4 ms·
I like the level 5 or bust approach taken by Waymo and Cruise. Anything in the middle (like what Tesla is doing) is IMO more dangerous than useful. The whole "t
by paxys 4y ago
I like the level 5 or bust approach taken by Waymo and Cruise. Anything in the middle (like what Tesla is doing) is IMO more dangerous than useful. The whole "the car is self-driving but you must also pay attention and have your hands on the wheel at all times" thing is idiotic.
- Justsignedup 4y agoHumans are notoriously bad at just paying attention and not being in charge. Those few seconds their actual attention is needed are critical. I do appreciate that my car can do full distance control and assist if I am drifting, but it doesn't control itself, so I can never disengage. Personally I feel that this is wonderful and should be the limit. Anything past that should just be fully autonomous. Otherwise you're asking for trouble.
- mikepurvis 4y ago100%. If I'm driving and my attention wanders, I need the immediate feedback of drifting out of the lane and having to abruptly course correct, and being like "dang yeah, let's not do that again", possibly reinforced by passengers scowling at me from elsewhere in the vehicle. I can't imagine trying to focus on supervising an AI pilot without that kind of feedback.
- xplanephil 4y agointerestingly, I don't have much trouble with that, as it works exactly like most airplanes that I fly as a pilot. An airplane autopilot is a dumb device, in that it does execute _exactly_ the plan you tell it to, and it is up to the pilot to at all times decide whether the current plan still makes sense or needs to be altered. So the pilot makes the strategic decisions, and leaves most of the physical tasks of flying to the autopilot. I find myself using my M3 w/FSD in exactly the same way, as that I put on autosteer pretty much immediately when I'm out of the driveway, but I constantly nudge it into the lane that I want it to be in (by using the turn signal) or push the accelerator when I think it is taking too long pondering a turn. So i leave the physical driving (keep lane and distance) to the car but manage the car to always go exactly where I want it. I have no trouble staying alert this way when doing medium long drives. Long highway drives where autopilot is so good that it requires no manual interaction is where the trouble starts and I find it hard to keep paying attention. This is where in an airplane you have a copilot and can discuss strategic things like overnight stops, fuel stops, etc... Maybe Tesla needs a built-in chatbot to make me do that :)
- Justsignedup 4y ago"I have no trouble staying alert this way when doing medium long drives. Long highway drives where autopilot is so good that it requires no manual interaction is where the trouble starts and I find it hard to keep paying attention." Exactly!!!!!! The trouble is when your attention wanes and you don't know exactly when you should be paying attention. What I found is the small amount of automation my car does is wonderful to keep my exhaustion down. When I drove for 4 hours in my 2012 prius, it was a chore, i had to do ALL the mental math myself. When I drive my 2023 CX-50 I have to pay attention at least 30% less, and that 30% is a massive difference, it feels like 90%. And any time my attention wanes, the car starts complaining because I am drifting or not putting enough immediate response to the road. It becomes a "pay attention quickly" wake-up call that happens within seconds of attention waning. The worry is when the car doesn't snap you back into that attention mode, and you just trust it, right up to the problem.
- mtgx 4y ago
- mikepurvis 4y agoIsn't airplane autopilot considered to be significantly easier than automobile autopilot? Fundamentally, it's PID to track a bearing and elevation, and the worst kind of emergency it's likely to encounter is rough weather or some kind of mechanical problem with the plane itself, neither of which need to be handled with sub-second response time the way many road emergencies do. I get what you're saying about the physical/strategic split, but my perception is that automobile autopilots are simply not good enough to be trusted with the "physical" stuff in a hands-off way like an airplane's can. And that's mostly because driving a car in a straight line down a highway is way harder than flying a plane in a straight line in an empty sky.
- peder 4y agoI suspect the below-"Level 5" driving systems will become more of an "augmented driving". I've driven in newer vehicles with automatic lane centering, pedestrian detection, etc. and they don't really seem like they're even doing anything, you still feel like you're the one driving, except that it's more precise with the occasional interruption by the car when it perceives risk of a collision. These augmented systems will probably reduce the risk of accidents so greatly that the value proposition for Level 5 driving systems just won't be there.
- peder 4y agoI'll also add that I think what Waymo is doing right now is closer to a semi-autonomous streetcar. There's probably immense value in that approach, especially as an alternative to mass-transit systems that have costly labor, but it's not clear that they are imminently close to "anywhere, anytime" self-driving.
- chime 4y ago> These augmented systems will probably reduce the risk of accidents so greatly that the value proposition for Level 5 driving systems just won't be there. I've driven a lot for decades and frankly enjoy driving. I drove from TPA to SLC via PHX and back for fun. But I will pay $500/mo level-5 subscription for a comfortable car that drives itself.
- oangemangut 4y agoI'm trying to figure out how many hours a month are you in a vehicle where that makes sense for you?
- HDThoreaun 4y agoHaving level 5 available honestly opens up tons of options that were not available before. A 90 minute commute is so much more palatable when you can be sleeping. So are road-trips.
- 4y ago
- jvolkman 4y agoHere's Chris Urmson talking about this 7 years ago when he was still working on (what is now) Waymo: https://youtu.be/tiwVMrTLUWg?t=169 https://youtu.be/tiwVMrTLUWg?t=169
- jsnell 4y agoAren't they geofenced, which would make them level 4?
- sebzim4500 4y ago>Anything in the middle (like what Tesla is doing) is IMO more dangerous than useful Intuitively I would have agreed with you, except Tesla has been doing it for years and their cars are statistically safer by every metric (fatalities, indicents, etc.).
- twiceaday 4y ago> their cars are statistically safer by every metric Compared to what population? Older, tech-savvy people buying 60k-120k usd vehicles? And do you mean in full self-driving mode Beta, which Tesla won't allow you to use unless you have a track record of save driving?
- redox99 4y ago> Anything in the middle (like what Tesla is doing) is IMO more dangerous than useful. Even if a hypothetical, future Tesla FSD sometimes crashes in ways that could be prevented had the driver payed attention, it could still be statistically safer than a fully human driver (ie the number of FSD crashes even if left unattended < the number of crashes by humans driving). To clarify, I'm not talking about the current state of FSD, I'm talking about a hypothetical, future Level 3.
- paxys 4y agoDoing such aggregations is pointless. The majority of traffic accidents are caused by drunk drivers, drivers who are too young/too old, people on their phones or otherwise distracted, people driving in bad conditions, people driving unsafe cars etc. So yes, while Tesla autopilot may be better than all of them on average, I will still only use it if it is better than ME.
- redox99 4y ago> I will still only use it if it is better than ME. You're free to not use it. But if Tesla FSD is safer than the average driver (even if that's because the average driver is on their phone) then, going back to your statement, it is more useful than dangerous for the average driver.
- paxys 4y agoWhat is your definition of "average driver"? There are ~250M drivers in the US and a little over 2 million car accidents that result in injuries every year. So the average driver is doing perfectly fine. In fact 99% of them are fine. Car accidents don't follow a bell curve. If you want to make the roads safer you need to target the bottom 1% of drivers, but there is no guarantee that they are the ones who will adopt autopilot. If everyone else takes their eyes off the road it will actually make things worse.
- drstewart 4y agoWhat are your thoughts on airplane autopilots then?