4 ms·
It isn't easy to build a thermally efficient building with balloon framing. That's because you have solid wood between the inner and outer skin in hundreds of
by londons_explore 4y ago
It isn't easy to build a thermally efficient building with balloon framing. That's because you have solid wood between the inner and outer skin in hundreds of places. And wood has a thermal conductivity of 0.2 W/mK, which is pretty bad compared to say PIR foam insulation at 0.02 W/mK.
Anywhere with high energy prices, hot/cold climates, or environmentally conscious buyers, thats a no-go!
- csours 4y agoInteresting solution: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UtviZ2GHWCI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UtviZ2GHWCI If you don't want to click it's T-Studs - 2x3s with diagonals dowels with a 1.5 inch air gap
- londons_explore 4y agoFrustrating to find that they're more expensive than regular studs - they ought to be cheaper because they need less wood to make, less mass to transport, etc. The actual manufacturing steps I'm sure are all automated, and not exactly complex, so the added manufacturing steps should be far outweighed by the reduced raw material and logistics cost. I'm going to guess the increased price is some combination of 'we have a patent on it' and 'we charge more because there are no competitors, because we have a patent on it'.
- crazygringo 4y agoHuh? Yes it is -- that's what insulation sheathing is for, a layer in between the wood and the exterior. They're the gigantic pink foam panels you see covering buildings under construction. Balloon framing is extremely thermally efficient, which is why it's used in places like the northeast US which have freezing winters!
- mikeg8 4y agoEh, kind of. Builders in the northeast didn’t choose balloon framing because it’s thermally efficient - they just didn’t have alternatives in the same cost range. Many homes in that region were build with masonry claddings as well to increase thermal mass and R value of the wall. The foam sheet insulation you speak of is relatively new to the industry, at least for middle class homes. Having a continuous layer of insulation outside the framing definitely makes stick framing more energy efficient than it would be with traditional fiberglass batt insulation in a wall cavity.
- londons_explore 4y agoThat layer is far too thin to have much impact. Most american buildings talk about R10 to R15, and occasionally you might get up to R20 if you build it well. Verticals of balloon framing are usually ~R5. New buildings in England need to have walls of R32 as an absolute legal minimum (and more for ceilings and floors). And England has pretty mild weather compared to much of the USA.
- crazygringo 4y ago(Edit: never mind, deleted misinformed comment as londons_explore helpfully explained that I was comparing US imperial units to European SI units. Thanks, londons_explore!)
- londons_explore 4y agoR values in Europe are metric, whereas the US is imperial. The conversion factor is 5.67. All values in my post are in imperial units to be consistent with the original poster and most of the HN readership.
- hasbot 4y agoWith modern products, it is easy. Check out the ZIP System which glues foam insulation to OSB.
- brudgers 4y agoStructural insulated panels are lightweight and efficient in terms of materials, but they are a long lead time engineered product manufactured in bespoke factories for specific requirements of each project. Which is to say there are shop drawings and you can’t just go down to the store on Saturday and strap a few to the roof of your station wagon even if you just want to build a shed. In the broad sweep of history they are a modern product. But in 1995 I worked with a guy who used to work at the local plant. That’s how I learned about them. Later he and his brother built a house out of them…that’s where the panels on top of the wagon image comes from.
- dsmmcken 4y agoThat's SIP, not Zip. Zip is like regular sheeting, but can have an inner layer of foam to thermally break the structure.
- turtlebits 4y agoExterior foam or rock wool makes it fairly easy. Also see Zip sheathing which laminates polyiso to OSB. Double stud construction with blown in cellulose has also been around a long time. (You can get R45 with a 12” wall)