5 ms·
There is one huge problem behind esports: their viewers are always going to be limited by the actual game's userbase. As no game grows forever at some point th
by epolanski 4y ago
There is one huge problem behind esports: their viewers are always going to be limited by the actual game's userbase.
As no game grows forever at some point the popularity of the esport is also going to fall.
Esports are here to stay but the dreams of any videogame being able to catch and retain viewers for decades is just never going to be there.
- pastacacioepepe 4y agoOr at least until competitive games become as enjoyable to watch as, say, a soccer game. It's true that most competitive games just look like a mess if you haven't played them. I guess game devs should start optimizing animations, camera and effects for viewers, rather than just for players, perhaps with a "viewer" mode that is different from the player mode.
- jmcgough 4y ago> I guess game devs should start optimizing animations, camera and effects for viewers, rather than just for players, perhaps with a "viewer" mode that is different from the player mode. They've put a lot of work into this for league of legends.
- nickff 4y ago>" There is one huge problem behind esports: their viewers are always going to be limited by the actual game's userbase." Is this true? I know many people who watch e-sports of games they don't play, and professional outdoor sports are often watched by people who rarely if ever play the game (football is a good example of this).
- 8note 4y agoMinecraft is the obvious eSports example
- thinkmcfly 4y agoI've been watching pro StarCraft Broodwar since 2005. 2 decades soon! If they had released new mechanics since then they would have killed the community. Modern esports lack the locked in balance that leads to nuanced play and decades of viewership, save for games like Cs and starcraft bw that avoid chasing the 'next gen' marketing ploy. Blizzard did it's part to try to kill scbw esports but they failed
- jjcm 4y ago> Modern esports lack the locked in balance that leads to nuanced play and decades of viewership Dota has been around for 20 years now and League has been around for 13. Both of which are modern esports game that are well balanced.
- misterprime 4y agoI can't speak for DotA, but isn't LoL's business model to continuously add new characters? This constant change never lets the true balance of the game be discovered the way it is with SC:BW. Players constantly need to adapt to new characters and modified game elements. It's not necessarily bad, but it's very different than leaving a game alone for a long time. For example, chess never got any patches, but new techniques and strategies developed for ages.
- kibwen 4y agoI agree that modern esports fail in many aspects e.g. stability, simplicity, readability, etc., though worth keeping in mind that "chess" was not a standardized/codified game for the first thousand or so years of its existence, and many of its newer developments (e.g. the pawn's two-space move, castling, en passant) could be viewed as balance patches.
- P5fRxh5kUvp2th 4y agoFor anyone who isn't familiar with Dota's history, the above poster is effectively lying (yes, lying). Starcraft and Warcraft 3 had what they called "custom maps" that people would play competitively online, with completely different styles of gameplay than the original game. There were probably thousands of custom maps, but over time "genres" of map became more popular than others. Dota is one such map, but it became so popular that in 2013 Valve released Dota2. Valve got involved because a few of their employees were fans of the original Dota mod and they wanted to build a modern sequel. Dota, in terms of esports (aka Dota 2), is less than 10 years old. Dota as a genre can draw it's LINEAGE back to the original mod from 2003, but that's about it.
- jmcgough 4y agoThis is true for a lot of games, but less true in evergreen games that can continue to update in perpetuity forever. League of Legends has been around for over a DECADE and the esports scene for it is bigger than it's ever been.
- nightpool 4y agoTFA: > Making matters worse, viewership for League of Legends’ Championship Series, one of the most mainstream leagues in esports, is at a five-year low, according to data aggregated by Esports Charts. As viewership declined, broadcast and streaming deals became less lucrative or less common for US and European esports leagues.
- uhuruity 4y agoI don't know what the viewership numbers are, but as someone who watches a lot of LoL across all the major leagues (LCS in North America, LEC in Europe, LCK in Korea, LPL in China), I wouldn't be surprised if LCS viewership falls even while others do well. The standard of play in LCS is far worse than the other three regions, and there are no redeeming features either (LEC is worse than LCK/LPL but they do a lot of fun things with their production that makes it entertaining to watch overall).
- NoPicklez 4y agoThis is why websites like Twitch do well, they're game agnostic which will be the same for esports, the same way that the success of a movie is defined through its viewers. Esports will grow, but not because of one game, but because of many games coming and going in popularity over time.
- jjcm 4y ago> Esports are here to stay but the dreams of any videogame being able to catch and retain viewers for decades is just never going to be there. It's true that the userbase is often the choke point, but don't discount the longevity of these games. The three largest games by tournament size (League, CS, Dota) are on average 18 years old at this point. Both CS and Dota are past the 2 decade point, and CS is still growing: https://steamcharts.com/app/730#All https://steamcharts.com/app/730#All
- epolanski 4y agoAnd who of the hundreds of thousands that watched the CPL or ESWC CS competition on hltv in 2002 is still following csgo esports without playing the game? That's what I mean by retaining viewers for a long time.
- russelg 4y agoI think the long-standing MOBAs such as League and Dota have a unique advantage in this area. Many people grow frustrated with playing the game themselves, with most games being ruined by uncooperative crybabies or just straight trolls. Losing at 10 minutes but being held hostage in the game regardless is incredibly frustrating. You don't have these issues while watching someone else play, or watching a tournament. So its become quite common to continue watching these games even if you barely ever play them yourself.
- P5fRxh5kUvp2th 4y agoAs one of those players, I stopped when I finally realized ranked in league wasn't actually competitive because Riot had no interest in making it competitive. And because I no longer play I have, over time, completely lost interest in watching it. Part of that is that the OG players I used to watch have pretty much all retired save a select few. I'm sure there are people that continue watching it long-term after they quit playing, but I doubt it's a hugely large percentage. The only exception is going to be championship games, where I'll still sometimes tune in (especially worlds) until NA falls out and then I don't even bother watching the actual final game.