4 ms·
We don't need weird elements to support solar with batteries. Grid stabilization can do fine with lead-acid batteries. Both lead and sulfur are readily availabl
by jeffbee 4y ago
We don't need weird elements to support solar with batteries. Grid stabilization can do fine with lead-acid batteries. Both lead and sulfur are readily available. There are also iron batteries and other emerging battery chemistries, as well as non-battery storage like pumped liquids or pressurized gases.
- Robotbeat 4y agoDon’t need manganese or any rare minerals for batteries. Lithium iron phosphate batteries are used in the least expensive Teslas (base Model 3 and Y), and although lithium is very abundant, you can even substitute it for the even more abundant Sodium with only a slight weight increase. That’s superior to Lead based batteries in nearly every way.
- pfdietz 4y agoManganese is not a rare mineral. One does not mine manganese nodules for the manganese. Mining them would create an enormous surplus of manganese that would get dumped in waste piles.
- Turing_Machine 4y agoWhy is a "waste pile" worse than having it distributed all over the ocean floor?
- pfdietz 4y agoI wasn't making a judgment here. I was just pointing out that most of the manganese ends up in the waste stream. One would not be mining these things for the manganese (although what manganese that could be sold would be sold.) In a world mining manganese nodules, the price of manganese would be very low.
- arcticbull 4y agoOr you can reduce your need for batteries by combining wind and solar with green, safe nuclear reactors - and smart grids capable of varying their demand instead of us trying desperately to adjust supply. For example, as more folks move to electric cars, a smart grid would allow chargers to charge less at periods of intense demand. We've historically focused exclusively on adjusting supply to meet demand - which is clearly very difficult and very expensive (especially if you look at gas peaker plants) - but we instead (or in addition) can adjust aspects of the demand curve to smooth out variability in load. This should be easier and significantly cheaper.
- hedora 4y agoAlternatively, keep burning fossil fuels, but overproduce renewables on average, and use the waste energy for carbon capture. (This has the big advantage of buying time to decarbonize things like concrete, cattle and airplanes.)
- arcticbull 4y agoWouldn't it be more efficient to not produce the carbon than to produce it on one side and capture it on the other?
- s1artibartfast 4y agoGreat, if we don't actually need the metals then there will be no one to buy them from the deep sea Miners and the problem will solve itself