2 ms·
> The answer to "why hasn't technology disrupted [XYZ]" is always that the problems in XYZ weren't technology related in the first place. I wonder why one woul
by TeMPOraL 4y ago
> The answer to "why hasn't technology disrupted [XYZ]" is always that the problems in XYZ weren't technology related in the first place.
I wonder why one would want to "disrupt* [XYZ] in general, and education in particular. Disruption seems to me to almost always being a net negative for everyone except the upstarts who displaced the incumbents by literally breaking their market - particularly, the customers end up holding the short end of the stick.
> Ultimately technology won't "fix" the higher education system, but simply make it less relevant in the practical world.
That is how technology works, which is why I don't like the whole "you can't fix a social problem with technology" line. You absolutely can. It's usually the only way you can fix it. And most of the time, the fix doesn't address the problem directly, just makes it go away by restructuring incentives that lead to it in the first place.
Thus, my belief is that the answer to "why hasn't technology disrupted [XYZ]" is that the technology the asker has in mind barks up the wrong tree. The [XYZ] in question isn't a fixed artifact you can sculpt, but an equilibrium of economic and social incentives. It's dynamically maintained, so pushing directly against it means you'll be pushed back at. You can make a small dent somewhere, then you run out of money or will, and status quo resumes.
EDIT:
Or, if you have access to billions of dollars of VC money, you can try and do it the hard way, to detonate a metaphorical nuke in a valley to reshape it completely. Maybe you'll succeed, but more likely, you'll just starve every established company/institution to death, and then still run out of money, leaving just a completely broken [XYZ]. See my previous point about disruption not being all that positive. It's what's currently happening in food delivery and private transportation, as restaurants and taxi companies are being outcompeted by unsustainable corporations operating at a loss.
- AnimalMuppet 4y ago> Disruption seems to me to almost always being a net negative for everyone except the upstarts who displaced the incumbents by literally breaking their market - particularly, the customers end up holding the short end of the stick. There's plenty of "customers" (students) who wind up holding the short end of the current stick, too. People who, say, wind up $50,000 in debt, and still didn't manage to get a degree. Or people who wind up $50,000 in debt and graduate, but with a degree that isn't worth that. Or even people who get a worthwhile degree, but still wind up $50,000 in debt. > That is how technology works, which is why I don't like the whole "you can't fix a social problem with technology" line. You absolutely can. It's usually the only way you can fix it. Yes and no. You can maybe stop your gullible grandmother from getting so many scam phone calls with SHAKEN/STIR. You can't stop her next-door neighbor from pulling her into a multi-level marketing deal, though. SHAKEN/STIR may stop (most) scam phone calls, but it doesn't fix the gullibility at all.
- pjmlp 4y agoThat is very country specific, as most countries actually do have easier paths into higher level education than US, that don't require a lifetime of savings since the child is born. So outside US, and a few other countries with similar approach to high level education, there isn't nothing to disrupt.