3 ms·
What about signaling of not just acquired knowledge, but the ability to apply it in a meaningful way? in other words - education and what it measures (grades)
by m463 4y ago
What about signaling of not just acquired knowledge, but the ability to apply it in a meaningful way?
in other words - education and what it measures (grades) may or may not correlate with a successful person.
is there a way to measure or predict if a person is or will be successful? And this isn't just for hiring, it is also part of a good feedback loop for helping people get an education.
- Hermitian909 4y ago> What about signaling of not just acquired knowledge, but the ability to apply it in a meaningful way? The best predictor of being able to apply knowledge is better mastery of that knowledge and the context in which you are applying it, e.g. to be a creative mathematician you must know some things relating to the problems you're solving deeply. > is there a way to measure or predict if a person is or will be successful Most companies use the following signals 1. A track record of success 2. Intelligence 3. Consentiousness - the willingness to do required work even if you don't want to 4. Stress tolerance This is somewhat unsatisfying. One would hope you'd also try to detect attitudes or ideologies that blind you to entire solution spaces or being a massive jerk and alienating people around you.
- TeMPOraL 4y ago> What about signaling of not just acquired knowledge, but the ability to apply it in a meaningful way? You survived the 3-5 year ordeal and got your BSc or MSc, this implies you can apply some knowledge in some way. > in other words - education and what it measures (grades) may or may not correlate with a successful person. The signal universities provide is not perfect, or even very strongly correlated with anyone's ability to excel in a specific domain. But it is somewhat positively correlated, which means using it as employment filter will weed out more bad than good candidates, which makes hiring cheaper and less risky. In other words: however bad the correlation is, it's already good enough to be useful. > is there a way to measure or predict if a person is or will be successful? I worry this is an anti-inductive problem: i.e. if you can measure the right factors and predict if a person will be successful accurately enough, you can make people successful (look at it as closed-loop control problem) - but it's most likely cheaper to just make them seem successful instead. The measure becomes a target, and so eventually will cease to become a good measure. (In a sense, BSc and MSc titles are suffering from just that. They're no longer anywhere as strong a signal than they were 50 years ago.) > And this isn't just for hiring, it is also part of a good feedback loop for helping people get an education. Unfortunately, the two goals - teaching for economic prospects, and educating for a rich and successful life in a more general sense - are at odds with each other.