3 ms·
Waymos velocity seems to have slowed dramatically since 2015 when they first did fully driverless rides on the public road and started deploying to multiple reg
by londons_explore 4y ago
Waymos velocity seems to have slowed dramatically since 2015 when they first did fully driverless rides on the public road and started deploying to multiple regions.
Now, 2 billion dollars and 7 years later, they are still only in a handful of small regions with limited numbers of vehicles.
That tells me there is still some fundamental issue that is hard to solve. I wonder why they aren't more transparent and tell us what that issue is that they've been battling for 7 years?
- londons_explore 4y agoIt's clear which bits they haven't been focussing on... There are multiple videos on youtube of rides (some where it has gone wrong) and the user experience is terrible. The car has a robotic voice which plays a long and annoying unskippable message with every ride, and 'Rider support' sounding like they are following a strict script with no ability to be helpful or fix the problem [1]... Imagine if every time you started your car, a robotic voice said "Welcome to your Ford Pickup XYZ model. Please ensure your seatbelts are fastened. If you are too hot, you can adjust the climate with the climate controls. If you want to lower the windows, please don't put your arms out. etc etc. Have a nice ride today in your Ford(tm) Pickup(tm).". [1]: https://youtu.be/2ZmdxkBV5Tw?t=180 https://youtu.be/2ZmdxkBV5Tw?t=180
- saxelsen 4y agoNot entirely different from getting on a plane? You have to listen to the safety protocol before take-off.
- londons_explore 4y agoMost things about planes are pretty user unfriendly to be fair... "arrive 2 hours before departure"... "queue for hours through security"... "walk miles to your gate"... "have to buy your ticket a long time in advance, and then 'check in' more than 3 hours in advance but less than 48 hours"... We're a long way from the ideal of "show up at the airport 5 mins before, hop on a plane, and hand cash to the pilot for your ride".
- rootusrootus 4y ago> We're a long way from the ideal of "show up at the airport 5 mins before, hop on a plane, and hand cash to the pilot for your ride". Also known as the private jet model. I've experienced it, through a bit of lucky employment, but I remain too poorly funded to make it my normal method of air travel. I do wish I could afford it.
- stevehawk 4y ago(I know nothing about self driving) I seems like the hardest 90% of the work is the last 10%.
- jmartrican 4y agoI suspect that the issue is with cars being so cautious that they just stop as people keep walking, or at best herky jerky move fwd. In NYC, a car like that wouldn't get anywhere as the pedestrians just won't stop. the pedestrians stop when they see that the driver isn't going to stop and they gonna get hit.
- drc500free 4y agoSo much of urban pedestrian-driver interactions depend on confirming eye contact and determining intent from body language. I don't see how an automated car with no driver can deal with the "are they crossing or not?" question that you get every few minutes while driving in a city. Both because body language is a hard problem to get right, and because there's a lot of non-verbal communication that a driverless car doesn't have a way of participating in.
- AlotOfReading 4y agoWaymo does pose estimation to help determine pedestrian intent and react accordingly [1]. [1] https://blog.waymo.com/2022/02/utilizing-key-point-and-pose-estimation.html?m=1 https://blog.waymo.com/2022/02/utilizing-key-point-and-pose-...
- drc500free 4y agoThanks, that's an interesting read. Not sure that I trust pose estimation algorithms with my life, but still interesting!
- Gunnerhead 4y agoAhaha, yup! Especially around midtown where crossing the road is a symphony between cars and pedestrians.
- gok 4y agoWaymo first deployed on public roads in 2019 (I appreciate 2019 feels like 7 years ago)
- jeffbee 4y agoDid you mean offered a service to the general public? Because Google's older self-driving car drove that one blind guy to the Taco Bell drive-thru more than 10 years ago. And they had been driving Googlers back and forth from their homes and offices for years prior.
- summerlight 4y agoRegulation is one of the major factor that slows down. You need more and more test cases to achieve higher reliability, but data collection at scale need approvals and regulators want to see if it's reliable enough to approve. This chicken and egg problem is not something easy to solve since at its heart it's a trust problem. Tesla was an exception because they choose to put all the responsibility to the drivers by making it technically ADAS but marketing it as "full self-driving".
- RockyMcNuts 4y agoThe fundamental problem which is impossible to solve is game theory. Suppose the collision avoidance is perfect. Now put it on the roads of NYC, or New Delhi. There are a lot of people who will just walk in front of a car going 40mph, if they know for sure it will brake hard and stop. The problem isn't technology, it's humanity. The solution is to change the rules of the road, have protected lanes for self-driving buses and taxis and cars, and enforcement. Let vehicles that can take full advantage of communicating with each other and the road go fast and use the infrastructure to maximum theoretical capacity, without having to worry about dumb human drivers.
- fooker 4y ago> The solution is to change the rules of the road, have protected lanes for self-driving buses and taxis and cars, and enforcement. We reached this conclusion about 150 years ago and came up with rails. In addition, you get cheap electricity so reliably that modern trains don't even bother having batteries. Yes, rail lines as they are deployed now might not be the ideal future proof solution, but something similar which allows 'cars' to go off track for the last mile but otherwise not incur wear and tear on your own tires and engine/transmission for the long haul might be a practical idea.
- londons_explore 4y ago> if they know for sure it will brake hard and stop. I think the solution here is to issue tickets to those people. You could probably ticket them already under some statute like "endangering road users" or something. With self driving cars having always on cameras, you only need to ticket each idiot once or twice, and they'll stop doing it. We already punish people who run around on the runway of airports - seems no different.