3 ms·
China indeed has an oppressive government, but it's not much like the impression you appear to be getting. Many Chinese are very happy with the system, especial
by jfengel 4y ago
China indeed has an oppressive government, but it's not much like the impression you appear to be getting. Many Chinese are very happy with the system, especially given how poor they were not long ago. China has lifted many millions out of poverty, in a very capitalist way.
They don't have many freedoms you take for granted, like voting, but it turns out to be less fundamental than you imagine. If the regime does not oppress them they don't feel the need to change it.
Obviously there are horror stories, magnified by their control over media. But we Americans have our own horror stories, and worse, many ignore them despite the fact that they are quite well known.
China isn't the hell scape as it's often presented. Which actually makes them more dangerous to Western ideals and values.
- e40 4y agoI agree, but the fly in the ointment here is the behavior of CCP wrt to covid lockdowns. That is making the lives of people there much worse. The good news, it seems the government is finally easing the policies, but it is early days on that.
- ipaddr 4y agoThey are being oppressed in a variety off ways each day that they are and are not aware of. Are people on China happier today because of additional wealth (but also additional pollution / increased loneliness)? Surveying them would be like asking citizens in cold war era Russia if they are happier than before and if they are lacking what the west has. They might reject it but they don't fully understand what they are missing.
- sidibe 4y agoThe reason China was able to develop so quickly after Deng Xiaoping was because they didn't do it earlier. The same rapid development happened in Taiwan, HK, and SK decades earlier because they didn't have to deal with Mao and his sycophants who kept throwing wrenches in the gears. Xi is more in the Mao class of leaders than his predecessors (both are uneducated populists who are not interested in developing strong institutions). I wouldn't count on China continuing to do well until they find a way to smoothly and consistently replace non-totalitarian leaders, which I think is related to free press/speech, as leaders want to set precedents so they aren't persecuted by the next guy.