3 ms·
Also a rural person living next to working farms, I'll just say this: Many things make more sense when you realize that farming is industry (and a workplace) an
by cmrdporcupine 4y ago
Also a rural person living next to working farms, I'll just say this: Many things make more sense when you realize that farming is industry (and a workplace) and has to be managed by the state as an industry with similar regulatory, health & safety and environmental concerns.
The bucolic picture of farms as family homes combined with a flock of peaceful sheep, a family dog, and some silly chickens and a hard working sole proprietor is really hobby farming and a primarily aesthetic thing at this point.
The real world of the countryside is one of industrial extraction/production, but where somehow homes are mixed in. Not saying this is ideal, but a lot of the conflict that arises is around the disjoint nature of our traditional view of "the countryside" vs what it's actually "for" (industrial farming + future suburban development + mixed residential uses)
- mistrial9 4y ago> really hobby farming and a primarily aesthetic thing no one can say that with certainty, you use the same rhetorical trick as people in politics when "progress is inevitable" bad news for everyone -- the industrial world has spoiled the nest.
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoI never said I liked it. It's not a "rhetorical trick" because I'm not advocating anything. Just simply describing what is out there. Myself, I am generally what you'd call anti-capitalist by convictions; but I've lived rural most of my life. And never in the actual "industry" that dominates the rural world, just... next to it.
- giraffe_lady 4y agoBelieve it or not governments have a pretty strong interest in knowing this sort of thing so the data is certainly there! It's been a while since I looked at it and it depends on what you consider a "small farm" to be. But when I last checked a few years ago, farms employing little or no outside laborers were a small minority. And more significantly here, those households were both above median household income and half or more of their income came from outside-the-farm sources. You can twiddle with it if you want but to me that seems like a pretty reasonable definition of "hobby farming." Which is not a value judgement per se. Not being strictly dependent on farm income allows these farmers to pursue traditional or sustainability-focused practices that may not be economically viable otherwise. But just be clear-eyed about it. The ideal of the small, self-sufficient, productive and profitable family farm is just that, an ideal and to a large extent a myth. In a very serious way it's not how things ever worked and, maybe unfortunately maybe not, it's not how they're going to now either.
- mistrial9 4y ago> Believe it or not governments have a pretty strong interest in knowing this sort of thing so the data is certainly there! professional researcher speaking -- your elementary-school approach is for someone else > I last checked a few years ago, farms employing little or no outside laborers were a small minority. news to no one > You can twiddle with it if you want but to me that seems like a pretty reasonable definition of "hobby farming." dismissal with faint praise, check > The ideal of the small, self-sufficient, productive and profitable family farm is just that, an ideal and to a large extent a myth. you now speak for all people in all ages, (edit) confident? If you want to show up as a voice of reason, you will need to show some better understanding of economic contexts over the last thousand years, not the latest NYTimes
- giraffe_lady 4y agoLotta shit talk but not a single refutation of any of these points. I said I'm not an expert and you said you are, care to show us?
- mistrial9 4y agoamong attorneys, this is a "burden of proof" moment. So now the burden of proof is on me, to show the history of farming economics. hmm I will offer this -- economics as a science was invented to explain food trade, not the other way around! Food trade is the basis of empires, armies and abundance.. speaking of which.. while "family farming is a myth" the violence of armed warfare, its destruction and death, is not a "myth" .. maybe those humans who chose to wage war might have literally killed off the ones who attempted to wage "family farms"? History is written by the winners so, "family farms" are a myth while War gets daily headlines and new fresh billions in weapons and monetization ? The burden of proof to refute that "family farming is a myth" in the face of daily war news in a place that is renown for fertile soils? rural Mississippi might be part of this discussion, but so are the plains of Canada, and Argentina, and Eastern Europe. I have no chance of accurately describing histories in South East Asia, big parts of Africa or South Asian subcontinent.. but those people have "family farms" right now? let's agree to set aside the personal indignations -- this topic is massive and I suggest, not at all solved.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- engineer_22 4y ago>The bucolic picture of farms as family homes combined with a flock of peaceful sheep, a family dog, and some silly chickens and a hard working sole proprietor is really hobby farming and a primarily aesthetic thing at this point. I think the truth of your statement depends on local environment. In the area I grew up there are still small families running dairy operations. They have admitted it's getting harder to keep the farm competitive. I agree farming has consolidated considerably since the mid 20th century. It's consolidation by design - the federal gov't has pursued policies to encourage consolidation. From a cost efficiency standpoint, it makes a lot of sense, but it has cost a lot of people their livelihoods. The joke is, to make a million dollars in farming, start with two million.