9 ms·
Chinese company that stole IP from ASML raises $140M
- tgv 4y agoNot surprised, but wouldn't there have been made some significant improvements since 2007? Or am I reading this wrong?
- hknmtt 4y agoChina does not recognize patent law, therefore they could not have stole anything. I am all for recognition of one's discovery but the patent law in "the west" went too far and is more a retarder rather than accelerator of progress.
- uvesten 4y agoWell, luckily China does not control the language used on HN or in the world in general, so stole it is.
- Veen 4y agoSeems untrue: > In 1985, China acceded to the Paris Convention for the Protection of Industrial Property, followed by the Patent Cooperation Treaty in 1994. When China joined the World Trade Organization (WTO) in 2001, it became a member of the TRIPS agreement. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patent_law_of_China https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patent_law_of_China
- bostonian10 4y ago
- Sakos 4y agoThe US did the same thing early on to Europe. It makes economic sense to steal IP, but that doesn't mean we should be okay with China doing it to us. They're still an economic and geopolitical rival and if we want to maintain our standard of living, maybe not give away all of our competitive advantages (since we've already handed over all our manufacturing).
- jq-r 4y agoThis argument makes my head spin. So as long as we’re hypocritical and pull up the ladder behind us - that’s fine, we don’t want to jeopardize our standard of living? Or the nicely worded phrase usually used in conjunction with boomer generation: “screw you, I’ve got mine.” Is this what we’ve came down to?
- Sakos 4y ago> Is this what we’ve came down to? You mean economic competition? I'm not sure what you're expecting here. This is how the world works. China refuses to adhere to IP law that others do. Our companies and governments spend billions upon billions on R&D. That R&D basically keeps the West relevant. In what way is it okay for that to be stolen? Meanwhile, China doesn't allow Western companies to operate in China, instead they're required to partner with a Chinese company and transfer technology. I think we've been MORE than fair with China in the past 20-30 years. We're a huge reason why they were able to raise HUNDREDS OF MILLIONS out of poverty and into the middle-class, the largest success story of the past 3 decades. > Or the nicely worded phrase usually used in conjunction with boomer generation: “screw you, I’ve got mine.” Yeah, no. Not the point. PS: I'm German.
- Veen 4y agoThat's how competition works. It's not what "we've come down to". It's what we've always been and ever will be. If the Chinese overtake the West, they'll be just as protective of Chinese IP as we are of Western IP. We compete and act to protect our own interests, as we should—it's what nations are for.
- 082349872349872 4y agoIGE/IPI was established[0] in 1888. And I think most of the "outcompetition" came due to avoiding the neighbours' strife. (the watch industry originated with Huguenot refugees from France, and relatively speaking, the difference between Heidi's depiction of an 1881 poor country contrasted to the rich people in Frankfurt, Germany, and todays perception of a rich country, lies in not having been bombed to rubble not once but twice during the last century) [0] https://www.ige.ch/en/about-us/the-history-of-the-ipi https://www.ige.ch/en/about-us/the-history-of-the-ipi [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heidi https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heidi
- krasin 4y ago> China does not recognize patent law, therefore they could not have stole anything. Here, an actual IP theft (as in "files on a USB stick") is involved. Not just violating patents.
- Brybry 4y agoLooks like they have patent law to me? Even ignoring treaties and such: "Article 42 The duration of an invention patent shall be twenty years, the duration of the patent for a utility model or design shall be ten years, counted from the date of application." [1][2] [1] http://mg.mofcom.gov.cn/article/policy/201910/20191002905592.shtml http://mg.mofcom.gov.cn/article/policy/201910/20191002905592... [2] http://www.npc.gov.cn/npc/c30834/202011/82354d98e70947c09dbc5e4eeb78bdf3.shtml http://www.npc.gov.cn/npc/c30834/202011/82354d98e70947c09dbc...
- midasz 4y agoIs it just me or is 140mil not that much? Also telling that the 'flagbearer' of the Chinese semiconductor industry is a thief. This industry is moving way too fast to copy properly. Doing business with these guys basically excludes you from ever doing business with ASML. You'd be forever behind technologically.
- varispeed 4y agoGiven the shortages, it's often hmm should I close my business or bite the bullet and go with Chinese? If Chinese didn't copy things like STM32, many businesses would be bankrupt now. The problem is that often manufacturers only care about big customers and view SMEs as nuisance, that's where China comes in.
- Roark66 4y agoIf Chinese didn't break their economy by silly covid lock downs that _still_ continue we wouldn't have shortages in the first place. Also I'm in favour of not calling it shortages, but "price gauges bonanza" as that is what it is essentially. Have you tried to buy a real fpga recently? Yes, many types are available, but the prices.... It is not really that surprising, if the only thing that kept prices in check was cheap competition from China and that competition was practically killed off by their own gov. Why would remaining companies not monetise this new market conditions by increasing prices?
- varispeed 4y agoYes, the Covid lockdowns are not helping, but I read (sorry for conspiracy theory) that these aren't really about Covid, but the real goal is to disrupt western supply chains as part of hybrid warfare. There is another aspect - Military Indistrial Complexes waking up around the world - and those under sanctions especially, buy MCUs and other parts from regular channels creating those shortages. For instance STM32F7 and H7 that are well used for control boards in drones and other military equipment are still unobtainium and unfortunately Chinese have not managed to clone them yet. > Why would remaining companies not monetise this new market conditions by increasing prices? Some product prices indeed are going up.
- rsj_hn 4y agoThe headline is misleading. The IP was "stolen" by an American company. I put stolen in quotes because an employee of US firm Brion stole his own IP, in the sense that he developed tech working for Brion, and then ASML acquired Brion, and the employee left and started a new US company, XTAL, using some of the old tech that he developed at Brion. XTAL paid a huge fine to ASML, and then the same employee went to China and was hired by a Chinese company. This Chinese company then raised some money in Chinese capital markets. That's the story. However there is no evidence that the Chinese company stole any IP from ASML, and certainly there has been no court case or finding of fact suggesting that the Chinese company is using the stolen IP. The offense committed by the Chinese company is hiring the employee of the American company who continued to use IP that was sold to ASML.
- birdyrooster 4y ago> The offense committed by the Chinese company is hiring the > employee of the American company who continued to use IP > that was sold to ASML. In the except above, you've described the means by which the company stole the IP and is using the IP illegally. How can you possibly believe that the company didn't steal IP after writing this? Did you forget a word/sentence/paragraph that explains this obvious contradiction?
- rsj_hn 4y agoI did no such thing. You are saying that this engineer, who is obviously talented, should never again be hired in his field, because anyone who hires him will only hire him to steal this (now quite ancient) tech and not for asking him to continue to innovate or even just be a productive worker. So do you really believe this or is this just an anti-China thing? Fun Fact: Many innovators in Silicon valley did the exact same thing, discovering something at one company, and then taking it to another where it was more fully developed. They then went on to continue to innovate completely new things. And sometimes there were lawsuits flying around about who stole which IP, yet the same workers continued to be hired by tech companies, and people didn't automatically assume that anyone who hired them subsequently was participating in IP theft. I guarantee you that former Uber self-driving engineers are still gainfully employed, many in the field of self-driving cars, and no one is accusing their new employers of trying to steal IP from Google. How do you justify applying this double standard?
- 082349872349872 4y agoSo IP regions may soon become Eastasia (CN+RU) No recognition/local only Oceania + Eurasia TRIPS ? Oceania has always been at war with Eastasia.
- holoduke 4y agoI wonder if the liberal west mentality is the only way to make technological progress. I dont think in an autocratic society people can really thrive. Maybe a bit. But i dont think China would ever be able to pass the US and Europe with high tech. Everything is copied and stolen. They cant even implement or come up with decent safety standards in electronic devices. Their factories are dangerous places where curruption is daily practice. The individual doesn't count. Its all about output. How can that ever lead to creativity and happy researchers. Or maybe this all is changing in China?
- arcticbull 4y ago> I wonder if the liberal west mentality is the only way to make technological progress. I dont think in an autocratic society people can really thrive. Maybe a bit. But i dont think China would ever be able to pass the US and Europe with high tech. Everything is copied and stolen. Nah, this is exactly what Japan did post-WWII until they didn't anymore. You copy until you catch up. Once you've caught up, you innovate. There's nothing fundamental that will hold China back. There are even benefits to authoritarianism - for instance Chinese infrastructure is in many cases far better than US infrastructure and built far more efficiently. The US has about 49.9 miles of high-speed rail while China built 25,000 miles in the last few years. They've even got maglev trains. We've got the diesel Caltrain (for now! electrification is finally happening). [edit] (And soon the Bakersfield-Merced Express - stopping at every cow paddock along the way). The PRC built a bridge from Hong Kong to Macau, 34mi long, and built islands along the way to support it. Never underestimate your opponent!
- winReInstall 4y agoIn a society were ip theft is the norm and success surface is everything, ask yourself what is actually real? So, if there is research, how many chinese papers get attacked by chinese researchers, and thus retracted? If nobody calls it out, can there even be a replication crisis. Now if all there is, is faked surface. What worth are all those agreements, all thos archievements and hailed green revolutions? What if all there is, is a great PR-campaign poster - and behind that.. nothing. Welcome to the desert behind stalins blooming landscape posters.
- roenxi 4y agoChina have just spent 50 years pulling off what is possibly the most transformative economic miracle in the history of humanity. Comparable to the industrial revolution. Put aside the idea that they are going to co-operate with an IP system explicitly being wielded to cripple their growth. That was always unlikely. The real question here is whether history will even see them as acting immorally. The legitimacy of IP law is supposed to be that it encourages human progress, not acts as a geopolitical weapon to stop 20% of the human population from getting uppity and competing with the US army. The problem the West has in this battle is that places with lax IP laws have a real chance to pull ahead with superior innovation. The only point in our favour is that poor IP property rights are linked to poor physical property rights. If the Chinese government could get the lesson through its thick skull that letting people own physical property was a good idea then they'd be completely unstoppable. But that is is a separate thing to IP law. Ditching most of IP law is a good idea.
- auggierose 4y agoSo people in China cannot own physical property?
- roenxi 4y agoCompare https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jack_Ma#Disappearance_from_the_public_eye https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jack_Ma#Disappearance_from_the... to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elon_Musk#SEC_lawsuit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elon_Musk#SEC_lawsuit . If I owned property, I'd rather be living in the west.
- dumb1224 4y agoIf the physical property mentioned is housing then no. In paper it's all leased. But it depends on local use. Property built in the countryside are less seen as 'commodity' so less constrained. Large development of housing are all leased.
- apexalpha 4y agoI thought the land was leased but the building is owned. Did that change or was it never the case?
- mutatio 4y agoIP espionage is always interesting in the emotions it invokes in the "us vs. them" sense - in an historic context there's nothing new under the sun (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Samuel_Slater https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Samuel_Slater)
- doesitrlymatter 4y agoWhichever prosecutor allowed the criminal foudner to flee the country after he was convicted, that prosecutor should be in orison. I look forward to the day this chinese criminal fucks up and interpol catches his commie ass.
- LatteLazy 4y agoIf you won't license someone the IP and you won't sell them the resulting tech, what does anyone actually expect them to do? To be clear, I am not making a moral argument, just a practical one. Did people really expect the CCP to just shrug and say "I guess we will be entirely reliant on Taiwan/Netherlands for top quality silicon. Including all military and research applications. And we will just accept whatever embargoes they (and America) decide"?
- hereme888 4y agoThe limits towards the CCP are based on their hostility and theft. Their hostility and theft is not based on the embargo. They are thieves to begin with. If they changed, the limits would be removed. But we know the CCP won't change.
- LatteLazy 4y agoI don't know whether that's true or not but I don't think it matters even if it is: my point was that if you ban china from buying they will steal. That's true whether they're banned for Reason A or for Reason B...