3 ms·
You have it the other way around almost 100%. The reason crypto has the absurd valuations that it does have is entirely because of the centralized exchanges tha
by tsimionescu 4y ago
You have it the other way around almost 100%. The reason crypto has the absurd valuations that it does have is entirely because of the centralized exchanges that were offering an easy way for lots of actual money to come into the space (and leave it).
As the larger exchanges collapse, it's also clear that many of these prices were simply invented. For example, it's pretty clear that FTX + Alameda alone invented at least a few billion dollars that simply never existed, but that were priced into BTC and others. Tether is almost certainly doing something very similar, as may be Binance and others.
And these are just some of the make-believe dollars in crypto. You then have all of the minor coins where someone buys one for a dollar and sells it back for two dollars, and someone else who had bought a thousand for a thousand dollars gets shown by some exchange that their funds doubled in value! And now they can leverage that to buy even more worthless coins, causing someone else to think their funds are increasing in value and so on.
It's all a house of cards propped up by savvy unscrupulous marketers.
Will BTC or ETH or Monero fall to 0 if the exchanges died? Probably not, as people actually do use them in some small measure (international payments with countries with failed banking systems, money laundering, evading sanctions, etc). But they would be back closer to where they were 10 years ago, a few dollars or maybe hundreds of dollars for 1 BTC. And most of the others would just die out.
- mattbrewsbytes 4y ago> fact that FTX was selling coins without delivering them I think you missed the point parent was making about the fraud of accepting money for $crypto_thing and not actually buying $crypto_thing and just moving the money to the Alameda hedge fund. All of that purchasing never impacted the prices of $crypto_thing. The other thing that will be interesting is if they uncover fraud around $crypto_things that were supposedly tracking actual SEC regulated securities as a derivative and if any Wall Street finance firms were using those FTX derivatives as part of their business.
- tsimionescu 4y agoEven if that is how it worked, what do you think Alameda was doing with the money it got? It's not like Alameda was investing in the stock markets - it was still pouring it into crypto. As for how the scam worked, my understanding is different - my understanding is that they both bought the token you asked for AND lent the same money to Alameda (who would then go on to buy it's own crypto) - because much of the buying was happening from other FTX accounts, which didn't actually require the dollars. So the same dollars were getting reflected both in the price of the crypto consumers asked for, and again in the prices of the crypto that Alameda was trading.