9 ms·
Facebook owner Meta sued for inciting hatred in Ethiopia
- oriettaxx 4y agoit was about time! kudos to the promoters
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- missedthecue 4y agoFrivolous lawsuit. Hope it fails.
- barbazoo 4y agoWhat about it is frivolous exactly?
- missedthecue 4y agoA civil suit for $2 billion which alleges that Facebook's algorithm promoted popular posts with lots of engagement more than it promoted unpopular posts is frivolous and deserves to be tossed.
- lostlogin 4y agoIt resulted in death. That seems a key detail. Do you think that aspect matters? It was raised with them, they didn’t act and someone died. They have no responsibility for spreading death threats? If that content is ok, what content is not ok?
- missedthecue 4y agoThe article expressly states that violent content is not allowed and was actively policed. Facebook moderators are not fully omniscient and omnipresent. That is not grounds for a $2 billion lawsuit. That fact that people died is sad, but ultimately immaterial to the arguments here considered.
- felipelemos 4y agoIf they can't determine if a post is violent or not, then they shouldn't blindly promote it.
- hulitu 4y agoThey don't promote it blindly. They promote it knowingly.
- mikem170 4y agoThat's a good answer to this. They should be responsible for what the algorithm decides to inject into people's feeds, when they are acting as a publisher. If they don't have enough resources to review the outputs from their algorithm, then to bad, just show posts from friends only.
- phendrenad2 4y agoThere will always be false negatives. Is one false negative enough to drag them into court? So every website on earth will just have that one moment where they accidentally promote (or don't actively de-promote) something toxic, and they'll get to go to court over it. I wonder how much Twitter will have to charge now. $8/mo isn't going to cut it. More like $80,000/mo
- barbazoo 4y ago> Abrham Amare, a researcher and son of chemistry professor Meareg Amare, said that his father was targeted by a series of threatening posts because he was ethnically Tigrayan. He reported the posts, some of them shared over 50,000 times, to Facebook because they contained his father's address and called for his death. > Eight days after the elder Amare was murdered, Facebook finally removed the post, according to the researcher. Doesn't sound like they "actively policed" the content sufficiently.
- metamann 4y agoWho determines sufficiency (well, a jury here…)? If an ethnic conflict occurs in a relatively obscure region are they going to spin up new moderators on the AWS spot market? These things aren’t perfect or fast.
- metamann 4y agoWell, the key here would be “raised with them.” How that was handled. Had they seen human review and wrongly rejected? Was it thrown up the chain and a VP said “fuck then skinnies!”? Was it just lost in a message queue? All in all, this reminds me a bit of the old joke “The mail man is my drug dealer, and he doesn’t even know it.” Well, if I mail a letter to the Post Master telling him my neighbor buys fentanyl via the post and he doesn’t read it in time, I can’t blame him for not getting to it… barring dereliction. So, no, blanket hating FB here is just smooth-brain outrage culture.
- toofy 4y ago> If that content is ok, what content is not ok? sharing the flight plan of an airplane, apparently. the reality is, these people truly do understand how posts impact real world safety. they fully understand and are outraged if the posts are directed in anyway towards their group—they just don’t care, or maybe worse.
- Nextgrid 4y agoIf they use an algorithm to promote posts to increase their bottom-line instead of some neutral and transparent way (such as reverse-chronological feed of what people explicitly followed) they effectively act as an editor and should lose whatever Section 230-equivalent protection they are currently using. Facebook (and other "growth & engagement" platforms) currently want to have their cake and eat it too. They act as an editor, selectively promoting certain content that increases engagement and thus their bottom-line while not taking any of the liability. Newspapers can do this too (and to a certain extent, do) but are under strict regulation which limits the damage (yes, tabloids are a thing, but none of them would publish outright calls to violence and promote illegal activities, something very commonplace on Facebook because outrageous content generates more engagement).
- kderbyma 4y agoWhy should a company be free to manslaughter as they please? I feel like the directors should be brought to account for that region...imho
- lostlogin 4y agoIs it more of less frivolous than the time Facebook helped organise a genocide? https://www.nytimes.com/2018/10/15/technology/myanmar-facebook-genocide.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/10/15/technology/myanmar-facebo...
- missedthecue 4y agoFacebook helped organize it in the same sense that Apple helped organize it when Burmese people use their devices to talk to each other. I understand that HN has a massive hate boner for Facebook, but don't let it cloud your judgment.
- lostlogin 4y agoNo, Facebook’s role was considerably more active than that. The messages that were amplified, the complaints that were ignored and they allowed the organisation of a genocide. The NYT article covers it quite well but there is no shortage of information on their abysmal performance in the atrocities.
- lostmsu 4y ago> The messages that were amplified And Apple participated in that. Also the internet providers. > the complaints that were ignored I am sure Apple gets a lot of complaints about Facebook > and they allowed the organisation of a genocide Still fits Apple
- nier 4y agoPlease explain it to me as if I was a 5 year old. I do not understand the similarities between a communication platform and an ad-supported social network that uses software to maximize user engagement. From my naive standpoint I feel like when you manipulate people’s attention you should be somewhat liable for what happens as a result of that.
- lostmsu 4y ago> communication platform and an ad-supported social network Every social network is a communication platform.
- LatteLazy 4y agoYou're being unfairly downvoted because it's perceived as trendy to hate facebook and pretend they can magically police all human activity. But you're quite right. The courts will find this too and have done in the past multiple times. This is just dumb clickbait and people are biting.
- nier 4y agoIn this case they should have demonstrated better security around their place. A person was singled out and PII was published. It was reported and they took down the information only 8 days after the person’s death. They clearly need more moderators for what they do and the way they play with people’s attention.
- LatteLazy 4y agoThese things always come down to people not being able to define "should". Would it be a good thing if Facebook had more moderation? Probably. Are they morally or legally liable because a bunch of third parties committed a crime off of the platform? No, not at all. You might disagree, but then you have to explain why facebook in particular are liable. Why aren't the actual murderers? Or the people who posted the information? Why aren't the electricity suppliers who enabled people to get online? Why isn't the government and local police? Would it be nice if facebook solved all social problems? Yes, it would be lovely. But it's not actually their job or problem and more than it is your job. Just because they're big and you're (understandably) angry doesn't make them guilty.
- phendrenad2 4y agoExactly. People want a special carve-out for Facebook and don't want to apply the same logic to public places and text apps. The magical "algorithm" is supposedly at blame, simply because there is supposedly an "algorithm" somewhere inside Facebook that sinisterly pulls the strings, whatever string, in order to make money.
- baynoob 4y ago
- thedaly 4y agoHow many genocides must a company be complicit in before they change the way they operate?
- hulitu 4y agoBob Dylan has an answer for you: Blowing in the wind
- hourago 4y ago> Abrham Amare, a researcher and son of chemistry professor Meareg Amare, said that his father was targeted by a series of threatening posts because he was ethnically Tigrayan. He reported the posts, some of them shared over 50,000 times, to Facebook because they contained his father's address and called for his death. Eight days after the elder Amare was murdered, Facebook finally removed the post, according to the researcher. Facebook caused the death of a man. If you think that Facebook did just because the posts were "popular". then Facebook caused the death of a man for money, and that makes it worse.
- noworriesnate 4y agoI have a friend and an ex-coworker who work at Meta. I've asked them about things like this in the past, their responses have boiled down to something like this: If Facebook's algorithms reduced millions of micro-aggressions but simultaneously enabled the death of one person, then they're probably still in the green. It's like public policy-making. There are tradeoffs everywhere, and somebody will always draw the short straw.
- p0pcult 4y agoI'll take the world of microaggressions, thanks. There's a reason they're called microaggressions.
- darkwizard42 4y agoIf we are just using words, then another saying "death by a thousand paper cuts" comes to mind. I think the parent has a point. Not sure I agree, but there are many ways to argue for or against.
- p0pcult 4y agoTry recovering from death vs. try recovering from a microagression. One is impossible; the other should have bounced off immediately.
- deleted 4y ago
- zug_zug 4y agoI hate meta as much as the next person, but I find this whole line of reasoning farsical and a distraction from the many actually bad things to worry about. I think there's a huge difference between "inciting hatred" and "not deplatforming racist stuff quickly enough in one case." It's my understanding that meta actively tries to prevent hateful content in over 500 languages. It's a cool experiment to try to deplatform racist tendencies, but I don't see how you're accountable for failing to catch 100% of cases. I imagine if facebook didn't exist at all (and people were gathering in churches or in the street to organize their racism) we'd see a lot lot less of it being caught and likely more deaths.
- aaomidi 4y agoFor what it’s worth, if Facebook is unable to exist without potentially being a catalyst of hate and genocide then maybe it shouldn’t exist. https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2022/09/myanmar-facebooks-systems-promoted-violence-against-rohingya-meta-owes-reparations-new-report/ https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2022/09/myanmar-faceb...
- hulitu 4y agoA lot of PR companies would like to dissagree with you (hello Cambridge Analytica).
- Manuel_D 4y agoYou could say the same about SMS, or IRC. Or even traditional radio for that matter: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radio_T%C3%A9l%C3%A9vision_Libre_des_Mille_Collines https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radio_T%C3%A9l%C3%A9vision_L...
- knaik94 4y agoUnless there is news about Facebook employees intentionally changing their algorithm to promote violence directly, none of these arguments feel genuine. We're past the point where we can compare the world with and without Faceboook, when a social media site becomes unavailable to a certain group they will go to an alternative, as seen with Parler. Facebook mining and profiting from harvesting political user data shows a direct conflict of interest between keep data private and making money. When Facebook is used as a platform by hate groups, I can't see how they would meaningfully profit from it. Saying that encouraging or ignoring it would increase userbase is very short sighted, at the bare minimum it would caused the group being targeted to leave. These situations feel more like the debate of whether ISPs are a public utility and the EARN IT act and section 230. Holding Facebook 100% accountable would set a very dangerous precedent. Facebook is not an entity and without showing hateful posts/comments were highlighted while alternatives were not, this feels like an argument against math. Popular posts reflect the interests of the vocal population. Assigning morality to the math used in an algorithm is a failure to understand the purpose or function of it. "Inciting" would means the algorithm promoted a hateful post despite the underlying signals saying it shouldn't be promoted. https://www.culawreview.org/journal/extending-corporate-tort-liability-to-social-media-algorithms https://www.culawreview.org/journal/extending-corporate-tort...
- Eleison23 4y agoSocial media's aims are unlike any other social space to come before. Restaurants gather people together around delicious food and everyone is able to enjoy themselves at the table with a meal and friends. Friendly engagement. Parks invite people to have recreation at various stages in life, whether with team sports, a playground, just running around the grass, or a picnic. Friendly engagement. Public transit helps people congregate on vehicles for the sake of traveling to a common destination, and therefore disparate people are united by this common goal of arriving safe and sound. I could go on about all the public spaces that promote some kind of friendly engagement and socializing, but social media such as Facebook is calibrated and designed to put us at one another's throats. It's not good if we see a post and let it go by, we must lash out and correct or attack. Dislikes are as valuable as Likes in the Facebook economy. Hordes of censors are required to tamp down the inevitable violations that occur when people go out of bounds. Social media thrives and grows from attacks, libel, gossip, and falsehoods. Of course this is all only an extrapolation of print and broadcast media as it came before. Nothing has changed since Moses broke the tablets and Luther nailed up his theses. But social media is concentrated and unadulterated poison.
- tsegratis 4y agoRadio station broadcasting played a big part in initiating the Rwanda genocide However innocuous 'algorithmically promoting popular posts' is, we should not be blind, legally or otherwise to the consequences I suppose it is hard; letting a dance video go viral, is not dissimilar to enabling any other message go viral. We are eager for it; but uncheck virality typically kills the host
- phendrenad2 4y agoPeople keep saying "the algorithm did this" but where's the proof? Or do we count "showing the latest posts in chronological order" an algorithm now? Sheesh.
- alach11 4y agoFacebook hasn't showed posts in chronological order for around a decade.
- phendrenad2 4y agoThere's still no proof that the algorithm contributed to this. Maybe chronological order would result in MORE hate online. This is the argument any good lawyer would make, so you have to defeat that simple before you can move on.
- nier 4y agoThere’s a difference between simple and simplistic. This 5-year old might be mislead into thinking that there’s no difference between a phone and a social network. A phone call is low-bandwidth and ephemeral. The time it takes to disseminate information that way to a larger group is huge. Societal self-regulation has a chance to kick in. On the other hand you have high-bandwidth posts that once published can be upvoted by a single click and spread like wildfire.