disable the "smart" behavior. It's in the menus. I did. It's fine.
- emodendroket 4y agoYou could have turned that off before using it.
- causi 4y agothey all inevitably decided on their own that they were smarter than me and generated some weird schedule despite my never commanding them to operate on a schedule. Seems to be a Google habit. I regularly get "commute traffic reports" several hours before or after I leave home or the office. Of course there's absolutely no way to set the alert schedule yourself.
- anikom15 4y agoDoes a simple analog Honeywell thermostat not do that?
- kylehotchkiss 4y agoIt turns out the cheapest thermostat at the store fulfills your exact requirement :)