6 ms·
You can argue this over in your head a lot, but it's really quite simple in my mind. If we assume space travel becomes relatively easy (that is to say it is us
by sliverstorm 15y ago
You can argue this over in your head a lot, but it's really quite simple in my mind.
If we assume space travel becomes relatively easy (that is to say it is used for more than initial colonization) there will be interstellar commerce. If there is unprotected commerce, there will be pirates. Any time there are pirates, protection will develop. Let us call these peace-keepers the Navy.
If you engage in commerce and you have a powerful Navy, you can influence or even control commerce.
Do you see where I'm going? Most wars are about resources. Commerce is about resources. Anywhere you have commerce, you are liable to develop conflict.
- weavejester 15y agoI think you're looking at this with a 20th century viewpoint. There doesn't seem like there'd be a lot of physical matter that an advanced civilisation might want to pirate. Perhaps some form of exotic matter, like a black hole, might fit the bill, but that would be particularly hard to steal because everyone could see where you were taking it.
- sliverstorm 15y agoUntil you can fabricate matter in your MrFusion6000, material resources in some form or another will continue to be valuable. Once you CAN fabricate, Einstein tells us you will need a TON of energy to do so. So, even if that day comes, you will still need to acquire energy.
- weavejester 15y agoSure, but even today, raw material resources tend not to be the sort of things criminals target directly. You rarely get thieves trying to steal lumber, or iron ore, for example, because they have a low price-to-weight ratio.
- archgoon 15y agoI think you need to pay more attention. Lumber: http://www.northfulton.com/Articles-CRIME-c-2011-12-05-190412.114126-sub-Lumber-theft-thwarted-in-Alpharetta-neighborhood.html http://www.northfulton.com/Articles-CRIME-c-2011-12-05-19041... Iron: http://allafrica.com/stories/201112210073.html http://allafrica.com/stories/201112210073.html Steel: http://www.post-gazette.com/pg/11280/1180364-455.stm http://www.post-gazette.com/pg/11280/1180364-455.stm Copper: http://www.reuters.com/article/2009/04/16/idUSLG73912 http://www.reuters.com/article/2009/04/16/idUSLG73912 http://www.guardian.co.uk/business/2011/jun/06/sheffield-copper-theft-national-rail http://www.guardian.co.uk/business/2011/jun/06/sheffield-cop... http://www.abc.net.au/news/2011-09-06/copper-theft/2873346 http://www.abc.net.au/news/2011-09-06/copper-theft/2873346
- ramchip 15y agoHe's talking about raw ore, and you're citing articles about concentrated/refined/treated metals and construction lumber.
- weavejester 15y ago1. None of those things are strictly raw materials; they've all been refined, cut or treated in some fashion. 2. Coming up with a several examples doesn't show that such thefts aren't rare in comparison to other thefts.
- duck 15y agoHow about copper? We had someone steal it from the crawlspace of a house we rent out.
- Retric 15y agoIt's a question of scarcity, platinum, gold, silver, and copper still have value, salt does not.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- brazzy 15y agoRead TFA, it argues pretty convincingly that there will not be pirates because A) you can't hide in space and B) Any ship is a WMD, so governments will do anything to keep them out of the hands of criminals, and protection rackets would be a far more profitable use for them than raiding commerce.
- sliverstorm 15y agoYou could apply the same arguments to why wooden naval combat shouldn't have happened. You'd think there is nowhere to hide on the ocean- but there is the horizon to hide behind (planets anyone?) and weather (electrical or magnetic storms?) to hinder visibility.
- weavejester 15y agoAll you need is a few hundred monitoring stations scattered throughout the solar system and you'd have 100% visibility. There's no phenomenon in space equivalent to planet-side weather that would regularly obscure or inhibit any monitoring system stationed in space.
- electromagnetic 15y agoPirates are generally noted as coming after privateers. Privateers had plenty of places to hide. Notably privateers with letters of marque against Spanish shipping had British, French and Dutch ports to hide in. Piracy developed when the pirates could appear easily as privateers. If you didn't piss of your host nation, then you were free to loot the ships you wanted. Then pirates gained enough money and power that they could start their own micronations. Note that privateer ships were often enlisted by the military during wars, so it's safe to assume an assault on a pirate haven was out of the question for the military. Especially when pirate controlled settlements were often cleared by privateers issued letters of marque on condition of clearing the settlement. I don't see how governments will keep ships out of the hands of criminals when governments show little desire to exploit space, where as corporations do. Corporations will grow very quickly in space, governments won't. Governments are likely to spread via colonies rather than commerce or expansion. The guy doesn't argue convincingly that there won't be pirates, because his argument should have meant pirates wouldn't have existed in the 1700's. The Spanish knew where the pirates and privateers were running to, but they were well enough armed that you wanted superior numbers. So it was a matter of attacking a solitary ship with more fire power before it could reach a safe port. Even though Port Royal and Tortuga were known as lawless ports, there was plenty of law there. The Spanish weren't about to invade a port with cannons on its battlements and dozens of privateer and pirate ships docked. Many of these pirate ships were better crewed and equipped than their respective nations military ships. Stede Bonnet had a sloop with 120 men and 16 guns. He was captured when he only had 50 men and was beached in a harbour. Notably the military brought 2 of the same tonnage ship, notably 8 gun vessels which Bonnet's ship had originally been at the start of his life of crime. [Edit: IIRC Rhett had 130 men on his two ships and simply outlasted Stede whose crew surrendered - Stede wanted to blow his ship up rather than surrender]
- ew 15y agoUnless we can effectively teleport, there won't be any interstellar commerce. Everything is too far away. Interplanetary, maybe, but within our solar system.
- transphenomenal 15y agoThere was commerce between the Romans and ancient china that took around 10 years one way. I don't remember what was being traded, except for the silk from china, but it shows that distance and time are not absolute limiters for trading.
- MatthewPhillips 15y agoHere's a good article about traveling to Alpha Centauri[1]. It posits that it would take 85 years best-case-scenario technology and 81k years using current technology. Absent the discovery of new physics that allows us to travel through wormholes or something of that ilk, traveling to the other side of the galaxy for a vacation will, sadly, not be happening. Instead long-distance space travel will likely involve putting humans into cryosleep and then waking them up when they reach their destination; hundreds of thousands or millions of years in the future. [1] http://www.universetoday.com/15403/how-long-would-it-take-to-travel-to-the-nearest-star/ http://www.universetoday.com/15403/how-long-would-it-take-to...
- redthrowaway 15y agoWhy send humans at all? By that time I'd assume we'd have reasonable AI; just send it along with a bunch of frozen embryos anywhere you please. The AI can incubate and raise the children. It could even terraform the planet until it was habitable. You wouldn't even need to explore; just send out probes willy-nilly. If they never reach a suitable location, then it's no big loss. A fire-and-forget method of human space colonization is not only far more feasible, but also far more economical.
- JDulin 15y agoI think your argument is aiming at the right target, but is using the wrong ammo. The essay outlines why piracy is not possible (or at least practical) for space commerce. However, it is very plausible that nations will fight over shipping routes and try to destroy each other's freighters and merchant ships. Like you said "Anywhere you have commerce, you are liable to develop conflict." This will be true, but probably only between political states.
- skore 15y agoTrue, but probably only until space flight becomes less prohibitively expensive, or the commerce that happens in space becomes more "interesting", to pirates.
- electromagnetic 15y agoIncidentally it was the nations of England, France, Spain and Denmark that caused piracy. Not only did they give charters to captains to give them the right to attack another nations ships, but they harboured them. The British ports were notorious for this. Spain had control of the gold, so Britain allowed their pirates to attack the gold galleons and haul it back to British ports. The pirates would eventually spend said gold in the port buying items imported from Europe and transferring wealth back to the old world (incidentally this actually faired better for England than it did Spain, as the Spanish gold went into the governments coffers. The stolen gold entered the economy). I agree, piracy isn't likely to happen just randomly. Without ports harbouring pirates the oceans became clear pretty quickly. The European superpowers didn't want to go to war with each other, but it was still in their own best advantage to sabotage the other. Remember the majority of 'pirates' were privateers. Many privateer ships were commissioned when their host nation went to war and decommissioned when the war ended. Whenever you see in the movies a pirate ship landing at Port Royal or Tortuga, then they likely had letters of marque from Britain or France against the Spanish, if not they would be real pirates and even then they'd have safe harbour if they didn't piss off the authorities. Steed Bonnet for instance was a pirate attacking British/any vessels. However he received an official pardon (along with Blackbeard) from his life of crime. However (unlike Blackbeard) he set sail for a Dutch settlement to buy a letter of marque and become a Dutch privateer against the Spanish. However, this didn't happen. He turned to all out piracy very shortly after his departure and when news got back that it was him, then the governor that pardoned him sent the military after him. Then he did the neck hanging dance. Privateers were even known to reclaim colonies from pirates for being issued letters of marque. IMO piracy and privateers have a very strong likelihood of occurring. We're already seeing signs that it's going to be companies to exploit space before governments, similar to in the Caribbean. It will only take one nation permitting privateers to operate before all nations and companies of size will be operating privateers. It's the logical step if governments aren't capable of exerting their force more than corporations.