6 ms·
Seawater electrolysis ignites new hope for affordable green hydrogen
- top_sigrid 4y agohttps://archive.ph/nkXDL https://archive.ph/nkXDL
- pjc50 4y agoFT article references https://www.chemistryworld.com/news/water-splitting-device-solves-puzzle-of-producing-hydrogen-direct-from-seawater/4016645.article https://www.chemistryworld.com/news/water-splitting-device-s..., which is free and references the actual paper at https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-022-05379-5 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-022-05379-5 or the DOI https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-022-05379-5 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-022-05379-5
- tinco 4y agoNot sceptical of the achievement which no doubt was a small feat. But is desalination and purification something that's been a blocker for electrolysis? I don't remember ever even seeing this in efficiency charts of for example hydrogen powered cars. Maybe I always glanced over it, but I just assumed there is always plenty fresh water available for hydrolysis, no need to even consider sea water?
- _0w8t 4y agoThere is no fresh watter at sea wind generator fields.
- tinco 4y agoNice, that's a cool scenario I hadn't thought of. I haven't heard of any deep sea wind generators, but obviously that might have great yields. I wonder if that far out at sea it wouldn't be easier/more feasible to have solar panels instead of wind mills.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deepnet 4y agoTidal turbines are a good contender. The tides are constant.
- onphonenow 4y agoAs someone who has spent a fair bit of time in / around salt water I’m skeptical of these claims. I want to see all in deployment costs with maintenance. Are these deep water or do they need to be shallow water where they will be banged up even more in storms etc
- dncornholio 4y agoI don't know about tidal forces, I do know in the Netherlands they create energy from salt / fresh water dialysis. https://redstack.nl/en/ https://redstack.nl/en/
- jcampbell1 4y agoTidal turbines are viable in inlets where currents are consistently strong during tidal changes, the problem is they often disrupt the ecosystems around where fish need to spawn. Altering the total water flow into estuaries is sketchy and the good places are typically shipping lanes. You could put them in a place like Gibraltar and live with reduced water exchange in the Mediterranean, but it will be met with a lot of resistance. Ideas that rely on moving a mass up and down 10 feet every 6 hours require floating platforms the size of Rhode Island. Not cheap to build. Neither strategy is a contender in my book. I recall a research project in France which the results were unappealing. The environmental costs were high and power generated was low. You have to be careful getting scientific knowledge from the mainstream press or researchers who need to sell their research which means it is more akin to marketing than scientific knowledge.
- moloch-hai 4y ago
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoIts easier to lay an electric cable to shore than to build a hydrogen plant at the sea, deal with corrosion, move hubdreds of staff there every day by boat and canisters of pressurised hydrogen. I am not seeing the practicality of this outside of some really niche areas.
- rolenthedeep 4y agoDesalination produces extremely concentrated brine as a waste product. Dumping that brine into coastal waters can kill a lot of marine life, so I imagine keeping the plant offshore helps. The current way the waste is handled is by laying a pipe from the shore deep underwater away from the coast. The brine is diluted with fresh seawater and pumped all the way down. By having the plant offshore, drawing in fresh water to dilute the waste becomes cheaper, and it's cheaper to build a vertical pipe to discharge the waste deep underwater. There's other byproducts like chlorine gas and sodium compounds released from cracking salt molecules. Small amounts, but keeping that offshore is a plus in my opinion.
- ClumsyPilot 4y agowhy do you need desalination, you only need a small amount of fresh water for electrolysis. Any standard city water supply will power a very large electrolysis setup. Also you seem to be massively underestimating the effect of corrosion, and needing to transport stafff and eqipment back and forth offshore
- rolenthedeep 4y agoTbh I got myself a bit mixed up. Desalination and hydrogen electrolysis have similar problems. Brine waste is still a problem with electrolysis. Everything that isn't water is left behind, and must be disposed of. Some of the dissolved gases and ions also get liberated, but in fairly small quantities. The article in question is about seawater electrolysis, and my understanding is that the dissolved ions in the water should improve efficiency (though I'm no expert). As far as corrosion, you're vastly overestimating the problem. We've been dealing with salt water corrosion for at least the last century. It isn't that bad if you keep up with maintenance. I used to work in the marine coatings industry, and the technology today is incredible. With a properly maintained coating and sacrificial anodes maintained regularly, corrosion damage is minimal. After all, we have countless steel cargo ships and oil rigs on the water today. A quick Google suggests that the lifespan of a cargo ship is on the order of 15-40 years. USS Olympia is a steel hull ship that's been in the water since 1945, and she seems to be doing fine. Salt water corrosion is a problem we know how to deal with, all it requires is regular maintenance. The cost of a good marine coating for something the size of an oil rig would be a couple hundred thousand dollars, and will last many years with regular maintenance. And as far as ferrying crew to the rig, the ferry from Seattle to Southworth costs about a million dollars a year, running 8 hours a day, ferrying up to 2400 people a day across 9 miles [0]. Extrapolate that to two or three round trips a day and you're down to a few hundred thousand dollars a year. Since the ferry is going to what is effectively a power station, it could even be powered electrically, which would further drive down the cost. Realistically, we've been building and manning offshore platforms for a very long time. Oil rigs don't rust out and collapse into the ocean. Cargo ships don't fall apart unexpectedly. We have a lot of steel floating in the ocean with no problems, as long as they are maintained. Yes, there are problems building structures in hostile environments. But we've been doing it for a very long time, and most of these problems have solutions. [0] https://leg.wa.gov/JTC/Documents/POFCostAnalysis.pdf https://leg.wa.gov/JTC/Documents/POFCostAnalysis.pdf
- eloff 4y agoYes, exactly this. These membranes will foul and need replacing. I don’t see why anyone would use this over freshwater. There’s plenty of freshwater available in many places. It literally runs into the ocean. You just don’t build one of these plants in the desert. It might be interesting in niche cases - desert countries where they're already producing water via desalination. But those countries tend to produce energy from fossil fuels anyway, and it's less effective to burn fossil fuels to split water than it is to just split methane to begin with. Maybe in the far future.
- jjk166 4y ago> You just don’t build one of these plants in the desert. If you're generating the electricity in a big solar field which would ideally be built in a desert (few clouds, cheap land) then building the electrolysis plant nearby makes sense. There are lots of areas like north Africa, western Australia, the southwest of North America, the Arabian peninsula, etc where sunlight and sea water are readily available but fresh water is at a premium. Ultra high voltage DC makes power transmission over continental scales technically possible, but the losses are still significant, having the option to use power close to where it is produced enables a lot of possibilities.
- eloff 4y agoIn Arabia and North Africa it makes more sense to use the solar to displace fossil fuel derived energy than to produce hydrogen - again if you want hydrogen and you’re burning fossil fuels for electricity it makes no sense to use the electricity to get the hydrogen - use methane and cut out the middleman. There might be some places where this could work, but they do seem quite niche.
- jjk166 4y agoYou can both provide power locally (if needed - the desert regions with little rain and cheap land tend to have minimal population) and also produce hydrogen with excess power, which could be exported to other locations, used locally as an alternative to other energy storage methods like batteries, and for various things which are not trivially electrified like industrial process heat or vehicle fuel. No one here is arguing that fossil fuels should be burned to conserve solar energy for other uses.
- chipsa 4y agoEven fresh water needs to be filtered before running it through the electrolysis. But yes, part of the problem with electrolysis is the power cost compared to current "blue" hydrogen, which is decarbonated natural gas. Some of the better places to get electricity though have been places with little fresh water, so being able use saltwater instead helps with this idea.
- defrost 4y agoThis will likely be industrialised relatively rapidly by those with deep partnership ties in China, eg: FFI / Woodside / etc. [1] https://www.fool.com.au/2022/12/09/will-fortescues-green-hydrogen-plans-really-pay-off-for-shareholders/ https://www.fool.com.au/2022/12/09/will-fortescues-green-hyd... [2] https://reneweconomy.com.au/fortescue-secures-land-rights-for-7-6gw-of-wind-and-solar-for-egypt-green-hydrogen-plans/ https://reneweconomy.com.au/fortescue-secures-land-rights-fo... [3] https://www.fmgl.com.au/in-the-news/media-releases/2022/10/12/fortescue-future-industries-and-sparc-hydrogen-accelerate-development-of-next-generation-green-hydrogen-technology https://www.fmgl.com.au/in-the-news/media-releases/2022/10/1... [4] https://www.fool.com.au/2022/11/29/did-fortescue-just-lose-out-on-this-multi-billion-dollar-green-hydrogen-project/ https://www.fool.com.au/2022/11/29/did-fortescue-just-lose-o...
- Gravityloss 4y agoWords "catalyst" or "platinum" are not mentioned in the articles. So they are not talking about those very important limiting factors.
- ben_w 4y agoGiven how cheap PV is, I think the limit is "we'd rather not actually try to keep it as moleculer hydrogen, how do we add carbon or nitrogen to it?"
- pjc50 4y agoYeah, this is something of a problem; it makes the capital cost quite high, which in turn makes it less useful for intermittency and less cost-effective as a means of energy storage.
- quaintdev 4y agoOnce we harnessed fusion, all these energy intensive tasks like desalination, electrolysis, Co2 capture will be easy, isn't it?
- defrost 4y agoSolar is Fusion .. and already available in direct light, indirect wind, and totals some 173,000 terawatts continuously reaching earth, or some 10,000x current total energy use. Usable Earth based Fusion is still quite some time away, meanwhile the immediate issue of mitigating fossil fuel byproducts is pressing.
- Retric 4y agoEconomics is more complicated than is X possible. We can make and store antimatter, but all those sci-fi applications that need significant quantities are still dozens of orders of magnitude outside our reach.
- alex_duf 4y agoIt's not fusion we need, it's cheap non polluting energy. Fusion _might_ become that cheap non polluting source, but right now we don't know. What we do know is: renewables are cheap right now. Now applied to hydrogen, we can even say that hydrogen production can perfectly adapt to the intermittency of renewables. But I'm of the opinion that we need to decarbonate our grids further before we start looking into using renewables for h2 production.
- ben_w 4y agoI think we should start looking at hydrogen before we strictly need it, because it's best to get all of this ready ASAP, and parallel is better than serial for that.
- gl-prod 4y agoWe don't want to just hang everything on "Once we harness fusion". We gotta act now, not in 100 years.
- nnurmanov 4y agoIMO, Paywalled articles should be banned. On the other hand, is there a service that charges per read?
- dredmorbius 4y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33997383 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33997383
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoAre you then gonna complain that att articles are AI written crap because noone is paying writers? Maybe if we had conpetent, well paid journalisms we would not be in the shit we are now
- burkaman 4y ago> On the other hand, is there a service that charges per read? There are services like this, https://launch.blendle.com/ https://launch.blendle.com/ for example. I have an account from a long time ago and it seems to still be working, but it hasn't really changed in 5 years and it looks like they never got out of beta, so I'm not sure if there's any ongoing effort there.
- DennisP 4y agoSomeone posted the paywall-bypassing archive link two hours before you commented.
- timbit42 4y agoYou can install a web browser add-on called, 'Bypass Paywalls Clean'. It transparently bypasses FT and over 400 other media paywalls.
- beached_whale 4y agoThis will probably suffer from the same issue as desalination. What to do with the left over brine(salt/minerals)
- detritus 4y agoStore it in old oil tankers for future dispersal in polar oceans when salinity drops from glacial melting, potentially disrupting things like the Gulf Stream? - ed "North Atlantic thermocline" is what I meant! I originally wrote "North Atlantic endocrine" before realising that was entirely wrong, and after wracking my brain went with 'gulf stream'. I need more tea.
- muttled 4y agoSell it as some sort of high-end version of regular salt at Whole Foods?
- eloff 4y agoI doubt it, much less a problem than with desalination, volume wise.
- brutusborn 4y agoThe volumes are huge. Each hydrogen molecule needs one water to break down. That adds up at industrial scale.
- eloff 4y agoThe volumes are tiny compared to desalination. Freshwater is worth much less than hydrogen.
- brutusborn 4y agoI cant seem to edit the parent comment but you are indeed correct. I thought the water usage was high because I was looking at local water usage from planned hydrogen production compared to human usage, but most of the hydrogen will be exported, so globally it averages out to a small amount that is very significant locally.
- nanomonkey 4y agoThis could be a boon for aquatic dead zones that suffer from hypoxia (low dissolved oxygen). The oxygen released during electrolysis could be reintroduced into the water to bring it back up to safe levels. Obviously some efforts need to be made to make sure that the salt and oxygen levels don't get too high.
- moloch-hai 4y agoIt would suffice to dissolve oxygen in river water on its way out. All the dead zones are at river outlets. The hydrogen freed would need to be sequestered to burn later, because hydrogen is insoluble in water, and is a 200x greenhouse gas (when counting secondary effects). There will be a hell of a lot of spare oxygen available to dissolve in water and flush to rivers, after we start producing green hydrogen. But just bubbling regular air through should suffice to saturate it, no electrolysis needed. A big perforated plate, with water running over it and air pushed under, does the job without fuss.
- seunosewa 4y ago> a 200x greenhouse gas I had no idea. So much for the hydrogen economy.
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoJust don't leak. Burning it produces water vapor, which is pretty generally available in the atmosphere. [Edit: Yes, I know "just don't leak" is the goal, and is never 100% achieved.]
- seunosewa 4y agoPreventing leaks is especially hard with hydrogen because its molecules are very tiny.
- moloch-hai 4y agoHydrogen is produced and used in the hundreds of millions of tons, today. People say it is mostly produced on demand at the site of use because of the difficulty of storing and transporting it. If it becomes an important part of the energy economy, it will need great care in preventing unavoidable leaks from escaping into the atmosphere. Of course for most uses, hydrogen will continue to be produced on the spot, by electrolysis instead of from natural gas as today. In places where it is not used immediately (e.g. to synthesize ammonia for transport), it will often be stored deep underground where leakage is less a worry. As aviation transitions to liquid hydrogen fuel, probably after 2040, hydrogen produced at major airports may be stored liquified in underground tanks, at a pressure close to ambient. Hydrogen leakage is minimal at low pressure. In general, for safety, installations that handle much hydrogen must continually flush air through indoor places with hydrogen plumbing, to prevent buildup of what would be an exceedingly dangerous mixture of hydrogen and air in confined spaces. It might be that sites handling much hydrogen will need to feed such air into an incinerator. A way to recognize significant hydrogen leaks, as we have for methane, probably will be needed.
- dusted 4y ago"They did what?" "Burned their seas." "They burned their seas?" "Yes, I'm telling you! They burned their seas!" "And they're made of what again?" "I know.. Commencing intergalactic bug spray." (I honestly think it's super cool though! And it'll just rain back down anyway! Shouldn't have a measurable impact unless super-extreme stockpiling of LH2)
- Timwi 4y agoAm I the only one who worries that if this is implemented at industrial scale, then 100 years down the line we'll be facing a new ecological catastrophe when we deplete a significant portion of the world ocean?
- credit_guy 4y agoIt's absolutely impossible to deplete a significant, or even an insignificant portion of the world ocean. To get a feel or it, it's useful to think in terms of cubic kilometers. A cubic kilometer of water weighs a billion tons (1 GT). The world consumes every year something of the order of 10 GT of fossil fuel (about 5 GT of coal and 5GT of petroleum and natural gas). Hydrogen has a higher energy density than fossil fuels (by a factor of 2 or 3). But only 10% of the water by weight is hydrogen. So, to get one GT of hydrogen you need to electrolize about 10 cubic kilometers of water. Let's say you want to fully replace all the fossil fuels with hydrogen, and then have room for further growth. 10 GT of hydrogen/year will be more than enough regardless how you project that growth. That would be 100 cubic kilometers per year, or 10000 cubic kilometers per century. The volume of the world's oceans is 1.3 billion cubic kilometers. You just used less than 0.001% of that. But actually you didn't. Because all the hydrogen you've produced and then burned to generate electricity ends up as water vapors, which after a bit of travel in the atmosphere become clouds, then rain, then end up right back in the oceans.