2 ms·
I feel like the data loss risk doesn't really make sense to be worried about. It doesn't matter what FS or storage system you use, you _need_ a backup if you ac
by Gigachad 4y ago
I feel like the data loss risk doesn't really make sense to be worried about. It doesn't matter what FS or storage system you use, you _need_ a backup if you actually care about the data. And if you have backups, you are fine.
As a random anecdote I've been using BTRFS for everything for over 7 years now and had no issues. Think the only FS I've ever had problems with was ExFAT.
- pavon 4y agoI think it is important for two reasons. First, the primary purpose of RAID is to improve availability of your data, such that you can continue operating in spite of a hardware failure. If the RAID feature of btrfs has serious data loss problems, then it is taking a feature that is supposed to increase availability, and instead decreasing it. It is like an UPS that is more likely to cause a power outage than to protect you from one. The other reason is that the atomic snapshot feature, and ability to easily transfer diffs of snapshots makes a wonderful foundation for incremental backups. But if I can't trust the filesystem to avoid corrupting my data, how can I trust it to avoid corrupting my snapshots? Hence I can't trust my backups. So I need to go back to a more independent backup processes like rsync. With those two features gone, my whole motivation for using btrfs over simpler file systems like ext4 is gone, so why bother.
- Gigachad 4y ago>With those two features gone Still seen no real proof this is true. It's always vague feelings and anecdotes. has anyone done any real testing to measure file corruption?
- Matthias247 4y agodata corruption is slightly orthogonal to data loss. If your filesystem silently corrupts some data in a way you don't notice, you might just replicate the corrupted data to your backup system over time. And in that case you will still have lost it. Data loss - e.g. due to a disk failure - is a lot more obvious.