3 ms·
Of course not; the point of a state is to be the sole place where tyrannical powers can be found. I'd like to say that in a democracy the use of such powers ar
by ben_w 4y ago
Of course not; the point of a state is to be the sole place where tyrannical powers can be found.
I'd like to say that in a democracy the use of such powers are limited, but every so often I find myself disappointed by news that such powers are directed at protesters in the UK, and my news about the US leans towards "gosh don't these police cars look suspiciously more capable than actual military vehicles".
For stuff like this, my main concern is that it creates an easy way for hostile agents (someone else's security agencies rather than our own) to break things that ought not to be breakable.
But, given that most people (including most criminals) are clueless about digital security, this kind of thing may genuinely be useful for breaking into otherwise-secret chat forums.
I can't balance these competing concerns. I really hope the people on our side ("security is good") are getting taken seriously by the agencies; but I don't have any reason to think that hope is anything more than wishful thinking.
- matheusmoreira 4y agoWe shouldn't balance any concerns, we should simply reject the idea that the governments should have any access at all. I'm convinced the whole purpose of the government granting itself these powere is to abuse them. There is no reason to accept this as legitimate. The governments of the world are essentially our enemies. Encryption technology needs to start threat modeling with governments in mind. Cryptography must be so ubiquitous and undefeatable that it's impossible for any government to do anything about it short of nuking its own citizens.
- ben_w 4y agoI would love to be able to reject the idea of the government having any access, except I keep running into the messy reality of human nature. Heck, I’d do away with governments existing and advocate anarchism, except for the messy reality of human nature.
- mindslight 4y ago> the point of a state is to be the sole place where tyrannical powers can be found Sure, but that doesn't imply that we should create new tyrannical powers out of whole cloth, just so the state can have them. The more that power remains distributed, allowing the population freedom and self-determination, the better.
- ben_w 4y agoI wish what you say was possible, because I certainly like that world: my preference would be anarchy, except people keep disappointing me by finding new ways to dominate and rule — it seems (human) nature abhors a (power) vacuum.
- matheusmoreira 4y agoYeah, anarchy is a fundamentally impossible state. People naturally form groups because it increaes their chance of survival, every group of humans has rules, they cede power to leaders who solve their problems for them, people who don't like it will leave and join another group or become lone wolves. The problem with governments is they dominate the entire earth. They force their social contract on us and we're forced to accept it just because we happened to be born somewhere. We can't just reject their power and rules: leaving is expensive, difficult or impossible and the only thing we can do is escape to another imperfect government.
- mindslight 4y agoComplete anarchy makes for an unachievable goal. What's possible is looking for ways to keep specific dynamics more anarchistic/free. Sure, in a sense the dual authoritarian powers of government/capital are always going to be looking for ways to push into our lives, turn voluntary two party relationships into chaperoned/extractive three party ones, etc. But as individuals that wish to remain individuals living in a distributed society, our job is to push back.