3 ms·
I hope this will lead to brands that just shut up and sell stuff. And do not attempt to signal anything in anyway.
by Ekaros 4y ago
I hope this will lead to brands that just shut up and sell stuff. And do not attempt to signal anything in anyway.
- HPMOR 4y agoI believe consumption patterns in general will reflect political leaning. For example a college kid probably travels to and from home requiring airline tickets, Uber, etc. Whereas a rural kid might have need of satellite wifi and diesel vehicles for long haul trips. These are inherently different consumption patterns that require brands to pick sides for their respective consumers. If anything the trend of companies choosing political sides will become exacerbated by consumers.
- hakfoo 4y agoThat applies to an extent, but there's plenty of products that sell across the political spectrum. I might not buy a work truck, and my neighbour might not be interested in fiber internet, but we both buy hamburgers. I could see this break two ways: 1. Investors start handing companies their asses for throwing away potential customers. 2. There's just enough extra margin available in segmenting their customers that politically flaired brands end up being successful. Obviously that gets toxic fast if it works, but will it actually pan out? I can see brands trying to be "big fish in a small pond" by being the "anti-woke" (or "woke") choice, but will people really pay a premium for it? I could see choosing Lyft over Uber, or ordering a mainboard from B&H instead of Amazon, when the price is more or less the same, but I'm not sure I can justify paying 20% more.
- badRNG 4y agoIt is often a bad bet in the long run to associate your brand with specific conservative causes. Conservatism, and right-reactionary thought, often exists as a critique or skepticism of the ideology and programs that progressives and leftists wish to enact. Sometimes the criticism is warranted, and this skepticism is an important part of civil discourse. Inevitably however, sometimes progressive causes will win and overcome their detractors. If you tied your brand to a critique of gay marriage, the Civil Rights Movement, or women's suffrage, your brand would face far more damage than being critical of rightist causes.
- mullingitover 4y agoThe big failure of the conservatives in the present day is their grouping into a single political party and the purging of anything progressive from that party. The problem with this is that progress usually wins, and conservatives again and again end up on the wrong side of history. History in this area is like the Harlem Globetrotters against the Washington Generals. At one point both parties had conservative and progressive wings. So now, by lumping everyone against progress into one party, they're firmly consolidated as the regressive lost-causers, and everyone who aligns with them ends up getting that label.
- mindslight 4y agoActually, I would say that the Democratic party is now the main home of conservatives. The Republican party has hitched themselves to the conservative stances from 30+ years ago. They aren't seeking preservation of the status quo, but rather the disruption of it. This is decidedly not conservative, and it's unfortunate that people continue to use 'Republican' and 'conservative' as synonyms when they are not. It's a similar mistaken framework to the complaints that large companies have embraced "progressive causes". Rather, those causes were progressive decades ago, but have since become accepted by and part of mainstream society. Which is exactly why large profit-maximizing companies use them for their marketing. Perhaps this past-shifted perspective ties in to the general contemporary homogenization of what used to be historical periods of pop culture.
- xedrac 4y agoI feel the same way about technical projects that force political/social agendas to be part of the project. Why can't we just keep things focused on technical stuff, and leave the virtue signaling out of it? The world has become a toxic place, no matter what your views are.
- beams_of_light 4y agoElon is the brand. They don’t advertise. If he’s really as smart as most people think he is, then all of this pandering to right wing politics is just a way to sway people who wouldn’t otherwise buy an electric car into buying one because they side with him politically. At least, it’s possible that’s the long game. It’s also highly possible he’s a narcissist and doesn’t care or have enough self control to stop harming Tesla with his antics. Ultimately, I don’t think right wingers are going to buy Teslas en masse because he “freed the bird”.
- fknorangesite 4y ago> And do not attempt to signal anything in anyway. Implicitly supporting the status quo is also a signal.
- thaneross 4y agoNeutrality does not "implicitly support the status quo" unless you believe the status quo is stable or exists in a local maxima. That clearly isn't true however because the status quo is dramatically different today than it was historically, and I wouldn't attribute activism for the bulk of those changes.