5 ms·
There's a universe of FOSS that hasn't needed third-party payment, lawyers, accountants, etc. because they do not perceive the purpose of apps as "making money.
by Waterluvian 4y ago
There's a universe of FOSS that hasn't needed third-party payment, lawyers, accountants, etc. because they do not perceive the purpose of apps as "making money."
That universe doesn't quite exist on iOS, partly because Apple makes it so uncomfortable in ways to attempt. I am hopeful that this shakeup might, in some way, make that easier. I've always wanted to ship some basic apps that do things without any ads or purchases or whatnot.
- theturtletalks 4y agoIt is likely that the use of web-based experiences will eventually surpass the need for app stores. In many cases, the functionality of a website is similar to that of a mobile app. However, Apple's restrictions on the progress of progressive web apps (PWAs) on Safari may slow the transition from app stores to web-based options. In the meantime, it may be worthwhile to consider visiting a website before downloading an app for your next mobile experience.
- ephimetheus 4y agoI have never encountered a PWA where you couldn’t immediately tell it was one. If that ever goes away, then maybe.
- xwdv 4y agoIt could easily go away we just have to allow PWAs greater access to native features on our phones.
- ephimetheus 4y agoIn terms of raw capabilities, sure. But they will still feel worse since native apps are almost always much nicer to use in my experience.
- Waterluvian 4y agoI write web applications for a living and while I LOVE how well-featured the browser APIs are becoming, sometimes I just want an app. I don't really subscribe to one camp. There's pros and cons to both.
- aequitas 4y agoThat’s funny. Because when the iPhone launched Apple offered just that: their own native apps and the rest had to contend with web based apps and a api to access phone specific features and UI elements. Only much later they announced the App Store and I doubt they will let it go now. In favor of non native web interfaces.
- chrisan 4y ago> I've always wanted to ship some basic apps that do things without any ads or purchases or whatnot. Besides the developer program cost (which I assume will still exist in this EU world) what is stopping you from doing this now?
- anonymousab 4y agoApple's review process and their rules about the kind of apps and code that are allowed to run? Heck, do they even allow GPLv2 and GPLv3 apps on the app store?
- Someone 4y agoIt doesn’t matter whether they do. The anti-tivoization clause in the GPLv3 license (https://www.gnu.org/licenses/gpl-faq.html#Tivoization https://www.gnu.org/licenses/gpl-faq.html#Tivoization) forbids developers from selling iOS apps that contain GPLv3-licensed software (the situation w.r.t. GPLv2 is less clear)
- heavyset_go 4y agoIt would violate the terms of those licenses for Apple to distribute binaries in the same manner that they currently are.
- kaba0 4y agoThe price of a developer account? FOSS is a big enough giveaway as is, most people doesn’t like the idea of paying for giving away their own free time
- Despegar 4y agoIf the FOSS universe wants to make web apps, that's great. But they didn't need this law to do that. If they want to make native iOS apps, well now they'll be using Apple's intellectual property, which won't be for free.
- EMIRELADERO 4y agoWhy is "making an app that calls iOS APIs" an use of Apple's IP that they should be compensated for? That's like saying people shouldn't be allowed to make unofficial accesories for physical products without paying the company because the original designs for the product itself are patented.
- Siira 4y agoIt should be Free. People are okay with literally stealing money from corporations in the name of “tax,” yet they balk at making SDKs Free? Platforms should capture some of the economic returns to have good incentives to improve, but the majority should go to users and third-party developers. It should also be possible to release GPL software on any platform. That’s the minimum bar for not screwing over users.
- ls15 4y agoIndeed. If we will not get iDroid soon, I expect the EU regulation to be adjusted to the point that ensures that FOSS does not get locked out anymore.