4 ms·
It's notable how building construction is very regional. For example, balloon framing is very rare in most of Europe - where people generally prefer brick, sto
by londons_explore 4y ago
It's notable how building construction is very regional.
For example, balloon framing is very rare in most of Europe - where people generally prefer brick, stone, blocks or even cast concrete. Something that won't rot away or creak in the wind.
- gonzo41 4y agoWealthy Europeans 'generally' build for the next generation. Also they have winter to deal with.
- makeitdouble 4y agoTrue, also to note brick construction traditionally can be dirt cheap if you adjust for materials and processes that are readily available locally. Nowadays there’s the option to go with hollow concrete blocks which makes building way faster and cheaper as well.
- crazygringo 4y agoBallon framing filled with insulation and covered with insulating sheathing is far more energy-efficient than old walls made of brick, stone, or concrete in the winter. That's why in the freezing northeast of the USA, it's all balloon framing -- while in sunny Florida they can build with cinder blocks instead.
- prottog 4y ago> Also they have winter to deal with. Europe doesn't really have winter compared to North America, unless you're making a quip about their energy crisis ;-). Compare someplace continental and ridiculously far north like Rovaniemi, Finland to, say, Fargo, ND; the latter has colder winters, despite being 20 degrees of latitude further south. And yet everyone in Fargo builds with stick frames. A well-built and well-maintained wood house can last multiple generations and keep warm in the meantime. Though, granted it's probably more expensive to maintain than equivalent masonry.
- ilyt 4y ago> Europe doesn't really have winter compared to North America, unless you're making a quip about their energy crisis ;-) Neither does most of America. You nitpicked one place in NA then forgot sweden finland and norway exists...
- Chilko 4y agoThey literally compared that place to a location in Finland...
- jameshart 4y agoScandinavia is also famously associated with timber construction, so…
- brudgers 4y agoA quick google suggests Alaska is almost twice as large as Scandinavia.
- ckrapu 4y agoThe American interior generally does not benefit from the same moderating influence of major water bodies as Scandinavia does. The winters are quite different. That's why you can have frequent awfully cold conditions as far south as Oklahoma (and sometimes Texas) despite being as far south as Egypt or Jordan.
- prottog 4y agoAs others pointed out, I nitpicked the one place in Scandinavia that would actually get cold, to make the comparison fair. Places further north than Rovaniemi (my example) that are closer to the ocean, like Tromsø, have milder winters due to the moderating influence of the Gulf Stream. This is a fairly well-known concept. From a starting place in Europe, usually one has to travel 10-15 degrees of latitude south to find similar winter temperatures in North America. See: - Helsinki, Finland vs. Syracuse, NY: 17 degrees of latitude - Warsaw, Poland vs. Pittsburgh, PA: 12 degrees - Berlin, Germany vs. Roanoke, VA: 13 degrees You have to go into Russia to find truly cold winters. Kazan, probably the coldest major city in the European side of Russia, has similar winter temperatures to Edmonton, AB, only two degrees further south.
- protastus 4y agoIndeed. I used to look down on the balloon framing + drywall construction used in the US. Until I bought a house in an earthquake zone and learned that my preferred building techniques involving brick and mortar would be completely unsafe. Then I thought about cold climate energy efficiency, and my way was pretty much terrible and once again inadequate. Understanding the requirements made me develop a lot of respect for balloon framing.
- poutine 4y agoStick and frame is an excellent construction technique. Built to modern code it'll not creak in the wind nor rot away. Further it can be framed by one person if needed with nothing more than a pick up truck and a local hardware store. It'll not fall over in an earthquake. Renovations are easy. Insulating is easy. It's a carbon sink. And best yet, it's much cheaper to build.
- orthoxerox 4y agoThe biggest issue with stick framing is the building envelope. It's very sensitive to the quality of the air/water barrier. Lots of subpar contractors around that don't care about taping together different pieces of house wrap, covering fastener and conduit holes, taping the window and door apertures correctly. You end up with moisture inside your walls and thermal losses that are annoying to diagnose and even more annoying to fix.
- prottog 4y agoI think it's not that people in Europe prefer sturdier stuff, I think it's that all the wood has already been cut down, so timber construction is not priced cheaply enough to offset its disadvantages vs. masonry. > Something that won't rot away or creak in the wind. Even in parts of the US that have a much harsher environment than any part of Europe -- extremely hot and humid weather conducive to wood rot, termite infestations, hurricanes and tornadoes -- people still build with wood because it's a lot cheaper. Sometimes I think it's strange, but it also makes sense, I suppose.
- EdwardDiego 4y agoIndeed, in New Zealand, for residential housing we have traditionally avoided such materials due to earthquakes. Timber framing is better at moving with the energy of an earthquake, so less likely to fail, and when it fails, well, it's far less heavy if it lands on you. The only injuries that occurred timber framed houses in Christchurch in the 2011-02-22 earthquake were from brick chimneys falling through the roof.